Glisten Effect
Editorial Reviews
Scoreboard Forum
Viewer Ratings
Composers
Awards
   NEWEST MAJOR REVIEWS:
     1. Pinocchio
    2. The Woman King
   3. Samaritan
  4. The Gray Man
 5. Prey
6. Bullet Train
   CURRENT MOST POPULAR REVIEWS:
         1. Dune (2021)
        2. Spider-Man
       3. Alice in Wonderland
      4. Encanto
     5. Batman
    6. Wonder Woman 1984
   7. No Time to Die
  8. Ghostbusters: Afterlife
 9. Murder on the Orient Express
10. LOTR: Fellowship of the Ring
Home Page
Archives:   2000-2006 | 2006-2015 | 2015-2021
Menu Options ▼

Edit | Delete
Got it Andres! Thank you for contributing! smile [EDITED]
Profile Image
• Posted by: Craig Richard Lysy   <Send E-Mail>
• Date: Thursday, February 24, 2022, at 6:27 a.m.
• IP Address: cpe-76-170-71-50.socal.res.rr.com
• In Response to: My Top 10 of 2021 (featuring massive commentar... (Ramůn)
Message Edited: Thursday, February 24, 2022, at 6:28 a.m.

Very much enjoyed your commentary! Thank you for the kind words.

All the best

> 1. Chicory: A Colorful Tale - Lena Raine
> 2. The Green Knight - Daniel Hart
> 3. Aliens: Fireteam Elite - Austin Wintory
> 4. Dune - Hans Zimmer
> 5. Masters of the Universe: Revelation - Bear McCreary
> 6. Us Again - Pinar Toprak
> 7. Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart - Mark Mothersbaugh & Wataru
> Hokoyama
> 8. Battlefield 2042 - Hildur Gudnadůttir & Sam Slater
> 9. Succession (Season 3) - Nicholas Britell
> 10. Raya and the Last Dragon - James Newton Howard

> As usual, huge thanks to Craig for organizing these. Iím always down to
> talk about music I love.

> For this list Iím gonna break one of the cardinal rules of my Scoreboard
> lists, which is that I only include scores Iíve experienced in context. No
> real reason why this rule exists, I often just find myself saying more
> interesting things about scores when Iíve heard them in context. But in
> 2021 I watched a lot less films and shows, played a lot less games, and
> even listened to a lot less scores (not that my sample size every year is
> stupid high anyway).

> So this list is a mix. Most of them Iíve heard in context, but some I
> havenít. Iíve also already done a Top 10 write-up on my site, featuring
> all video game scores. Some overlap with this one, so I will be referring
> to it when they pop up here.

> https://wp.me/pcOTTc-eE

> 10. Raya and the Last Dragon - James Newton Howard
> When I first listened to this, I didnít think much of it. It took me a
> couple of listens and watching the film to warm up to it.

> And now I think itís great. Itís Howard fantasy like only Howard can do
> it. I love the very distinctive sound that he creates for this world,
> coupled with his signature emotional and action writing. The Unity theme
> (the one heard very prominently during the first half of The Drunn
> Close In
) is a vintage Howard theme, and itís very moving, as is
> Running on Raindrops.

> It may not have the easy accessibility of other fantasy scores of his, but
> its creativity and sense of fun more than make up for it.

> 9. Succession (Season 3) - Nicholas Britell
> I was surprised by how angry I found the third seasonís music to be. Itís
> still very much that quasi-classical music pastiche, but thereís a
> certainÖ yeah, anger to it that I found fascinating.

> It fits the Roys losing control over their empire and even themselves
> really well, and itís a very necessary dimension to be added to the music
> after the more Ďclinicalí approach from the previous two seasons.

> I adored it in context, and elevated a lot of the sequences from the show
> a lot. I just wish there was an album so that I could mention specific
> highlights.

