|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Menu Options ▼
I couldn't believe it ... but ...
|
|
I couldn't believe it ... but ... |
Wednesday, December 15, 2004 (2:00 p.m.) |
|---|
... it IS really as bad as Clemmie says.
I just finished it and ... well ... I returned to some points to make sure I didn't just hallucinate ...
The famous Phantom song alone ... WOW ... pathetic mixing, the organ is played REALLY bad, 80s CLAPPING SOUNDS(!) without reverberation out of the blue and I didn't even touch the vocal performance.
Shallow ... AT BEST. And I'm only speaking of Christine.
The Phantom is crap. His voice MAY be good enough for a garage-rock band, but PEOPLE, we're talking of the PHANTOM OF THE OPERA.
I have nothing against re-interpretation and I would even say the original isn't flawless ... but this indeed feels like a school play.
2 shiny silver frisbees.
Mac
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
Re: I couldn't believe it ... but ... |
Wednesday, December 15, 2004 (8:47 p.m.) |
|---|
Totally agree with you, the movie version is a disaster, why can't they just keep the same sequence as the musical, but introduce stupid mixing and rearrange fighting music (martial art don't work in phantom)
I going back to my London cast recording
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
Go, go go!!!
(bbcache-115.singnet.com.sg)
In Response to:
↑ Steven Yu |
|
Re: I couldn't believe it ... but ... |
Wednesday, August 24, 2005 (3:33 a.m.) |
|---|
> I going back to my London cast recording >
Just go, go, go go. Get lost! If you have nothing good to say, say Nothing. But please do hurry along to wherever !
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
nonofyourbusiness
(A011-0123.HSTN.dial.mcleodusa.net)
In Response to:
↑ Mac Styran
Responses to this Comment:
↓ anonymous |
|
Re: I couldn't believe it ... but ... |
Saturday, February 19, 2005 (10:42 a.m.) |
|---|
> ... it IS really as bad as Clemmie says.
> I just finished it and ... well ... I returned to some points to make sure
> I didn't just hallucinate ...
> The famous Phantom song alone ... WOW ... pathetic mixing, the organ is
> played REALLY bad, 80s CLAPPING SOUNDS(!) without reverberation out of the
> blue and I didn't even touch the vocal performance.
> Shallow ... AT BEST. And I'm only speaking of Christine.
> The Phantom is crap. His voice MAY be good enough for a garage-rock band,
> but PEOPLE, we're talking of the PHANTOM OF THE OPERA.
> I have nothing against re-interpretation and I would even say the original
> isn't flawless ... but this indeed feels like a school play.
> 2 shiny silver frisbees.
> Mac
Bogus!! Gerard Butler did a great job. He was really good for someone who's never sung before. Emmy Rossum was wonderful as well. This soundtrack was better than any of the rest.
People need to take a good look at this version.
Butler was amazing people LIVE WITH IT!!
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
anonymous
(pcp778348pcs.dalect01.va.comcast.
net)
In Response to:
↑ nonofyourbusiness |
|
Re: I couldn't believe it ... but ... |
Tuesday, May 3, 2005 (1:10 p.m.) |
|---|
> Bogus!! Gerard Butler did a great job. He was really good for someone
> who's never sung before. Emmy Rossum was wonderful as well. This
> soundtrack was better than any of the rest.
People need to take a good
> look at this version.
Butler was amazing people LIVE WITH IT!!
yeah he was great for someone who has never sung before but that's not good enough the phantom is supposed to sound like an angel (literally) and well butler just...doesn't. doesn't even come close.
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
|
|
