|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Menu Options ▼
But the scene with Yoda's Theme in it *does* make sense... [EDITED]
|
|
But the scene with Yoda's Theme in it *does* make sense... [EDITED] |
Monday, February 17, 2020 (10:36 p.m.) |
|---|
That scene is a callback to the scene in TESB when Luke was unable to lift the X-Wing out of the swamp. In TESB, that same triumphant music played when Yoda was able to lift it. Now that Luke is able to lift the X-Wing, he gets the same musical treatment. It's more of an emotional callback to a *moment* that fans will remember, rather than a specific leitmotivic character connection.
(Message edited on Monday, February 17, 2020, at 10:37 p.m.)
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
Re: But the scene with Yoda's Theme in it *does* make sense... |
Tuesday, February 18, 2020 (7:12 a.m.) |
|---|
> That scene is a callback to the scene in TESB when Luke was unable to lift
> the X-Wing out of the swamp. In TESB, that same triumphant music played
> when Yoda was able to lift it. Now that Luke is able to lift the X-Wing,
> he gets the same musical treatment. It's more of an emotional callback to
> a *moment* that fans will remember, rather than a specific leitmotivic
> character connection.
That's not what Clemmensen was talking about there. He was objecting to the Yoda theme during "Reunion" because, well, it makes no sense.
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
Re: But the scene with Yoda's Theme in it *does* make sense... |
Tuesday, February 18, 2020 (9:06 a.m.) |
|---|
> That's not what Clemmensen was talking about there. He was objecting to
> the Yoda theme during 'Reunion' because, well, it makes no sense.
From a scholarly perspective, it does. Yoda's theme was written by John Williams for The Empire Strikes Back as a theme highlighting that a little old alien could be a great Jedi master and a former hero.
In Reunion it accompanies the hug Beaumont Kin gives to the alien mechanic Kled, and the awarding of an alliance victory medal to another alien - Chewbacca - by yet another alien - Maz Kanata.
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
Re: But the scene with Yoda's Theme in it *does* make sense... |
Tuesday, February 18, 2020 (9:57 a.m.) |
|---|
> That's not what Clemmensen was talking about there. He was objecting to
> the Yoda theme during 'Reunion' because, well, it makes no sense.
Ah! Forgot about that one. Yeah, that makes no sense at all.
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
The Orchestrator
(cpe-158-222-138-162.nyc.res.rr.co
m)
In Response to:
↑ Tydirium |
|
Re: But the scene with Yoda's Theme in it *does* make sense... |
Tuesday, February 18, 2020 (3:07 p.m.) |
|---|
> Ah! Forgot about that one. Yeah, that makes no sense at all.
The only thing that makes sense is Maz Kanata possibly being a force user in the vein of a small person giving advice about the force like how Yoda functioned in the original trilogy. In Force Awakens, she says she knows the force and just happens to have a lightsaber. Like clearly a lot of things were cut and undeveloped from the trilogy and it wouldn't be shocking that Maz Kanata was force sensitive but all the hints got cut from the movie. A small stature person in tuned with the force is not a stretch in this case.
|
Post Full Response
Edit Post
Threaded display
|
|
|
|
|
|