Filmtracks Home Page Filmtracks Logo
MODERN SOUNDTRACK REVIEWS
Menu Search
Scoreboard Forum
Hisaishi rundown post #5 - 1990-91: Tasmania Story, A Scene at the Sea

Hisaishi rundown post #5 - 1990-91: Tasmania Story, A Scene at the Sea
JBlough
<Send E-Mail>
(155.201.57.2)
Profile Picture
Monday, October 23, 2023 (5:33 a.m.) 

Last post - https://www.filmtracks.com/scoreboard/forum.cgi?read=128404
See my profile for earlier posts.

-----------------------

As we move into the 1990s, we find Hisaishi now established as a major composer in Japan’s film industry, one quite comfortable with both symphonic and contemporary modes and fluent in both rapturous melody and repetitive minimalism. The elegant piano that was often prominently in the sound mix was practically becoming a calling card for him at this point. That familiarity would start to turn into a double-edged sword at times, as Hisaishi would deliver some works that occasionally recycled elements of his hits of the 1980s; one can’t help but wonder if, like composers in Hollywood once they’ve made a name for themselves, he started getting gigs on the basis of being asked to sound like himself. But he would also start working with new people who would push his music in interesting new directions, including the only director aside from Hayao Miyazaki who would later have albums dedicated to the music Hisaishi wrote for his films. By the end of the decade, he’d won Japan’s equivalent of the Oscar for best original score five times.

---------

Tasmania Story / Tasumania monogatari (1990) - ***

Discovery #14.

Hisaishi’s score for this film about a kid visiting his Tasmanian tiger-obsessed father on (you guessed it) Tasmania is a bit of a mishmash. There’s a lot of electronic and instrumental music that was the first instance of the composer starting to sound a bit stylistically derivative; expect to be reminded of Castle in the Sky and Totoro here and there. On the other hand, there are moments of grandeur, not quite what you get in John Barry’s Out of Africa or Georges Delerue’s woefully underheard The African, but still fairly sweeping. The album will reward your patience as towards its end you’ll find some marvelous orchestral outbursts related to the score’s lullaby waltz theme. As with 1989’s The Universe Within, the final theme suite from the album will be enough for most listeners. Hisaishi would return to it on two albums done over the next two years, including a grand arrangement for a 1992 concert complete with a John Williams-like coda.

At the time, Japan’s Academy Film Prize (comparable to America’s Academy Award) was awarded to composers for their output across the entire year, and Hisaishi’s work on this - along with three other scores from 1989 and 1990, none of which got album releases - secured him his first nomination for the award.

Score album - https://open.spotify.com/album/7kmtT5rXCDUYvUC6RhVkuQ?si=hJqrL0NxRBKB6NIVYjWx4A

-----------------------

Chizuko’s Younger Sister / Futari (1991) - *½

Discovery #15.

Hisaishi reunited with Nobuhiko Obayashi, the director of The Drifting Classroom, for a drama about a girl who encounters the ghost of her dead sibling…or does she? At its most pleasant, the score’s use of synthetic pan flute evokes what Hans Zimmer sounded like when he channeled Morricone in his earlier days, an element that had also factored into a few parts of the earlier Tasmania Story. Alas, the pitfalls of Hans’ early days also come to mind, as the suspenseful moments are oddly generic and hard on the ears, particularly the bass pulses and the painful moments of sampled strings which give the film a cheap “TV movie of the week” vibe. The weaker parts of Tasmania Story sound like an orchestra by comparison, and the twelfth album track features shrill chirps that rival The Dragon’s Den from the Castle in the Sky image album as one of the most obnoxious sequences the composer ever wrote.

In a time when Hisaishi’s CDs usually ran well under an hour, it was by far the longest Hisaishi album to date, with a 74-minute runtime not justified by its content that somehow created a worse listening experience than what we got for The Drifting Classroom four years earlier. Fans (if they exist) may grumble that I forgot to mention the occasional use of the composer’s trademark elegant piano sounds, but there are umpteen other, better scores for scratching that itch.

