Posted by: Craig <Send E-Mail> Date: Thursday, June 24, 2004, at 11:39 a.m. IP Address: 126.96.36.199.ptr.us.xo.net
A good score from Horner that works well with and supports the movie. The triumphant 2nd track and the action cues especially track 8 are complex, rich and add drama to the scene. Track 11 the finale was outstanding and evoked the pathos of Troy's demise. Lastly, the song Remember Me sung by Josh Groban is well sung, lyrical and deeply moving. It is emblematic of the fateful choice of Achilles: a short gloriuous life or a long and safe life in obscurity.
As to the repetitions of his earlier works, may I say to the Horner haters that Herrmann, Rozsa, Williams, Barry, Goldsmith et al all have similiar repetitions, or echoes of earlier works in their efforts. I am constrained to point out that the people we love most in our lives have similiar repetitions or echoes in their mannerism, personality, and habits that serve to endear them to us and provide a personal connection, a sense of comfort and familiarity, all essential qualities for human relationships. It is no different in that respect to our bond with our favorite film score composers. So measure your criticism more thoughtfully, and think twice before engaging in personal attacks. Giving oneself permission to blindly assign bad motives via supposition must always be condemned. May I close by saying that at least James Horner strives to enrich us and bring beauty into our lives with his music when there are all too many despicable people whose only contribution to life is animosity, hatred and violence. Thank you for the forum, have a nice day.