|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Menu Options ▼
"and it will cause you to gain an enormous amount of respect for Goldenthal's talents"
|
|
"and it will cause you to gain an enormous amount of respect for Goldenthal's talents" |
Tuesday, December 10, 2002 (9:36 a.m.) |
|---|
I have the feeling that you are speaking also for yourself here, Christian.
Very well, this review was the last straw for me to finally get this score. I haven't seen the film as of yet (Germany rules!  ), but I definitely will.
What are the chances to see Goldenthal nominated for his third Oscar here, folks? Although I hope very much for it, I don't expect it to happen...
CK
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
Re: "and it will cause you to gain an enormous amount of respect for Goldenthal's tale |
Tuesday, December 10, 2002 (2:20 p.m.) |
|---|
> I have the feeling that you are speaking also for yourself here,
> Christian.
> Very well, this review was the last straw for me to finally get this
> score. I haven't seen the film as of yet (Germany rules! ), but I
> definitely will.
> What are the chances to see Goldenthal nominated for his third Oscar here,
> folks? Although I hope very much for it, I don't expect it to happen...
Well, I have to say that, speaking as someone who owns all of Goldenthal's albums (and loves the vast majority) I think Frida is the least remarkable. Yes it has some pleasant moments but on the whole it's quite mediocre in my opinion and I can't think of a Goldenthal score I would recommend less as a starting point in exploring his incredible output.
James
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
Chris
(h68-147-164-93.cg.shawcable.net)
In Response to:
↑ Southall
Responses to this Comment:
↓ Mark
↓ TimT |
|
Re: "and it will cause you to gain an enormous amount of respect for Goldenthal's tale |
Tuesday, December 10, 2002 (5:37 p.m.) |
|---|
> Well, I have to say that, speaking as someone who owns all of Goldenthal's
> albums (and loves the vast majority) I think Frida is the least
> remarkable. Yes it has some pleasant moments but on the whole it's quite
> mediocre in my opinion and I can't think of a Goldenthal score I would
> recommend less as a starting point in exploring his incredible output.
> James
In that case, what albums do you recommend?? I have very little experience of his work and would like to see what the big fuss is about Goldenthal.
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
I recommand ALIEN 3 |
Wednesday, December 11, 2002 (5:02 a.m.) |
|---|
I will recommand "A L I E N 3"
BUT BE CAREFULL - You will like it or you will hate it - It depends of your taste for music that breaks the rule and sounds more like an experiment than theme-music
I like alien 3 - but I have to admit that it has been time since I last heard "Alien 3"
Mark from Denmark
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
Re: "and it will cause you to gain an enormous amount of respect for Goldenthal's tale |
Wednesday, December 11, 2002 (12:31 p.m.) |
|---|
> In that case, what albums do you recommend?? I have very little experience
> of his work and would like to see what the big fuss is about Goldenthal.
I would reccomend, Michael Collins and Titus. I became convenced after hearing those two scores. But it was mainly Titus.
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
Re: "and it will cause you to gain an enormous amount of respect for Goldenthal's tale |
Wednesday, December 11, 2002 (12:28 p.m.) |
|---|
> Well, I have to say that, speaking as someone who owns all of Goldenthal's
> albums (and loves the vast majority) I think Frida is the least
> remarkable. Yes it has some pleasant moments but on the whole it's quite
> mediocre in my opinion and I can't think of a Goldenthal score I would
> recommend less as a starting point in exploring his incredible output.
> James
I think I understand, what you mean. You are comparing this score to his own previous works. When you should be comparing it to traditional Mexican music, because that exactly what Goldenthal was doing.
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
Re: "and it will cause you to gain an enormous amount of respect for Goldenthal's tale |
Thursday, December 12, 2002 (6:30 a.m.) |
|---|
Don't forget that Goldenthal wrote Final Fantasy and he wasn't nominated et all. But I hope the best.
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
|
|
