After a somewhat disappointing year of film score quality
in 2023, the selection of top-notch music improved significantly
in 2024. Scores mostly from the West dominated in the animation, drama,
and fantasy genres, with soundtracks for musicals and those aimed at
children faring surprisingly well. Because of the impressive collection
of scores in the year, Filmtracks exercises its occasional practice of
nominating an additional entry for its top award.
Although theatrical releases have been steadily returning to their
pre-pandemic quantities, a substantial portion of the year's best music
resulted from projects aimed mainly at small screens. The immensity of
Bear McCreary's continued involvement with second season of the
television series "The Lord of the Rings: The Rings of Power" draws
the most attention, but primarily streaming films were a source of
continued mastery in film music, especially for Netflix offerings.
The nominees at Filmtracks this year are multi-generational, featuring
composers popular since the 1980's and those just asserting their
positions atop their field in the 2020's. Leading the field with four
nominations each are Kris Bowers and John Powell, with Amelia Warner
earning three. Receiving two nominations each are Lorne Balfe, Roc Chen,
Alan Menken, Alan Silvestri, and Benjamin Wallfisch. Nine others are
represented, and this year represents the first nominations for seven
composers, including some exciting new names.
The robust quality of the year compelled six nominees
and a wider selection of honorable mentions. The five-star scores from
2024 span a variety of compositional styles, though each work had the
distinction of adding immense presence in their pictures. The dark horse
winner this year is Warner's
Young Woman and the Sea, which
played a pivotal role for its film's story and stands to become one of
the best respected, inspirational sports scores in the genre's history.
Though it is certainly not the most complicated of compositions,
Warner's score, with some production assistance from Balfe, is
undeniably powerful reinforcement for the message of the movie.
Vying for second place and worthy winners in any weaker year were
Bowers' extraordinarily accomplished
The Wild Robot and Powell's
adaptation of Schwartz's themes for the musical
Wicked, which is
brilliantly reverent and expansive in scope. The three following scores
are led by Silvestri's heartbreakingly lovely
Here, Powell's
affably engaging
That Christmas, and Menken's nostalgic
Spellbound, which features an impressive slate of new songs. The
runner-up this year is Andrew Lockington's largely forgotten
Atlas, a score with a fantastic finish and far more intelligence
throughout than one might think on first pass.
The rest of the top ten include Michael Giacchino's charmingly sensitive
IF, Chen's diversely unpredictable but at times gorgeous
Into
the Mortal World, and David Fleming's superbly bookended
Damsel. Additional honorable mentions go to John Debney's broadly
painted
Horizon: An American Saga, Chapter 1, Raphaël
Dargent's rambunctious
Why Dinosaurs?, and Balfe and team's
highly amusing
Argylle. A special shout-out this year also goes
to a pair of notably pretty scores for short films: Ivan Palomares'
Carmen and the Wooden Spoon and Romain Paillot's
The Dove
Secret.
| Alien: Romulus (Benjamin Wallfisch) | "Raine" |
| Argylle (Lorne Balfe/Various) | "Argylle's Theme" |
| Atlas (Andrew Lockington) | "Atlas Main Titles" |
| Damsel (David Fleming) | "Elodie's Maze" |
| The Dove Secret (Romain Paillot) | "Escaping the Covent" |
| Here (Alan Silvestri) | "This is Here" |
| Horizon: An American Saga, Chapter 1 (John Debney) | "Horizon Montage Begins/Closing Survey" |
| Into the Mortal World (Roc Chen) | "Truth of Mother" |
| Kensuke's Kingdom (Stuart Hancock) | "Kensuke's Kingdom (End Titles Suite)" |
| Kingdom of the Planet of the Apes (John Paesano) | "We Will Rebuild" |
| Our Living World (Pinar Toprak) | "Life Blood" |
| Spellbound (Alan Menken) | "Journey Suite" |
| That Christmas (John Powell) | "Searching and Finding" |
| White Bird (Thomas Newman) | "White Bird" |
| Wicked (John Powell/Stephen Schwartz) | "Train to Emerald City" |
| The Wild Robot (Kris Bowers) | "I Could Use a Boost" |
| The Wild Robot (Kris Bowers) | "You Don't Have To" |
| Why Dinosaurs? (Raphaël Dargent) | "Why Dinosaurs?" |
| Young Woman and the Sea (Amelia Warner) | "Trudy Escapes" |
| Young Woman and the Sea (Amelia Warner) | "Gertrude Ederle's Legacy" |
The "Top Film Cue" category is restricted to twenty
nominees, with the number of runner-ups capped at ten and honorable
mentions limited to twenty. No single score can receive more than two
nominations in this field, and two of the year's "Top Film Score"
entries were awarded multiple top cue nods. The top ten scores of the
year produced twelve of the nominations for "Top Film Cue," showing
those scores' consolidated strength atop the field.
Only three of the twenty nominated cues were truly competitive for the
award, and for much of the year, the assumed winner was to be the
incredibly emotional "I Could Use a Boost" from Bowers'
The Wild
Robot, followed by the sentimental historical powerhouse "This is
Here" from Silvestri's
Here. In the end, though, the resoundingly
satisfying, melodic "Atlas Main Titles" from Lockington's
Atlas
raises all the best memories from 2012's top score,
Journey 2: The
Mysterious Island, and exemplifies the definition of an earned
payoff cue.
