|
|
|
|
|
My Left Foot
|
|
|
|
|
| |
Composed and Conducted by:
Produced by:
Cynthia Millar
|
|
LABEL & RELEASE DATE
| |
|
|
|
ALBUM AVAILABILITY
| |
|
Regular U.S. release.
|
|
AWARDS
| |
|
None.
|
|
ALSO SEE
| |
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
|
Buy it... because of its fleeting moments of joy for a secondary
theme of perseverance, Elmer Bernstein occasionally breaking through the
frustrating, minimal cycles of this score for moments of engaging
hope.
Avoid it... and watch the film instead, for the score, while
functional, doesn't satisfyingly address the ethnic element or provide
the necessary narrative via its challenged melodies.
BUY IT
 | | Bernstein |
My Left Foot: (Elmer Bernstein) Among the most
highly respected British films in history, 1989's My Left Foot is
the largely true biographical tale of Christy Brown, an Irishman whose
cerebral palsy left him only able to truly control his left foot. With
years of practice, he became a painter and a writer, suffering mightily
with his inability to speak normally or take care of himself but
remarkably persevering to write a book about his life in 1954. The fame
from that work, along with his artwork, yielded international notoriety
and led to this film, in which actor Daniel Day-Lewis brilliantly
conveyed the man's physical mannerisms and sharp personality. Perhaps
the most intriguing aspect of Brown's life was the adoration he received
from women, carrying on multiple affairs before the final one reportedly
cost him his life due to abuse. The narrative of My Left Foot
stops before those days of darkness, content to dwell upon his early
life in Dublin. It garnered immense awards recognition, largely for its
outstanding acting performances. Its score by Elmer Bernstein is minimal
enough that it didn't get swept up in that consideration. Its impact on
the film is less than one might expect, mainly due to a low mix
throughout, and only in a few scenes does its presence really matter for
more than just short moments. The composer saw his music for this film
as a representation of frustration and imprisonment because of Brown's
considerable challenges, but that strategy doesn't really translate as
the composer intended on screen. He instead alternates between extremely
restrained melodrama and moments of joy and bluster, the latter yielding
the clear highlights. While Bernstein recorded the score in Ireland and
had the country in mind when writing, no Irish aspect really prevails in
the end result, the lack of a solo flute or whistle or fiddle to
accentuate the region a major failure of strategy if such representation
was truly his desire. He opted for his personal obsession, the ondes
martenot, for that duty, which suggests nothing of the Dublin
setting.
The tone of the music in My Left Foot is still
that of yesteryear, Bernstein's Golden Age touch remaining intact, and
only occasional dissonance supplies the setbacks for the lead character,
the cue "Unspoken Fear" largely containing this alarming material. His
instrumentation combines a small string section with a decent number of
woodwinds, piano, and harp. Strings are often limited to quartet size,
with woodwinds supplying greater ensemble size as needed alongside
subtle horn accompaniment that also seems to exist sparingly. The same
method applies to snare presence at the more heightened moments of
rhythm. Plucked strings join emphasized low piano strikes for touches of
amusement or defiance from Brown. While the ondes martenot is a key
voice of the score, it may not serve the whole as well as one might
expect. Bernstein almost suggests its other-worldly tone as means of
denoting Brown being different from everyone else, and that alien
definition is the wrong message to send. Instead, he should have scored
the common emotions that tie the man to the common aspirations of life.
In that regard, the instrument's use may seem anything from inauthentic
to outright offensive for those with disabilities. A soft synthesizer
accents the happier moments with a distinctive sound that is friendly,
though, and a church organ cameos in one quasi-source cue. Because of
the score's brevity and its lack of dominant theme, it struggles to
achieve a purpose. This music needed a narrative, and instead it got a
basically functional tact of each moment. The more optimistic passages
are quite pretty, but they never really achieve warmth. That lack of any
sense of emotional weight in this music is its greatest weakness. Even
though it goes through all the motions sufficiently and thus suffices,
you won't remember it at all. Bernstein's main theme is built upon
ascending figures that augment a melody that endeavors to itself ascend,
ending up in a circle instead. It's a smart structural device that
eventually does escape its confines later in story. Listeners can hear
this idea tentatively opening "Mother" on winds before segueing directly
into the ondes martenot.
Bernstein's main theme for My Left Foot, while
an admirable construct, doesn't really provide the identity the
character deserves. It's stuck in its cyclical loop on woodwind layers
at the outset of "Unspoken Fear," and pieces of that cycle persist in
the latter half of the prickly "Church and Witches." The theme repeats
extensively in its opening ascents during "Study for Christy," in which
the ondes martenot toys with the actual melody thereafter against the
string quartet. Returning to its original form with ascending harp lines
in "Gift for Mother/Cold" for the familial element, the idea informs the
anxious atmosphere of "Struggle and Frustration" in its trapped routine.
At the finale, both the ascending figures and melody open "Love Spoken"
and return on ondes martenot later in the cue. Far more engaging is
Bernstein's theme for Brown's moments of joy and small triumphs in My
Left Foot. The best portions of the score use such material that
raises the life that Bernstein brings to his comedies of the era, and
it's a pulsating rhythm on piano thriving buoyantly as a representation
of Brown's willful determination. Debuting at the end of "Mother" with
much-needed zest, this theme shows some optimism in the jovial second
half of "Therapy," and its underlying rhythm bubbles along in "Study for
Christy." The idea becomes very attractive in its synthetic and
woodwind-bouncing personality during "Happy Moment," and a lively jig
variant closes "Struggle and Frustration" as the only Irish-tilted
passage. At the close of the score, it vitally recurs at 1:10 into "Love
Spoken" and alternates brightly with the main theme throughout the cue.
The only other theme in the score may belong to the Eileen character,
tenderly expressed early in "Therapy" but never destined to go anywhere
musically. Overall, aside from the lackluster ethnic element, the film
really could have used a more cohesive set of themes, but its melodies
still please. The best summary of the score's main themes and highlights
is the "Love Spoken" cue, though an assembly of the joy theme's
performances for Brown could be recommended. A decent 31 minutes of the
score shares an early CD album with Bernstein's like-minded Da
from year earlier, a warmer score that is also Irish-inclined and
contains out-of-place ondes martenot solos.
*** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download
| Bias Check: |
For Elmer Bernstein reviews at Filmtracks, the average editorial rating is 3.48
(in 30 reviews) and the average viewer rating is 3.22
(in 12,570 votes). The maximum rating is 5 stars.
|
Total Time: 31:23
My Left Foot: (31:23)
1. Mother (3:40)
2. Unspoken Fear (4:23)
3. Therapy (2:55)
4. Church and Witches (2:52)
5. Study for Christy (3:05)
6. Happy Moment (2:33)
7. Gift for Mother/Cold (2:54)
8. Struggle and Frustration (3:52)
9. Love Spoken (4:49)
|
Da: (17:20)
10. Da and Memories (2:35)
11. Temptress (2:00)
12. Drown the Dog! (2:52)
13. Secrets (1:28)
14. Old Matters (2:15)
15. Goodbyes (1:00)
16. Resolution (3:58)
|
(The nine tracks from this score occupy the first half of the album only. Total CD time is 48:43.)
The insert includes notes from the composer about the two scores included on the album.
|