Still, the composer came up with a decent-enough theme that evokes a sense of longing, almost like a sad warm-up act to a similar idea he would realize in superior fashion in an animated film the following year. In 1997 he rearranged it for his album Works I with the LPO, delivering an enchanting five minutes of soulful strings, impressive woodwind harmonies, and even some solo harp. It’s a miracle that anything like that emerged from this dreadfully mundane score.

Score album - https://youtu.be/KM_XbsUIAP4?si=VkxoTDZ38GrU_1gV
Works I Two of Us - https://open.spotify.com/track/5AVF8tfzO0M4uoxRAFFDEm?si=07cc37f948c645fa

-----------------------

I Am (1991) - Not rated

Discovery #16.

The first of several albums / scores Hisaishi worked on at Abbey Road in London. Most of the tracks appear to be original creations (at least in name), though the opening piece is credited as the main theme from the 1991 film Deer Friend and another piece covers material from Tasmania Story. Of the few tracks I could find, the final piece is by far the best, with the composer lacing his pop-orchestral mannerisms with some of the in-your-face romanticism of Georges Delerue.

The CD’s most intriguing element is its cover which features a photo of the composer from when he still had hair!

Deer’s Wind - https://youtu.be/GYb_US-egnE?si=trFsQh0di-_l38lY
Silencio de Parc Güell - https://youtu.be/9Ictwigy-98?si=8lHtXBFjPHhsv2HB
White Island - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lZZdddjDDIw

-----------------------

A Scene at the Sea / Ano natsu, ichiban shizukana umi (1991) - ****½

Discovery #17.

Actor-director Takeshi Kitano pivoted after helming two crime films to a less violent (but no less tragic) drama about a deaf couple and how their lives are changed by the discovery of a surfboard. “My [prior films didn’t get] good reviews. My producer advised me to work with Joe Hisaishi, a renowned composer. I accepted because it was a positive thing for the film. I showed Hisaishi some images from the film and I asked him to do the music, giving him a free hand. His music helped a lot. If this film works, it owes a lot to Hisaishi’s music. It really is a great tune.”

After years of Hisaishi tinkering with the kind of minimalism and electronics that Terry Riley and Ryuichi Sakamoto had popularized, including only two years earlier with The Universe Within, on A Scene at the Sea he finally found a version of that sound that was undeniably his own. Taking a simple theme and weaving it over hypnotic repeated percussion, guitar, violin solos blown in from Curved Air, new age vocal duets, the composer’s own keyboard playing, and whatever sounds he could summon from his Fairlight synthesizer, Hisaishi whipped up a soothing, engaging, and utterly unique love theme, its lengthy album-opening arrangement Silent Love one of the essential film score tracks of 1991. Hisaishi returned to the idea several times but also balanced out the listening experience with a soulful secondary waltz theme, several contemporary jazz interludes, and one ultra-cool climactic surfing track.

This is not one of those expansive Studio Ghibli scores that the composer is best known for today, and some of the work’s synthetic elements may wear on some listeners; the mostly fun Bus Stop has some moments of imitation ensemble noise that haven’t aged well, and the first half of the short track Next Is My Turn has some cheap-sounding suspense material that evokes the lesser portions of Chizuko’s Younger Sister. But the rest of the album is a contemporary-sounding triumph, even if a low-key one, and it more than capably captures the soul of the movie, one that has very little vocal dialogue and is thus more reliant on music for its emotional core than the average film. Six years later the composer put together a marvelous orchestral arrangement, one which has some impressive horn counterpoint, but at best it can only be considered complementary to the original recording’s beguiling mix of sounds.

A Scene at the Sea started to change opinions in Japan about Kitano (already famous as a TV comedian) as a director, securing nominations for best film, directing, screenplay, and editing at the Japan Academy Prize awards. The association also awarded Hisaisahi best composer for this along with the rest of his 1991 output.

It would also nail down the template for Kitano’s next few collaborations with Hisaishi. If you want to understand how we got to more well-known works like Sonatine and Fireworks, you have to start here.

