Posted by: Chris Gouvelos <Send E-Mail> Date: Tuesday, July 19, 2011, at 2:18 p.m. IP Address: athedsl-307034.home.otenet.gr
In Response to:
Academy Gone Wrong?(Trevor)
> Can someone please tell me how this score beat out Zimmer, Powell, and
> Desplat? Especially Powell's score. What is going on here? How did Gustavo
> Santaolalla's thirteen minutes of atmospheric score beat both John
> Williams's phenomenal scores?
> I honestly have no idea. Can someone give me some incite?
I've been one of the stronger supporters of TSN score since day 1. But i'll be totally honest: Zimmer and Powell didn't seserve the Oscar, Desplat deserved it. But it's just that the Academy has always been searching something extravagant to award in this category. So even if we spend a few more months on a meaningless debate whether TSN deserved the Oscar or "Frisbee", it's better to go with it and move on.
What worries me about the ranking on this site is that most of the users and some admins are willing to "crucify" decent artists when they are not on their best form, but on the other hand they discover some mediocre composers and they turn them to gods...