:
(Miklós Rózsa) It's easy to joke about longtime former FBI
director J. Edgar Hoover, and one still has to wonder how
would have turned out if Hoover had indeed been
selected as the form of the destructor. But he was an immensely
influential and feared man for decades, shaping perceptions about
government surveillance and shadow control over many public figures,
including top American leadership. The 1977 biographical drama
sought to illuminate his legendary
"files" of information that became the source of much fuss after his
death in 1972, particularly as Nixon administration loyalists were
attempting to prove that Hoover was actively subverting that presidency.
But the movie, while showing the mad rush to retrieve the director's
files around that time, goes all the way back to the man's start as a
spook in the 1920's and details his personal attributes more than had
been explored before. The problem is that few audiences had any interest
in learning anything more about Hoover's personal life, especially the
rumors that he had abnormal sexual interests. Whether or not he achieved
sexual satisfaction listening to his targets copulating is moderately
amusing, but nobody really wanted to see depictions of such depravity.
The movie thus faded into obscurity very quickly, and for composer
Miklós Rózsa, the assignment became the least known of
this final six scores of the late 1970's and early 1980's. Rózsa
was never one to adjust his personal writing style in his later days,
even as the industry shifted its style to synthesizers and space operas.
He predictably handled
just
as he would have in the late 1940's, his approach resembling his
crime-related scores from late in that decade. The demeanor of the music
is incredibly bloated in stature, perhaps too overstated by Rózsa
standards even here. Hoover was an imposing, larger-than-life man, but
some of the character-oriented cues sound like Jesus Christ is being
scored in this film, and the epic scope of some portions just doesn't
play well in this context.
Rózsa faithfully sticks to his guns in
The
Private Files of J. Edgar Hoover, though. The explosive, positive,
major-key ending to the work is especially out of character for an
unlikeable real-life character like Hoover, following the composer's
usual fanfare mode but awkward to the very end. While much of the music
for the central portions of the film is also overwrought, there are
stock conspiratorial suspense passages throughout these sections,
starting with "The Hijacker." These passages, along with stewing drama,
don't hold attention for the score on album even if they are more
appropriate for the picture. The instrumentation for the work is typical
for Rózsa, his cues alternating between his designations of
"large" and "small" orchestra but throwing no unique sleezy or sultry
solo element into his mix. He does nothing to uniquely romanticize the
man aside from the sheer scope of the fuller performances that sometimes
have a self-important newsreel feel to them. Thematically, the composer
stands true to his usual process of providing several recurring
identities and mingling them extensively in the score, though don't be
surprised if you only end up remembering the main theme. That primary
idea is a challenging, ten-note melody with a dynamic final four-note
phrase frequently accessed for the composer in this and his other late
scores. (This constant re-use did become something of an in-joke between
the composer and his orchestrator at the time.) The theme is neither
heroic nor evil, mostly espousing simple bravado and importance.
Debuting at 0:14 into "Main Title" on muscular low brass and repeating
its phrases throughout the cue, the theme catapults up to lofty violins
over low brass counterpoint at 0:47 and rotates between the sections
liberally amongst the secondary charging theme. It reduces to sickly
solo bassoon and haunted low strings at the end of that opening cue.
Woodwinds alternate between its phrases in "Suicide Trap" with
hesitation but the theme dominates "Shadowing Nixon" on slightly
romantic strings with a tinge of restrained agony. It suddenly
interrupts at 0:34 into "Purse Snatcher" with a tortured, dominant
presence, and flutes toy with its initial progressions in the middle of
"And Finally Purvis Broke."
