Posted by: G.K. Date: Wednesday, July 16, 2008, at 1:39 p.m. IP Address: pd9e5bdb7.dip.t-dialin.net
In Response to:
To all Zimmer fanboys...(NL)
Is it just me or is the "happy jolly theme" comment from Zimmer really the outright dumbest and insulting thing he's ever said?
For me, that's such a deeply revealing quote ... I've suspected it a long time ago, but never had any hard evidence, but that quote is the last piece of the puzzle: Zimmer has no idea about the needs of a specific film, and, as Christian put it nicely, he has no intuition whatsoever as a film composer in the traditional sense.
I don't care what other people say, if you can't see the painful one- dimensionality in his latest works, and those Batman films especially, then nobody on earth is able to save you.
Christian put it perfectly, Zimmer has put his own preferences and "ideas" over the good of the films he scores a long time ago. His ideas may be unique and easily recognisable, but they say nothing, zero, about any given character. And he's painting with such ridiculously broad and inflexible block strokes that he takes forever to make a point about those characters; I suspect that's why his suites usually ramble on for way over five minutes without any greater impact - no wonder when the basic material has no characteristic substance to begin with.
It's like he's sitting in front of any given movie, temp- tracks it with The Rock or Gladiator, and says "Hey, that works somehow, let me see how I can disguise it!"
I didn't think I heard correctly when I heard Chevaliers De Sangreal (my favourite Zimmer cue of the last eight years by the way) in "A Dark Knight".
I'll be so glad when he takes several years off and works with orchestras for a while, maybe then he will find an appreciation of that environment. Although I wouldn't be surprised to read comments by him soon, saying such a traditional ensemble was boring.
And yes, the woodwinds ... did Nolan, like Bruckheimer, also tell him he didn't want such girly- man instruments?