| CLOSE WINDOW |
|
FILMTRACKS.COM
PRINTER-FRIENDLY VIEW 
Review of Ronin (Elia Cmiral)
FILMTRACKS RECOMMENDS:
Buy it... if you are attracted to both the edgy orchestrations of
Elliot Goldenthal's thrillers and the slashing techno-inspired rhythms
of Eric Serra's action.
Avoid it... if you expect the substantial chase music to adequately merge with the solemn title theme for duduk and strings, because Elia Cmiral's score never adequately blends the lines of its two distinct halves.
FILMTRACKS EDITORIAL REVIEW:
Ronin: (Elia Cmiral) Director John Frankenheimer's
first universally praised triumph since his classic The Manchurian
Candidate more than three decades earlier, Ronin is among the
most impressive chase movies of the digital era. Filmed in a dreary
France, the biting story of soul-wandering professional agents and
tacticians from various Cold War origins resorting to one mercenary
mission together is something of an excuse for a series of extraordinary
car chases along the charged, personal lines of The French
Connection. A stellar cast highlights both the five mercenaries and
their shady employers, and their gritty performances of writer David
Mamet's uncredited script for Ronin lacks a weak link. While
composer Gary Chang was the usual provider of music for Frankenheimer's
films, the Ronin assignment was reported to be in the hands of
Christopher Young and then Jerry Goldsmith before the latter composer's
last-minute departure from the project left Frankenheimer with
little-known Swedish composer Elia Cmiral. In the ten years since
Ronin, Cmiral has made a career skirting mainstream film scoring
in Hollywood, with a series of B-rate projects rarely as compelling as
his major opening venture. His certainly adequate and occasionally
interesting score for Frankenheimer's project placed him on the map (his
previous notable efforts coming from television). Expectations for his
music for Ronin were non-existent, though Cmiral's composition is
a striking combination of elements that do and don't make much sense.
The concept behind the title is that of the Japanese samurai who failed
to protect their lords from slaying, and who thus were outcasts and,
like the warriors of this film, available for hire. Cmiral does make
some token cultural references to the Japanese and East Asian culture in
his music, mostly centered around the use of Taiko-like drums and sparse
throat singing effects, both evident in the first minute of the opening
"Ronin Theme" cue. The remainder of the ethnicity involves the
performances of the title theme by a duduk, though the choice of the
Armenian clarinet seems a bit awkward in this context.
Without a doubt, the employment of the duduk to perform the simple, but effective theme for the souls of the mercenaries places the spiritual setting of the story at some vague point in history. But, as with the remainder of the performing ensemble, the greatest weakness of the duduk's otherwise solemnly enchanting performances is Cmiral's choice not to develop them well throughout the score's non-thematic majority. The solitary theme is fine as a representation for the five leads, but the statements of this theme, outside of the orchestral accompaniment that breaks the monotony in both "Ronin Theme" and (especially) "Good Knowing You," are too consistent to merit continuous interest. Its appearances in "Thank You," "Et Toi, Comment Ca Va," "The Girl Sold Us Out," and "The Ronin Myth" never grow with the characters. A subtheme of comradery heard in "A New Friendship" and "Passion" is performed on piano, strings, and flute without much interest until the last minute of the latter cue. The majority of the score is a slashing and bleak series of techno-rhythmed chase cues, often dissonant and changing in tempo as necessary to follow the frantic movements on screen. The instrumentation of these cues is marginally interesting for the first few minutes, though after an hour on album, with most of the cues adhering to the same chasing mold, it becomes tiresome. A distinct European sensibility will remind of some of Eric Serra's more electronically frenetic works, though the consistent augmentation of the synthesizers by a reasonable collection of brass and strings will be rewarding for some fans of Elliot Goldenthal's more edgy works. Outside of this mass of suspense and action music, as well as the handful of duduk and string-led performances of the two themes, the score's only remaining notable cue is an irritating carnival march in "Carousel for Little Tamao." While the score serves its purpose, it's a rather frustrating one in that Cmiral had all the elements to make a truly inspiring multi-cultural work but never merged the style or instrumentation of the score's two halves. The lack of this development is exacerbated further by an album that's 20 minutes too long. Overall, there's much to be intrigued about in Ronin, but outside of the closing "Good Knowing You" cue, the score offers little to enjoy on a regular basis. ***
TRACK LISTINGS:
Total Time: 66:17
NOTES & QUOTES:
The album includes the following note about Cmiral from the director,
John Frankenheimer:
Copyright ©
2000-2024, Filmtracks Publications. All rights reserved.
The reviews and other textual content contained on the filmtracks.com site may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without the prior written authority of Christian Clemmensen at Filmtracks Publications. All artwork and sound clips from Ronin are Copyright © 1998, Varèse Sarabande and cannot be redistributed without the label's expressed written consent. Page created 1/11/00 and last updated 4/10/08. |