> 8. Battlefield 2042 - Hildur Gudnadůttir & Sam
> Slater

> Thoughts are on the article. The only update being that I have now played
> a couple of hours of the game. The score doesnít do much within the game,
> but that doesnít diminish my opinions on it in any way.

> 7. Ratchet & Clank: Rift Apart - Mark Mothersbaugh &
> Wataru Hokoyama

> Thoughts are on the article.

> 6. Us Again - Pinar Toprak
> I probably couldíve asked Craig if short films were fair game, but I
> really loved this score and I feel very strongly about what I have to say
> about this one.

> Captain Marvel is the score that put Toprak on the map for many
> (including me), and I know that itís a lot of yíallís favorite of hers,
> but Iíve always been mostly indifferent towards it (with the exception of
> a couple of cues). Until very recently I hadnít been able to put into
> words why that was.

> I heard a certain composer I really respect say recently that one of the
> most common crutches of composers in the early stages of their career was
> their inability to stick with one musical idea for a reasonable period of
> time, resulting in pieces of music that constantly shift from motif to
> motif, from rhythm to rhythm more than is actually necessary, and often to
> the point of overload.

> And while I donít presume to know Toprakís frame of mind when writing her
> score or her methods, it suddenly dawned on me what it is that I donít
> like about it, and itís just that. The action music is extremely frenetic
> to me, constantly jumping around and not letting any of its ideas stay for
> a little bit for me to enjoy them or develop organically so that one leads
> to the other. Itís musical whiplash to me. Itís also probably why I enjoy
> Iím All Fired Up the most.

> All of this to say that Us Again is the exact opposite. Throughout
> its 6+ minutes, Us Again hits many more sync points than any single
> cue in Captain Marvel ever does, and yet the music in this short
> film reads as far more effortless than an entire feature score. Toprak
> riffs on a handful of ideas, but itís the way that she leads from one
> section to the next, to the way that she uses her main theme as a
> throughline and develops it for a myriad of settings and instruments.

> Listen to how she uses the electric bass as the cue jumps around from the
> jazz ensemble to electric guitar to muted trumpets to accordion to low
> woodwinds and finally to piano, which after some more riffing, finally
> leads to the reveal of the main theme on piano at 1:12. She piles up so
> many musical lines on top of each other in rapid-fire fashion, but itís
> done in such an elegant and effortless way that itís not exhausting or
> jarring; it feels like a piece of music naturally evolving and developing.

> By the time that the cue hits that intense, climatic moment at 4:12, it
> doesnít feel like it came out of nowhere or that the cue took a sudden
> left turn to get here. It feels like a piece of music that organically
> evolved towards this point. It feels earned, which makes that adrenaline
> rush that youíre supposed to be feeling seeing the old man frantically,
> and foolishly, chasing after his youth all the more palpable and sincere.

> I was very, deeply moved by this score, both before and after I watched
> the short. I think itís my favorite thing that Toprakís done so far.

> 5. Masters of the Universe: Revelation - Bear McCreary
> Bear McCreary goes all-out again! I was going to write more about it, but
> given how much love it has received already, I donít want to be redundant.

> Quick shout-out to The Temptation of Evil-Lyn. This and The
> Dream of Cleon the First
from Foundation are probably my very
> favorite things McCreary wrote last year. The MOTU track is just great,
> taking the Evil-Lyn theme on a journey through several emotional settings
> (much like the character themselves during this sequence).

> 4. Dune - Hans Zimmer
> And the award for the most exhausting score discourse of the year goes toÖ
> not Dune!

> I was fully expecting this score to blow up, hyperbolic rants ensue and
> end up absolutely hating to see people talk about Dune after a couple of
> weeks. Thatís how divisive Zimmer tends to be (and Iím just talking about
> his music here). Instead, The Matrix Resurrections burst out like a
> brick wall and knocked me out for a solid two months. I was exhausted
> before I even got to hear the music or watch the film.

> Which means that I got to fully enjoy and pick apart (and read others pick
> apart) Dune without all the hyperbolic noise surrounding it. I
> found so much that I love about it, some things Iím okay with, and only a
> couple I donít really like.

