: (Craig Armstrong) The Marvel
universe has struck back with a vengeance in 2008, providing a pair of
interconnected films (led by
) sure to erase bad memories
of previous ventures and open the doors to several sequels. The long
history of the story of Dr. Bruce Banner on screen originates in the
popular 70's/80's television series "The Incredible Hulk" and includes
the far less convincing Ang Lee adaptation
to cinemas in
2003. With 2008's
, Marvel and Universal
essentially forget all about the Lee failure and concentrate on
re-inventing the character in a fashion that gives no thought to the
events of 2003. By the start of French director Louis Leterrier's
, Banner has already fled to South America to escape
capture and look for a cure to his genetically altered state. When
discovered by the American military after a temper flare-up, Banner's
return to the United States reunites him with his lost love and
ultimately sets him up for a showdown with the military and one
particular villain who himself will become a hulk-like mass in order to
complete the capture. Not only does this rearranged adaptation connect
to the larger Marvel universe (with a
crowd-pleasing cameo at the end that almost steals all of this film's
thunder), but it's also very loyal to the original television series.
Lou Ferrigno, Stan Lee, and even Bill Bixby are integrated into the
film, as are some iconic scenes and musical motifs. Scottish composer
Craig Armstrong received the assignment for
because of Leterrier's appreciation for his music and confidence that
Armstrong's orchestral techniques would be well suited for the occasion.
One of Armstrong's first actions upon being hired was to purchase a copy
of the 2003 film, but he wisely decided not to view it. Not only was
Lee's film misguided, but Danny Elfman's score for it is widely
considered to be among the composer's least inspired (and occasionally
inappropriate) superhero work of his career. Armstrong would start with
a clean slate, writing demo themes for several characters and especially
impressing Marvel with his creative method of providing an identity for
the title character himself.
The style of Armstrong's writing has always been one of
the easiest to identify in mainstream films of the past ten years. His
blend of contemporary electronics, propulsive rhythms, strained and
romantic strings, and ethereal chorus are unique to his writing. For
The Incredible Hulk, Leterrier emphasized that he wanted
primarily an orchestral score, and so the composer's usual electronic
samples and loops are largely absent from the work (despite some
synthetic augmentation in parts). Absent completely is the chorus that
Armstrong typically incorporates. Instead, he relies heavily on the
other two trademarks of his writing: rolling rhythms and strident
strings. Because of time constraints, Armstrong ended up writing most of
the score at Remote Control in Los Angeles (though the result is nothing
like you'd usually hear from the Remote Control factory of clones) and
recording it with 73 players in Seattle. While a rewarding process that
was met with enthusiasm by Marvel and Universal along the way, not to
mention Leterrier's perpetual support, Armstrong reportedly is heading
off into his classical concert writing for a while, taking a break from
his scoring duties. Nothing could keep him from
The Incredible
Hulk, however, for it was one of the composer's favorite shows as a
child. The result of his inspiration is interesting in all of its parts,
brilliant in some while serviceable in others. Armstrong almost writes a
score that is too intelligent for the concept, concocting and
interweaving themes for both halves of Banner's personality, the
collaboration between villains played by William Hurt and Tim Roth, and
the love interest between Banner and Betty Ross. It's the complicated
mingling of the themes that sacrifices easy entertainment for an
intriguing and intellectual listening experience. Most of the nuances of
Armstrong's work are the kind that could easily be missed on album,
which doesn't bode well for most of them in the film itself. That lack
of clarity is by far the score's greatest weakness. Still, when
especially compared to most of the comic book superhero scores of this
era, Armstrong's take on
The Incredible Hulk concentrates heavily
on the duality in character that so many other composers fail to
adequately address nowadays.
The highlight of Armstrong's work for
The Incredible
Hulk is his strikingly simple idea for Banner's ill-tempered side.
