Filmtracks Recommends:
Buy it... if you're among the Danny Elfman fans who have waited years to hear the composer write a jovial score for the countryside with no overbearingly melodramatic strings attached. Avoid it... if you prefer your Elfman scores in the children's fantasy genre to be an emotional punch in the face. Filmtracks Editorial Review:
Charlotte's Web: (Danny Elfman) The first live action adaptation of E.B. White's classic children's story is a who's who of vocal talents. An all-star cast accompanies digitally rendered barnyard animals and real-life humans to tell the beloved story of Wilbur the pig, the runt destined for slaughter if not for the valiant efforts of his friends in the animal world. Along with Charlotte the spider, a host of comical beasts attract enough attention to the pig to gain it the notoriety necessary to save its life. The story is one of sacrifice, however, as the spider's plan comes at the end of her life. There is no doubt that Charlotte's Web is an old favorite, and its live action debut seems a project perfect for composer Danny Elfman. The Elfman of the early 1990's, that is. In those days, the eccentric composer took many such stories to heart, writing music often considered to be the best and most heartwarming of his career. As his Oscar-nominated career has matured, though, the days of his innocent fairy tale writing have become a seemingly distant memory. In 2006, his career even expanded to include his first concert piece, "Serenada Schizophrana," and while it gave Elfman the opportunity to return to his zany roots, it hardly resurrected the glory of his fans' favorites from his early fantasy era. To their pleasure, Charlotte's Web will instead represent that return, though understandably not in the usual layers of melancholy brooding that also came with those early scores. Even in its sad scene near the end, the film never features that truly delicious Elfman fantasy flavor. Instead, Charlotte's Web is a unequivocally upbeat score with jovial rhythms and soothingly harmonic ideas. It's the culmination of all the small happy moments you heard in Black Beauty, Sommersby, Edward Scissorhands, and The Nightmare Before Christmas, though owing the most to the first two. The elegance of the string textures in Black Beauty is merged with the instrumentation of Sommersby, as well as the trademark light choir in the high ranks, to create Elfman's most undoubtedly upbeat score. So upbeat, in fact, that it resembles the kind of sugary music that John Debney would write for the story, if not for the little Elfmanisms that prevail throughout the instrumentation and constructs. In some of the more parody-oriented comedy cues, Elfman does indeed present a sound strangely equivalent to Debney's, including the frenetic "The Dump." But unlike Debney, Elfman substitutes the normal Americana sound for the setting with his own quirky vision of the barnyard. His jumpy, nervous rhythms, with wildness in the percussion section, serve as the backdrop for the opening titles. Country-swaying strings, a bass-heavy acoustic guitar, fluttering woodwinds, and an occasionally rambling piano are all lightly rendered throughout the score, with each element mixed at the front for easy identification. The small-town feel is updated from Sommersby with the more contemporary guitar, though the occasional soaring woodwind solos place the score back in the Rachel Portman hillsides of yesteryear. The sum of all the instruments is an almost timeless setting, a wise move for Elfman, though if Charlotte's Web has a weakness, it resides in its rather anonymous personality outside of its inherent rhythmic characteristics. The themes won't be easy for casual listeners to grasp, as they are often performed by only fragments of the ensemble and move at a brisk pace. Thus, you don't leave Charlotte's Web with a tune in mind, but rather an instant improvement of mood caused by Elfman's rare saturation of hopeless optimism in the work. That optimism, headlined understandably by "The Word Spreads," is such a refreshing sound to come from Elfman that you can finally enjoy his bouncy countryside writing without any strings attached. For you die-hard Elfman fans, you'll even hear a few moments of that enchanting high choir in full glory. As Charlotte gets things rolling in "The Plan Begins," Elfman places the choir at the forefront with a magical performance marking the first such uninhibited use since The Family Man. A brief reprise of the choral role would resurface in "Radiant" and "Wilbur's Homecoming," providing just enough magic spark from the wave of Elfman's wand to supply the story's equally imaginative aspects. Structurally, the score is short and sweet, with the lengthy "Wilbur's Homecoming" serving as somewhat of a concert piece covering all the major thematic ideas and opening with some of that choral majesty. The Sarah McLachlan song at the end contains no inspiration from Elfman's score and is the kind of sappy, simplistic light rock piece that will appeal to teenage girls and may perhaps gain some Oscar votes for McLachlan's usual, soothing sound. Overall, Charlotte's Web is delightfully pretty and the most enjoyable Elfman score in a while. But don't expect too much from it, for its personality comes from more humble and playful roots. It's a score that's good to hear from Elfman, regardless of its relative lack of flair. **** Track Listings:
Total Time: 47:09
All artwork and sound clips from Charlotte's Web are Copyright © 2006, Sony Classical. The reviews and notes contained on the filmtracks.com site may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without the prior written authority of Filmtracks Publications. Audio clips can be heard using RealPlayer but cannot be redistributed without the label's expressed written consent. Page created 12/9/06, updated 12/10/06. Review Version 4.1 - PHP (Filmtracks Publications). Copyright © 2006-2013, Christian Clemmensen. All rights reserved. |
