> Illogical is rate this score "as heard in the movie" without
> Have been seen the movie.
Clemmensen got rid of "as heard in film" ratings three years ago. Now he rates
the score itself ("as written for film") and the album presentation ("as heard on album"). It's really a simple concept.
Aside from that, the movie is so faithful to the book that cross-conclusions are easy to make about the score's merit for the story.
> And of course Clemmensen has rated zimmer scores with 4 stars, but he
> attack with personal arguments his scores.
That's because he doesn't agree with Zimmer's methods. Many people don't, these days.
> you can't rate a score with 4 stars as head in the cd and say it's simple.
I'm not even going to try to address that moronic statement.