Score album - https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSP_sMZH6pQ0JkQKiMyXsMWjYlSXI5HZm&si=mpMpa3IvrDazFuGJ
Works I Silent Love - https://open.spotify.com/track/1PZb0CAIjzu1BCu3mx3SAp?si=37f5aa1bf738459e
Original Silent Love arrangement - https://open.spotify.com/track/2BvkrhRz7dzf87oJS9ucLQ?si=f4699804f617453b

-----------------------

Next time: “I'd rather be a pig than a fascist.”



Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
JLFM
  Responses to this Message:
Christian Kühn
Riley KZ
JLFM


Re: Hisaishi rundown post #5
Christian Kühn
(tmo-071-33.customers.d1-online.co
m)
Profile Picture
Tuesday, October 24, 2023 (5:21 a.m.) 
Now Playing: Dead Again (P. Doyle, LLL release, ***1/2)

> Six years later the composer put together a marvelous
> orchestral arrangement, one which has some impressive
> horn counterpoint, but at best it can only be considered
> complementary to the original recording’s beguiling mix of
> sounds.

Thanks for emphasizing this, Jon. I’ve had the Works I album for a decade-and-a-half, but I’ll pay extra attention to this track next time I’ll be playing it.

Fascinating read, as always! 🙂

CK


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
Riley KZ
  Responses to this Message:
Riley KZ


Re: Hisaishi rundown post #5
Riley KZ
<Send E-Mail>
(ip-104-224-127-142.xplore.ca)
Profile Picture
Tuesday, October 24, 2023 (7:07 a.m.) 

> Thanks for emphasizing this, Jon. I’ve had the Works I album for a
> decade-and-a-half, but I’ll pay extra attention to this track next time
> I’ll be playing it.

> Fascinating read, as always! 🙂

> CK

Also Kuhni, check out the Movie Theme Quiz this week, I have a Hisaishi on there I thought would tickle your pickles.


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
Christian Kühn
  Responses to this Message:
Riley KZ


Re: Hisaishi rundown post #5 - 1990-91: Tasmania Story, A Scene at the Sea
Riley KZ
<Send E-Mail>
(ip-104-224-127-142.xplore.ca)
Profile Picture
Tuesday, October 24, 2023 (7:06 a.m.) 

> Last post - https://www.filmtracks.com/scoreboard/forum.cgi?read=128404
> See my profile for earlier posts.

> -----------------------

> As we move into the 1990s, we find Hisaishi now established as a major
> composer in Japan’s film industry, one quite comfortable with both
> symphonic and contemporary modes and fluent in both rapturous melody and
> repetitive minimalism. The elegant piano that was often prominently in the
> sound mix was practically becoming a calling card for him at this point.
> That familiarity would start to turn into a double-edged sword at times,
> as Hisaishi would deliver some works that occasionally recycled elements
> of his hits of the 1980s; one can’t help but wonder if, like composers in
> Hollywood once they’ve made a name for themselves, he started getting gigs
> on the basis of being asked to sound like himself. But he would also start
> working with new people who would push his music in interesting new
> directions, including the only director aside from Hayao Miyazaki who
> would later have albums dedicated to the music Hisaishi wrote for his
> films. By the end of the decade, he’d won Japan’s equivalent of the Oscar
> for best original score five times.

> ---------

> Tasmania Story / Tasumania monogatari (1990) - ***

> Discovery #14.

> Hisaishi’s score for this film about a kid visiting his Tasmanian
> tiger-obsessed father on (you guessed it) Tasmania is a bit of a mishmash.
> There’s a lot of electronic and instrumental music that was the first
> instance of the composer starting to sound a bit stylistically derivative;
> expect to be reminded of Castle in the Sky and Totoro here
> and there. On the other hand, there are moments of grandeur, not quite
> what you get in John Barry’s Out of Africa or Georges Delerue’s
> woefully underheard The African, but still fairly sweeping. The
> album will reward your patience as towards its end you’ll find some
> marvelous orchestral outbursts related to the score’s lullaby waltz theme.
> As with 1989’s The Universe Within, the final theme suite from the
> album will be enough for most listeners. Hisaishi would return to it on
> two albums done over the next two years, including a grand arrangement for
> a 1992 concert complete with a John Williams-like coda.

