| |
 | |
|
| | Comments about: Willow (James Horner) |
Re: Schumann music and folk song in Willow> The fact that Willow's Theme is derived from Robert Schumann's 3rd
> Symphony "Rhenish" is now old news. I recently bouhght the
> Schumann and upon hearing it my initial feeling was that - although it is
> admittedly very similar - Willow is not totally identical to it as the
> Schumann does not contain the four-note statement which opens the Willow
> Theme. This took me by surprise because I had read in various forums that
> Willow is an exact duplicate of this Schumann music. I was also somewhat
> surprised by the different "feel" of it. Did anyone else feel
> the same way?
> I have also read somewhere that Elora Danan's Theme is a
> "note-by-note" copy of an old Bulgarian harvest song. However,
> Wikipedia claims that it resembles the "Redemption Motif" in
> Wagner's "Ring". Does anyone have an opinion on this??
Isn't it just the first five notes of the Schumann Symphony? It's not like it's the whole symphony copied.
| | Comments in this Thread:
( Expand ) |
|
|
 |
|