Posted by: Nate Date: Monday, October 11, 2004, at 2:05 p.m. IP Address: pcp06586504pcs.nrockv01.md.comcast.net
In Response to:
Re: Goldsmith's work was weak.(MB)
> They aren't childish tantrums and in my un-proffesional review at the
> start of this year, which can be found on the comments page. I found that
> Tyler had used music he had composed for all of his other scores. This is
> my opinion of course but as a fan of both composers, Goldsmith's score
> really is the superior of the two but Goldsmith is also guilty of re-using
> his own well walked on teritory, he just happened to re-use it more
> successfully to at least make it sound brand new again. That doesn't mean
> I'm dissing Tyler, I'm not. It just means I connected to Goldsmith's score
> in particular.
That's understandable as my criticisms were directed at you. I was speaking of some of the fans on the online petitions and Goldsmith websites who behaved ratherly obnoxious. I too like both composers and plan to own both scores.