In the tier just behind these fantastic cues is Warner's infectious free
spirit theme in "Trudy Escapes" from
Young Woman and the Sea,
Fleming's culminating thematic force in "Elodie's Maze" from
Damsel, Balfe and team's equivalent, excellent summary in
"Argylle's Theme" from
Argylle, and Pinar Toprak's rousing
highlight, "Life Blood," from the documentary
Our Living World.
Not far behind is the sustained excellence of "Searching and Finding"
from Powell's
That Christmas and Debney's conclusive climax,
"Horizon Montage Begins/Closing Survey," in
Horizon: An American
Saga, Chapter 1.
Among the additional cues from the year's top scores is Bowers' great
closing integration with a song from
The Wild Robot in "You Don't
Have To," Powell's extremely intelligent adaptations in "Train to
Emerald City" from
Wicked, Warner's perfectly respectful epilogue
in "Gertrude Ederle's Legacy" in
Young Woman and the Sea, and
Menken's spirited action romp in "Journey Suite" from
Spellbound.
While there are several beautiful highlights in the lyrical portions of
Chen's
Into the Mortal World, topping the list is the ethnic
tenderness and grace of "Truth of Mother."
Rounding out the nominees for 2024 are Stuart Hancock's epic fantasy
themes in "Kensuke's Kingdom (End Titles Suite)" from
Kensuke's
Kingdom, Thomas Newman's familiar but still soothingly delightful
style of "White Bird" from
White Bird, and Paillot's extremely
wholesome "Escaping the Covent" from
The Dove Secret. The group
is completed by Dargent's loving tribute to yesteryear in "Why
Dinosaurs?" from
Why Dinosaurs?, Wallfisch's massive choral
catharsis in "Raine" from
Alien: Romulus, and John Paesano's
propulsive and determined climax in "We Will Rebuild" from
Kingdom of
the Planet of the Apes.
The list of runner-ups this year is extremely diverse but features a few
additional cues from scores already nominated, including the immensely
powerful "Transformations" from Powell's
Wicked, the softly
wonderful melodicism in the same composer's "Shop Romance" from
That
Christmas, and the tremendous respect of "End of Massacre" from
Debney's
Horizon: An American Saga, Chapter 1. Also from Powell
is the engagingly rousing "Red Carpet" from
Thelma the Unicorn.
Not far behind that style is Henry Jackman's rockingly redemptive
"Saving Christmas" from
Red One.
Completing the runner-up group is the delicately pretty and eventually
resounding "Il Était une Fois..." from Laurent Perez Del Mar's
Bambi: A Life in the Woods, Jeymes Samuel's thought-provoking
reverence in "They Always Take Our Babies" from
The Book of
Clarence, Dario Marianelli's nearly hypnotizing beauty of "In the
Fabric of the Universe" from
Ghostbusters: Frozen Empire, Geoff
Zanelli's action and fantasy heights in "I Hope This Helps" from
Man
and Witch: The Dance of a Thousand Steps, and Dave Metzger's
monumental blend of old and new in the closing "A Story of a Great King"
from
Mufasa: The Lion King.
In contention but eliminated earlier in the selection process were the
following cues receiving honorable mentions (listed alphabetically by
film title): Perez Del Mar's impressive action burst in "La Chasse" from
Bambi: A Life in the Woods, Fernando Velázquez's
enthusiastic Western introduction in "The Arrival" from
Buffalo
Kids, Palomares' charming, creatively percussive "Carmen and the
Wooden Spoon" from
Carmen and the Wooden Spoon, Fleming's
incredibly deceptive romantic fantasy in "Ever After" from
Damsel, Balfe and Kevin Riepl's restrained but engrossing
"Farewell" from
Decoded, and Giuliano Taviani and Carmelo
Travia's stoic but elegant melodicism in "Diamanti Theme (Extended)"
from
Diamanti.
Also contending but eliminated were Silvestri's summary of themes in
"End Credits" from
Here, Marco Beltrami's stylishly suspenseful
action in "Graveyard Shootout" from
The Killer, Wallfisch and
team's guilty pleasure of a main theme in "Kraven the Hunter" from
Kraven the Hunter, Chris Benstead's guitar and vocal-driven force
of "Absconding With the Duquesa" from
The Ministry of Ungentlemanly
Warfare, Sung-Woo Cho's classically restrained but alluring "A
Normal Family" from
A Normal Family, Robert Gulya's increasingly
inspirational "You are the Spark" from
Now or Never!,
Marianelli's ambitiously layered "Chased" from
Paddington in
Peru, and John Coda's thrillingly propulsive, bass-dwelling anthem
in "Agent T-10" from
Reagan.
Completing the list of honorable mentions are Lauri Porra's elegantly
swaying rhythmic tonalities in "Driftwood II" from
Stormskerry
Maja, Diego Navarro's heroic flourish in "Theme From SuperKlaus (End
Credits)" from
SuperKlaus, Powell's striking introductory action
and character-building in "Meet Our Heroes" from
That Christmas
and his demonically romping "Monkey Mayhem" from
Wicked, Robin
Hoffmann's cheerful swashbuckling tones in "End Credits" from
Treasure Tracker, and Anne-Kathrin Dern's top mystical fantasy
mode, albeit with a low budget, in "Carag" from
Woodwalkers.