|
|
|
|
|
Menu Options ▼
John Williams is always overrated
The Top Gun
(host-209-214-194-15.mem.bellsouth
.net)
In Response to:
↑ Rafal Czaja
Responses to this Comment:
↓ tpigeon |
|
Re: John Williams is always overrated |
Saturday, August 17, 2002 (9:32 a.m.) |
|---|
> Why ***/red, it should be */red -- What? Apparently, you don't know good film music. This score was perfect for the film. What was wrong with it? John Williams is the King of film music.
The Top Gun
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
Re: John Williams is always overrated |
Wednesday, August 21, 2002 (12:16 p.m.) |
|---|
> let me guess Rafal, you like Hans Zimmer.
I like Zimmer too, doesn't mean that I don't like John Williams. Favoring particular composers is a folly I find in almost all filmtracks patrons. Even I tend to have a bias in favor of Jerry Goldsmith and Bruce Brougton. Now there really is nothing wrong with picking favorite composers who we seem to notice perform well on a regular basis, that's not where the folly lies. The problem can be found more so in how we often tend to exagerate that preference to a point where we feel that the composer can do no wrong and all others are inferior. That is where the folly lies.
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
Re: John Williams is always overrated |
Thursday, September 12, 2002 (6:13 a.m.) |
|---|
> I like Zimmer too, doesn't mean that I don't like John Williams. Favoring
> particular composers is a folly I find in almost all filmtracks patrons.
> Even I tend to have a bias in favor of Jerry Goldsmith and Bruce Brougton.
> Now there really is nothing wrong with picking favorite composers who we
> seem to notice perform well on a regular basis, that's not where the folly
> lies. The problem can be found more so in how we often tend to exagerate
> that preference to a point where we feel that the composer can do no wrong
> and all others are inferior. That is where the folly lies.
100% agreed. I think this is a problem especially with JW fans. I like some of his scores (Amistad, SW, Lost World, AOTC, this one), some annoys me (Harry Potter).
My favorite is Hans Zimmer, but I'm a fan of film music not a particular composer.
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
Re: Sorry, but You're wrong... |
Wednesday, October 9, 2002 (5:23 p.m.) |
|---|
...Even his not so successful scores (in artistic or commercial sense) has always this "something" that it sticks in your mind (and often in the heart) for a long time (f.e. "The Accidental Tourist"). He is a master, you want or not
Tomek
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
Re: Sorry, but You're wrong... |
Monday, October 14, 2002 (2:21 a.m.) |
|---|
> ...Even his not so successful scores (in artistic or commercial sense) has
> always this "something" that it sticks in your mind (and often
> in the heart) for a long time (f.e. "The Accidental Tourist").
> He is a master, you want or not
> Tomek
Sorry. Williams usually fails to evoke any emotions from me. He's too technical.
Pawel
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
|
|