> I think when all is said and done, Dune is a pretty traditionally
> structured score. Youíve got plenty of thematic ideas for the various
> concepts in the story (by thematic I donít necessarily mean melodic) and
> they play off each other as the narrative requires. But itís Zimmer and
> his teamís execution of this structure that makes the score shine as well
> as it does.

> I was probably most surprised at how heavily vocal this score is (and
> hereís where my ignorance about the source material shows the most). At
> first, I thought it was an instrumental choice to represent this universe,
> but the more I thought about it, the more it convinced me that this is
> Zimmerís way of representing the Bene Gesseritís influence over many
> things in the story, from influencing the Fremen into believing the tale
> of the Lisan al-Gaib to Paulís own existence as the son of a Bene
> Gesserit and part of the larger prophecy of the Kwisatz Haderach.

> The Bene Gesseritís music itself is already heavily vocal, with Zimmer
> expanding upon those heavily-processed vocal experiments he was already
> doing for Dark Phoenix. More than any other use of voices in the
> score, the Bene Gesserit stand starkly apart from everything else with the
> cold, alienating, almost mechanical nature of their soundscape (although
> the Sardaukar throat-singing comes very close to this).

> Nearly every other use of voices throughout the film can be traced back to
> the Bene Gesserit in some way. For example, while the Fremen theme is most
> noticeably heard on Loire Cotlerís soaring vocals whenever Paulís
> relationship with them is brought up, such as in Gom Jabbar, its
> standard rendition is actually on duduk or soft synths. Chaniís motif is
> not overtly vocal, but notice the subtle layering of voices from hissings
> and hummings to actual whispering that pop up during tracks like
> Visions of Chani, which scores one of Paulís many visions of the
> girl. Paulís motif (the one that explodes in Leaving Caladan), is
> performed by a myriad of instruments, but whenever his messianic role is
> touched upon, vocals pick up the arpeggiated figure (in Ripples in the
> Sand
, for example).

> And itís not just with voices. You can find many examples of smart
> instrumental storytelling throughout; another example of this is Paulís
> motif being played by the duduk as he watches documentaries about the
> Fremen. Iím a huge fan of instrumental storytelling, so I was very
> satisfied with how much this score says with the subtlest changes to the
> instrumental palette.

> Unsurprisingly, the most accessible material in the score relates to House
> Atreides, from Paulís motif to the actual Atreides anthem, to a motif that
> seems to relate to Paulís destiny, and which seems to share strong
> connections with Chaniís motif (listen to the elegiac melody that opens
> Holy War).

> The latter theme is one I instantly picked up on when watching the film
> but wasnít as obvious on the album. It appears for the first time when
> Leto talks with him about their role in Arrakis and Paulís future. Itís
> both regal and mysterious (putting it through a standard choir was a
> perfect touch), and does a great job of selling the weight of Paulís
> importance within the story.

> Itís, once again, a fully realized world that stunningly complements and
> elevates the film experience. Thereís so much to love here and so much
> still left to uncover for me.

> 3. Aliens: Fireteam Elite - Austin Wintory
> Thoughts are on the article.

> 2. The Green Knight - Daniel Hart
> This was one of those very late additions to the list. Iíve been wanting
> to watch The Green Knight for a long time, but unfortunately I
> missed its theatrical window (thanks COVID!) and it only just recently was
> made available on VOD over here.

> I donít think thereís any more of substance I can add to the praise that
> hasnít already been said by both Jon and Vikram. This is a breathtaking
> score, one so carefully constructed and researched, which marries both
> synths and period-accurate music. More than evoking a specific time
> period, the score evokes the world of this specific film, one that
> effortlessly blurs the line between reality and fantasy.

> I adore the sense of history that the score adds beyond the dramatic
> accompaniment. One of my favorite aspects of genre worldbuilding is
> getting the sense that the world of the story has already been lived in,
> with its own microstories hidden beneath the surface. By writing songs in
> period-accurate musical styles and even long-forgotten languages Hart
> manages to do just that.

