I stumbled on to Filmtracks review of John William's score for HP1 while idly surfing the web to see Fan reaction to the music of recent HP films. Of course everyone is entitled to their options, but gad, I've never read a review with which I DISAGREED more.

Whoever wrote the FT review should have his 'reviewer-credentials' examined. This score (for HP1) will likely go down as one of JW's most memorable and appropriate theme music (next to SW). In contrast to Filmtrack review, I thought JW captured beautifully the unique 'magical' nature of JK's story.

Sadly the recent HP movies (4 & 5) have been progressively worse in everything from directing to following book plot lines, scripting and including music scores. HP5 was pathetic in that regard. I know a lot of folks who agree.

Please - bring back Chris Colubus, Steve Kloves and John Williams. Save us from inept reviews like that from Filmtracks.

> I stumbled on to Filmtracks review of John William's score for HP1 while
> idly surfing the web to see Fan reaction to the music of recent HP films.
> Of course everyone is entitled to their options, but gad, I've never read
> a review with which I DISAGREED more.

> Whoever wrote the FT review should have his 'reviewer-credentials'
> examined. This score (for HP1) will likely go down as one of JW's most
> memorable and appropriate theme music (next to SW). In contrast to
> Filmtrack review, I thought JW captured beautifully the unique 'magical'
> nature of JK's story.

> Sadly the recent HP movies (4 & 5) have been progressively worse in
> everything from directing to following book plot lines, scripting and
> including music scores. HP5 was pathetic in that regard. I know a lot of
> folks who agree.

> Please - bring back Chris Colubus, Steve Kloves and John Williams. Save us
> from inept reviews like that from Filmtracks.
your an idiot harry potter 4 and 5 arnt bad in fact didnt you visit the critic website the rotten tomatoes that critics rank gof a 88 % out of a 100 while ss only got 78 % and says who that a lot of the fans agree that 4 and 5 sucks thats not what i heard crtics love 4 and 5 doesnt the 88 % of gof ranking on rotton tomatoes mean anything to you and yes i understand everyone is entitled to there own oppinyen's theres no crime about it but by saying every potter fan hates hp 4 and 5 thats crazy have you cross the line or something is there proof no because you have none sorry to burst your bubble but hp 4 and 5 didnt suck check out rotten tomatoes next time to see for yourself its no joke