|
|
|
|
|
Menu Options ▼
Re: Did Alan Silvestri rip off..?
Posted by: Hellsong Date: Thursday, October 7, 2004, at 1:28 a.m.
IP Address: 218.208.200.189
In Response to:
Re: Did Alan Silvestri rip off..? (SeReNdiPitY)
> Itīs not the grail theme, itīs very very similar but itīs not (same
> begining but different end). You can hear it when mr van helsing is about
> to be briefed about his mission in transylvania (itīs about 4 seconds
> long)
Silvestri is too good to rip themes from other compositors
>
I agree, the track sounded ALMOST loke the grail theme, but here Alan did a more personal score, touching the end of the family's curse...William's Grail theme is more grandiose, echoing a forgotten but noble past...
as for Alan ripping LOTR; BLAHHH i said to that; Alan Silvestri (along with John Williams, Jerry Goldsmith) were legends LOOng before Howard Shore became one (ya, i NEVER heard of Shore up until LOTR)...so to say Silvestri rip Shore's work is like what the Cardinal says to Van Helsing in the confessional box; "Don'y BLASPHEME"!!!!
Comments in this Thread:
Expand >>
|
|
|