> Itís great. Itís just so great. I love hearing a composer as comfortable
> doing such avant-garde scoring as he is writing accessible, traditional
> orchestral scores.

> 1. Chicory: A Colorful Tale - Lena Raine
> I wasnít going to write anything for Chicory, given that Iíve
> already written quite a bit during my write-up for Game Music Hub. If you
> want a lighter read, you can read that one and skip this one.

> The reason for talking even more now is because I purposefully restricted
> myself to giving no spoilers over there, and a lot of my feelings towards
> Chicory came from not knowing anything but the music beforehand.

> And apparently this score flew under the radar around here. Thatís the way
> it goes, I guess.

> So letís get spoiler-y here. Chicory: A Colorful Tale is a story
> about a talking dog called Pizza (because apparently Lentejas con
> Cebollita, Salchichas y Tocino was too long to fit in the naming bar).
> They work cleaning the Wielderís Tower, where Chicory, wielder of the
> legendary Magical Brush, resides. One day, the world is rendered
> colorless, Chicory disappears and the Brush is left behind, leaving it to
> Pizza to find Chicory and restore the color of the world.

> Thematically, the game is about the relationship between art and the
> artist, touching upon subjects like mental health, self-esteem, impostorís
> syndrome, burnout, outsider expectations, or the meaning of individuality
> in a world that sometimes demands your art to be stripped of it in order
> to please someone else.

> These themes are explored through two perspectives. The first is Chicory,
> a prodigious wielder of the Brush who crumbled under the weight of her
> responsibility as the only person capable of giving color to the world,
> failed by a mentor who comes from a line of past wielders carrying the
> same trauma as her. The second is Pizza, a janitor thrusted into the
> duties of the Wielder who, though secretly yearning to be a Wielder
> themselves, constantly doubts whether they've truly earned it or if they
> were just lucky to be at the right place at the right time.

> So I love doing creative writing when Iím not working or writing for Game
> Music Hub. Itís been my very favorite thing to do since I know how to do
> it. On the surface, I love the craftsmanship of it. I love thinking about
> characters, about narrative arcs, about plotlines interweaving with one
> another, about carefully constructing a narrative development that hits at
> exactly the right moment to create the most powerful impact.

> On a deeper level than that, I find very few things in this world as
> fulfilling as finding ways to say something meaningful to me through a
> story, having an indirect conversation with someone else through that
> story. Ty Franck (one half of James S.A. Corey) recently tweeted that
> stories are a conversation where the response is someone else resonating
> with something from the story and going to write their own where they
> expand on it. And yeah, the entirety of art history is a continuum of
> interlocking, simultaneous conversations where one piece couldnít exist
> without the other.

> If things turn out alright with me, and my many gambles somehow pay off,
> Iíd love to write for a living, whether itís literature, film, games or
> TV. Iím honestly too fascinated by the idea of storytelling to want to be
> limited to just being ďa screenwriter,Ē or ďa TV writer,Ē or ďa novelist.Ē

> So Chicory strongly resonated with me. What does this have to do
> with the score? Well, nothing and everything. I listened to the score when
> the game launched in June, but it wouldnít be until December that I
> actually played the game, so I spent nearly six months with the music and
> no context. I fell in love with the scoreís sense of wonder, fun, and
> emotion. Itís been a while since Iíve heard a score filled with this much
> life, color and vibrancy.

> Then I played the game, and another, deeper layer of understanding was
> unlocked for me. The music was saying a lot more that I didnít understand.
> I keep coming back to that devastating boss fight scored by Abandon
> Me
, where Chicory, consumed by crippling depression, manifests
> horrific monsters that attack Pizza. The fight alternates between stages
> of fighting and interludes of conversation as Pizza tries to talk Chicory
> out of her spiral. The interactive score waxes and wanes as the intensity
> of the battle shifts. Raine elegantly supports the conversations with that
> fragile piano figure and, as Chicory spirals into despair, wanting to be
> left alone and be forgotten, Iím hit with a very familiar feeling.

