I'll admit to being a fan of Zimmer's work, and I haven't heard this score yet, but the review to me seems to be about as fair as can be considering how controversial Zimmer is. Four stars is still a very good rating, and the points Christian made were all perfectly valid.
> No surprise, of course.
> The writer goes out his way to find a contradiction in Zimmer's statements
> and uses that as a basis to dismiss what's obviously a 5 star soundtrack.