Heard immediately in "The Arctic" and "Main Titles" and flourishing in
the monster's multiple appearances throughout the film (along with a
couple of suite arrangements on album), this frightfully basic idea is
perfect for the "smashing" mentality of the character. Conveyed on
well-enunciated layers of strings, this theme forcefully opens on a "C"
note, the most primordial of opening locations, and bounces up and down
through octaves with sharp glissandos of distinctly menacing attitude.
The octave steps are smartly incorporated underneath higher string
ostinatos that often allude to the theme for the normal state of
Banner's character. By "Harlem Brawl" and "Hulk Smash" in the final
battle sequences of the film, the bass string and cello theme for the
Hulk pounds its way through yearning harmonic performances on violins
that both address Banner's low key theme, or otherwise Armstrong's own
"lonely man theme," while also stating pieces of the love theme. That
love theme is first heard partly in "Return to Culvery University" and
in full in the bittersweet "Reunion." This theme continues to develop
throughout the film in unexpected ways, adapted by Armstrong to serve
more action-oriented purposes during scenes when Betty and the Hulk
share screen time. While the score closes with significantly tender
expressions of the theme, perhaps its most heartbreaking moment comes on
strings in "I Can't." Unfortunately, while Armstrong intelligently works
this thematic idea into the bulk of the score, it's not among the most
compelling romantic themes of his career. Even in the suite "Bruce and
Betty," which is adapted into the film in parts, the theme fails to
leave a strong impression (especially when compared to Banner's
conflicting motifs). The material for the Emil Blonsky (technically two
different themes) and a motif for the science behind the mutations also
suffer from anonymity problems because of Armstrong's wickedly powerful
ideas for Banner and the Hulk. The brass theme for the Abomination,
which is also happy in its anchoring to notes on key, gets short-changed
because of its infrequent need in the story.
One area in which Armstrong doesn't forget to nod to
the franchise's past is in the use of a piano to create the ambience of
his "lonely man theme." This usage, along with some similar
progressions, will remind listeners of the melodramatic title theme to
The Bone Collector. Armstrong does use Joe Harnell's famous
television "lonely man theme" on piano in "Bruce Goes Home," a touching
tribute, albeit brief. Another moment worth mentioning is "Who's We?,"
the cue for the aforementioned crowd-pleasing connection to another
franchise in the Marvel Universe at the end of the film. It's
interesting that in the crescendo during this brief cue, Armstrong
provides a more convincing superhero progression than was provided the
cameo character in his own film (which, despite being considered the
better film, features a truly wretched Remote Control-style score).
Aside from the merits of the music, there has to be some discussion
about the release of
The Incredible Hulk on album. Because the
director considered the score to be so good, he convinced Marvel to
allow for a full, double-CD release of the complete work. This product
would be pressed on an on-demand basis only at the online retailer
Amazon.com, which understandably confused some listeners trying to find
the product at a local store. The method of release (which includes
CDR's and professionally printed packaging) allowed for the score to
receive this kind of full treatment, for which Armstrong included
material ultimately removed from the film (such as the opening "The
Arctic" piece, a very good cue) as well as two suite variations of the
"End Credits" suite (the one in the picture is the synthetics-dominated
version on the second CD... the weaker one of the two, unfortunately,
but likely better appealing to the mainstream). The one hour and fifty
minutes of material can become burdensome, especially with the sheer
volume of the many ambitious, layered action cues. The sound quality of
the CDR's, however, is very strong, and given that it's possible that
Amazon.com and Marvel won't be offering these CDR's forever, you
shouldn't hesitate to purchase one sooner rather than later. Armstrong's
score isn't the best in the superhero genre, but it certainly beats
Elfman's 2003
Hulk and has an intelligence, title theme, and
orchestral performance that will not fail to impress you.
**** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download
Bias Check: |
For Craig Armstrong reviews at Filmtracks, the average editorial rating is 3.83
(in 12 reviews) and the average viewer rating is 3.42
(in 46,015 votes). The maximum rating is 5 stars.
|