You're absolutely right. I often wonder about the reviewers' competence too. Hollow Man is a masterpiece (as was Star Trek Nemesis), and it takes a nuanced understanding of motivic construction, thematic development, and most importantly, dramatic subtext, to appreciate what Goldsmith does so masterfully. Unfortunately, Mr. Clemmensen often (not always) critiques Goldsmith's work unfairly while lauding John William's overrated scores profusely.