| CLOSE WINDOW |
|
FILMTRACKS.COM
PRINTER-FRIENDLY VIEW 
Review of 10 Cloverfield Lane (Bear McCreary)
FILMTRACKS RECOMMENDS:
Buy it... if you appreciate surprisingly intelligent psychological
horror scores that balance their discomforting passages with lyrically
enticing moments of accessibly tonal suspense.
Avoid it... if you are the type to over-analyze your film scores, because there are enough intentionally counterintuitive choices made by Bear McCreary here to potentially leave you somewhat dissatisfied with his approach.
FILMTRACKS EDITORIAL REVIEW:
10 Cloverfield Lane: (Bear McCreary) Before anyone
screams "spoiler!" about this review, let's keep in mind that if there's
one thing that filmmaker J.J. Abrams obsesses about more than any other,
it's aliens. His cultish hit, Cloverfield from 2008, apparently
fed into his fascination with bizarre accounts of otherworldly
encounters to such an extent that his team of director Dan Trachtenberg
and screenwriter Damien Chazelle revised a rather mundane psychological
horror script into a pseudo-sequel of Cloverfield for 2016's less
heralded but still successful 10 Cloverfield Lane. Rampant
speculation exists about the literal connections between the films'
plots, though the more important link remains the unusual personal
storylines that exist during the disintegration of society. Despite the
fact there's a likely related alien invasion occurring in both films,
the task of 10 Cloverfield Lane is to fool you into believing
that man is the real monster of the universe. The film spends most of
its running time convincing you that the doomsday preparation fanatic
who rescues (read: kidnaps) the young female protagonist for his
underground bunker during some kind of widespread surface catastrophe is
the sole problem at hand. When she escapes, there are larger issues that
would make Fox Mulder proud, and the heroine is thrust into the position
of combatant against far greater powers. Leading up to the arguably
cheap twist ending is the fairly standard psychological horror script
that spawned this entire production, and playing along with that
expected formula is Bear McCreary's score. A tirelessly busy composer of
the younger generation, McCreary first became widely noticed after his
music for the "Battlestar Galactica" television series that he joined in
2004. Since then, his presence in the television realm has been both
prolific and impressive in the quality of output, including countless
hours of music for "Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D.," "The Walking Dead," "Da
Vinci's Demons," "Outlander," and "Black Sails," among others. There
have been a few feature film projects long the way, but 10
Cloverfield Lane represents the composer's first truly mainstream
feature project.
McCreary's connection to Abrams has already yielded the expected comparisons between the composer's early career and that of Michael Giacchino, who also enjoyed significant success on television productions before using his knack for creativity and style to storm the feature realm. With 10 Cloverfield Lane, McCreary positions himself well to make that jump to major feature projects, and enthusiasts of his intellectually interesting approach to his assignments have to be thrilled by this ascendance. As one would expect, McCreary likely over-thought the music for 10 Cloverfield Lane, adding layers of intelligence probably unnecessary for a rather typical psychological horror venture. Anyone looking for relationships between this score and Giacchino's one massive end titles cue from Cloverfield will find few similarities, as the immense Giacchino composition made no attempt to hide its intent to pay tribute to the massive monster epics of yesteryear. The general formula of McCreary's score is more akin to a standard Christopher Young entry in the genre, offering a lovely and seductive main protagonist theme that exposes its romanticism at the beginning and end of the score's otherwise predictable horror fare. Stylistically, McCreary more directly takes inspiration from his mentor, Elmer Bernstein, and especially suspense master Bernard Herrmann, with a few nods to Jerry Goldsmith along the way. Not a bad collection of composers with which to make a comparison. McCreary's route to the finished product was overwrought, however, the composer hiring four ensembles ranging from a string quartet to a full orchestra and fusing them together with a variety of processed percussive-like sounds emanating from a warehouse environment, the solo vocals of his wife, and prominent performances on a Turkish stringed instrument and the Star Trek-favorite Blaster Beam. Some of these performances will fly right over the heads of casual listeners, and the whole affair seems like overkill given the end product, but the intellectual collector will appreciate the effort. In many cases, as in the distinctly foreign Turkish yayli tambur representing the average American heroine of the tale, the instrumental choices are intentionally counterintuitive, and that may bother or confuse some listeners. Against that eerie sound for the lead protagonist in 10 Cloverfield Lane, McCreary balances a short, whining, dissonant violin motif for the physically imposing human villain, again playing with audience expectations. Its major performance ("Howard") is laced with the female vocals you'd rather expect to hear in the heroine's material. Fortunately, the main theme in the two "Michelle" cues is very strong regardless of its somewhat bizarre instrumentation, a rousing, undulating rhythmic motif often accompanying it to suggest the underlying panic of the situation. It is in this tonally satisfying rhythm that the Chris Young comparisons will emerge. As with many Young scores, the first six and final ten minutes of the score are anchored by this attractive theme, the last cue a suite that transitions into the "Howard" material in its midsection. Expect these passages to beckon you for repeat appreciation, as they espouse just the right qualities of lyricism and creepiness in conjunction with the unique instrumentation. The mass of the middle, horror portions of the score are competent, and they smartly incorporate fragments of the themes into their strikes and explosions of sound. Don't expect too many tonally accessible passages in these parts, however; much of it is quite unpleasant, even if the nearly perpetual layering of the Blaster Beam does fulfill your bass region fantasies. Aside from the curiosity that is the foreign tilt to the heroine's theme, you also have a failure in this score to shift from the horror/suspense mode into a convincing action mode, only the last portions of "Valencia" beginning to suggest the rebellious victories at hand. As such, the narrative of the score isn't quite as neatly wrapped as it might have been, the difference between "Michelle" and "The New Michelle" noticeable in volume and percussive thumping but not truly evolved to any degree. These quibbles aside, 10 Cloverfield Lane remains a truly engaging score that performs beyond most expectations. Originally released only digitally, the score's diverse instrumental palette demands a lossless presentation, and McCreary's own independent label eventually supplied a CD of the same digital soundtrack contents later in 2016. Explore that CD with confidence and an appreciation for the influences you'll hear from genre masters of yesteryear, and expect McCreary to follow a Giacchino trajectory before long as well, his talents too broad to remain confined to television forever. ****
TRACK LISTINGS:
Total Time: 63:44
NOTES & QUOTES:
The insert includes a wealth of information, including lists of performers, photos from the sessions, and detailed
notes from the composer about the score. The booklet is so thick that it barely fits in the jewel case; do not be surprised
if you damage the booklet attempting to re-insert it into the case.
Copyright ©
2016-2024, Filmtracks Publications. All rights reserved.
The reviews and other textual content contained on the filmtracks.com site may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without the prior written authority of Christian Clemmensen at Filmtracks Publications. All artwork and sound clips from 10 Cloverfield Lane are Copyright © 2016, Sparks & Shadows (McCreary) and cannot be redistributed without the label's expressed written consent. Page created 6/12/16 (and not updated significantly since). |
