Who do I believe?
The 'juvenile fangirls' because I have seen the movie.

Linda

> I hope that people who find this Filmtracks review notice that Clemmensen
> and other people who find the new Phantom disappointing are articulating
> themselves very well. There are many very intelligent arguments being
> presented against the merits of the new Phantom recording.

> Then there are the fangirls, who seem to cause most of the favorable
> comments about the new Phantom here, and their English is poor, their
> opinions are badly uninformed, and they all sound like they're too young
> to know what the hell they are talking about. I think many of them are the
> same uneducated two or three girls posting over and over again without the
> guts to use their real name.

> Filmtracks' ratings don't lie. And Phantom of the Opera is getting the
> pounding it deserves in the polls.

> CB