Boy are you ever wrong in your whole life you need to get a new job , you can't review squat!!!! I have the cd and 2 copies of the dvd incase one goes bad that is how much I LOVE it and I play the cd everyday I can. Everyone in that movie and cd were wonderful. They sang well, and to hear such a beautiful voice come out of a Scottish accent, that is I might think hard to do, was magnificent. There are thousands if not millions of Gerard Butler fans out here who think he is going to be the next Big Star so get ready. We adore him, we love him, and you can't see beyond your computer or typewriter what ever you use. Be sure and look for greater things from him but Phantom of the Opera was what hooked me on him to begin with. And to think I almost passed it by in the store. Shame on me !!!!