The main theme's presence on slower and more
contemplative strings in "The Meeting" eventually becomes hopelessly
intertwined with the score's personal theme during its massive, long
crescendo in "Temptation." It's more cautious at the beginning of "The
Bloodhound," the four-note descents lacing the later action. After again
stewing on low reeds throughout the brief "Wiretaps," the main theme
becomes a bit more reverent in the deeper string drama of "Mother's
Death" and receives a different perspective in the sparsely jumpy and
plucked "Creepy Surprised." The drama is cranked up at the outset of
"Death of the Director" to extremely bloated levels, with residual
shades of the same stance occupying "Farewell to a President." The theme
stutters with uncertainty in "There's No Romance in a Dead Rat" and is
expressed muted defiance on strings in "Attorney General," yielding the
four-note descents once more. The almost joyous demeanor in the
rollicking rhythm that opens "End Titles" is problematic for the story,
though Rózsa reduces the idea to muted string drama later in the
cue for a while. He cannot resist building to an awkwardly heroic final
note, though, and the actual credits explode at 3:23 with militaristic
zeal for the theme. For those closing credits, he reprises the "Main
Title" performance yet appends a mandatory but out of place major key
note at its end for near superhero shine; the score simply can't end
like it does and be convincing for the character. Among the secondary
themes in
The Private Files of J. Edgar Hoover, a charging theme
associated with the main one uses marching, upward staccato movements of
relentless focus and pursuit, repeating the same note. Its first two
phrases are five notes followed by staggered two-note answers of
anxiety. This motif opens "Main Title" prior to the primary melody and
returns at 0:37 for suspense, becoming even more powerful with thumping
piano and timpani at 1:58. This representation of prosecutorial zeal
accelerates into a frantic action outburst in the second half of
"Suicide Trap" and remains somewhat influential in the second half of
"The Hijacker" but is not clear enough for a direct connection. It
guides all of "Shredding" with increasing force of will until a swirling
crescendo and takes a snappier stance with snare hits in the opening
minute of "The Bloodhound." Finally, it's lightly ponderous in "There's
No Romance in a Dead Rat."
Rózsa also supplies something of a personal
theme to Hoover, replacing the usual love theme constructs for the
composer with quasi-noir melodramatic appeal. Its predictable,
cyclically rising, falling phrases yearn in "Suspicion" while touching
edges of main theme, that idea's falling four-note phrases overtaking
this melody and shifting the cue right back into the main theme. This
material receives more conventional, less intense attention to begin
"Purse Snatcher," and a clarinet explores the idea almost alone in "And
Finally Purvis Broke." Slightly whimsical in "Hold On" against bassoon
fragments of the main theme, the idea is pleasantly relieving at 0:40
into "The Meeting" but tenuous at the beginning of "Temptation," in
which it builds to a monumentally anguished conclusion. The personal
theme helps guide the less flamboyant drama at the end of "Death of the
Director," is barely warm in the ineffective romance of "Courting?," and
achieves more convincing care in the middle of "End Titles" but is still
only moderately tepid. Two lesser motifs round out the score, starting
with a heroic deeds theme that lives as an almost valiant march at 1:24
into "Purse Snatcher." The composer revisits similar heights in the
brief "R.F.K." with the main theme pulling at the edges. More notably, a
nobility theme is a unique idea of stoic virtue in "Dr. King" that
becomes embroiled in simplistic and deep pulses, and this personality is
reprised in the middle of "Farewell to a President" with a processional
personality from percussion. Rózsa's overall narrative is decent
but not really that compelling. The score is so steeped in his usual
methodology and styles that it earns an average rating for the composer,
but this work is among his least interesting in his "free" era that
ended his career. On album, original Citadel CD album represents the
complete score, adding onto the contents of a 26-minute suite provided
on a 1990 Bay Cities compilation CD. That album also includes music from
Rózsa's scores for
Lydia and
Crisis, both
representing circumstances in which the composer tackled his scores with
only one instrument. While the piano for
Lydia is alluring, the
acoustic guitar for
Crisis is grating. The same presentation was
later re-issued in 2021 and 2026 by BSX Records, though copies of the
original CD product remained readily available on the market. Demand
isn't great for this Rózsa entry, as it represents a somewhat
interesting but not very engaging dramatic entry without the appealing
attributes of his other later scores.
*** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download