> I left college in 2019. After years of near-constant struggle, I burned
> out hard for reasons too long to explain. I wanted to be a doctor, but a
> mental illness plus a whole host of secondary things took that drive away
> from me, and it nearly did the same with my drive to write.

> When it was time for me to grapple with my feelings towards my creative
> side, or what was left of them, I asked the same questions that
> Chicory, the game, asks with its story. On one hand, I wanted to
> just give it up; I felt so defeated and exhausted and demoralized and
> empty that I didnít feel like writing another word for the rest of my
> life. On the other, who am I if I donít do that ever again? SoÖ what ifÖ I
> could still do it? Is it worth getting back to it? Will I still enjoy it?
> Do I still have something to say? If I do, am I saying something that has
> meaning? Do I need to make something that has meaning? Would anyone even
> care to read? And the question that took me the longest to answer: Where
> do I start? The question, it turned out, was ďjust sit down and write
> whatever, do the same tomorrow, then the day after that.Ē

> Even today, after Game Music Hub has enjoyed a small moment of exposure,
> with a handful of composers telling me how much theyíve enjoyed my
> articles on their scores and a number of readers giving positive feedback
> and somehow finding my ramblings interesting, I still ask some of the same
> questions.

> What does this have to do with the score? Still, nothing and everything.
> Even if the game presented the framework that allowed it to happen, it was
> that elegant piano figure from Abandon Me that made me flash all
> the way back to that dark period of my life. Lena Raine somehow managed to
> capture that horrific combination of emotions at the heart of both
> Chicoryís plight and my own.

> And as the game kept going, I was constantly stunned by the sincerity and
> profundity with which the game tackled its complicated subjects, and how
> much genuine emotion Lena Raine was imprinting onto this cutesy and quirky
> score. There is so much turmoil at the heart of her music.

> And sure, I can concede that maybe Iím projecting a lot of myself onto a
> piece of music and a game. But art is all about projecting, isnít it?
> Thatís how we connect to it.

> Well, this is how I connected to Chicory: A Colorful Tale and its
> score. I could keep writing about it for paragraphs on end (on top of what
> I already said in the article). I could get into the weeds of the
> intricate connections between the themes. I could talk about details like
> how the piano is recorded in such a way to purposefully include extraneous
> details like the pressing of the pedal, the clicking of the keys, and even
> sometimes the breathing of the player, which is a genius, though subtle,
> way of representing the central 'art and the artist' theme of the game. I
> could talk about the interactive details of the score, like how the attack
> patterns of certain bosses are timed to the music.

> But I figure itís about time I wrap this up. I actually did write a whole
> three paragraphs about me finding this score to say something really
> interesting about Lena Raine herself, but by this point itís too much.

> Chicory is Score of the Year, yíall. Nothing came even close to
> managing to move me this deeply in 2021. And Lena Raine just skyrocketed
> from a very high regard to one of my absolute favorite contemporary
> composers.

> Composer of the Year: Bear McCreary
> I was very tempted to shout out Lena Raine as CotY just based on how much
> I enjoyed Chicory and Moonglow Bay, but truly, Bear McCreary
> had a stellar year with solid scores all around.

> EDIT: Accidentally deleted the numbering when formatting the write-up.
> Whoops!




Messages in this Thread:     Expand >>


Copyright © 1998-2022, Filmtracks Publications. All rights reserved.
The reviews and other textual content contained on the filmtracks.com site may not be published, broadcast,
rewritten or redistributed without the prior written authority of Christian Clemmensen at Filmtracks Publications. Scoreboard created 7/24/98 and last updated 4/25/15.
Filmtracks takes no responsibility for any offense or mental trauma caused by this forum. Behold the Scoreboard motto to better understand why this party is relentlessly trolled.