> At the time, Japan’s Academy Film Prize (comparable to America’s Academy
> Award) was awarded to composers for their output across the entire year,
> and Hisaishi’s work on this - along with three other scores from 1989 and
> 1990, none of which got album releases - secured him his first nomination
> for the award.

> Score album -
> https://open.spotify.com/album/7kmtT5rXCDUYvUC6RhVkuQ?si=hJqrL0NxRBKB6NIVYjWx4A

> -----------------------

> Chizuko’s Younger Sister / Futari (1991) - *½

> Discovery #15.

> Hisaishi reunited with Nobuhiko Obayashi, the director of The Drifting
> Classroom
, for a drama about a girl who encounters the ghost of her
> dead sibling…or does she? At its most pleasant, the score’s use of
> synthetic pan flute evokes what Hans Zimmer sounded like when he channeled
> Morricone in his earlier days, an element that had also factored into a
> few parts of the earlier Tasmania Story. Alas, the pitfalls of
> Hans’ early days also come to mind, as the suspenseful moments are oddly
> generic and hard on the ears, particularly the bass pulses and the painful
> moments of sampled strings which give the film a cheap “TV movie of the
> week” vibe. The weaker parts of Tasmania Story sound like an
> orchestra by comparison, and the twelfth album track features shrill
> chirps that rival The Dragon’s Den from the Castle in the
> Sky
image album as one of the most obnoxious sequences the composer
> ever wrote.

> In a time when Hisaishi’s CDs usually ran well under an hour, it was by
> far the longest Hisaishi album to date, with a 74-minute runtime
> not justified by its content that somehow created a worse listening
> experience than what we got for The Drifting Classroom four years
> earlier. Fans (if they exist) may grumble that I forgot to mention the
> occasional use of the composer’s trademark elegant piano sounds, but there
> are umpteen other, better scores for scratching that itch.

> Still, the composer came up with a decent-enough theme that evokes a sense
> of longing, almost like a sad warm-up act to a similar idea he would
> realize in superior fashion in an animated film the following year. In
> 1997 he rearranged it for his album Works I with the LPO,
> delivering an enchanting five minutes of soulful strings, impressive
> woodwind harmonies, and even some solo harp. It’s a miracle that anything
> like that emerged from this dreadfully mundane score.

> Score album - https://youtu.be/KM_XbsUIAP4?si=VkxoTDZ38GrU_1gV
> Works I Two of Us -
> https://open.spotify.com/track/5AVF8tfzO0M4uoxRAFFDEm?si=07cc37f948c645fa

> -----------------------

> I Am (1991) - Not rated

> Discovery #16.

> The first of several albums / scores Hisaishi worked on at Abbey Road in
> London. Most of the tracks appear to be original creations (at least in
> name), though the opening piece is credited as the main theme from the
> 1991 film Deer Friend and another piece covers material from
> Tasmania Story. Of the few tracks I could find, the final piece is
> by far the best, with the composer lacing his pop-orchestral mannerisms
> with some of the in-your-face romanticism of Georges Delerue.

> The CD’s most intriguing element is its cover which features a photo of
> the composer from when he still had hair!

> Deer’s Wind - https://youtu.be/GYb_US-egnE?si=trFsQh0di-_l38lY
> Silencio de Parc Güell -
> https://youtu.be/9Ictwigy-98?si=8lHtXBFjPHhsv2HB
> White Island - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lZZdddjDDIw

> -----------------------

> A Scene at the Sea / Ano natsu, ichiban shizukana umi (1991) -
> ****½

> Discovery #17.

> Actor-director Takeshi Kitano pivoted after helming two crime films to a
> less violent (but no less tragic) drama about a deaf couple and how their
> lives are changed by the discovery of a surfboard. “My [prior films didn’t
> get] good reviews. My producer advised me to work with Joe Hisaishi, a
> renowned composer. I accepted because it was a positive thing for the
> film. I showed Hisaishi some images from the film and I asked him to do
> the music, giving him a free hand. His music helped a lot. If this film
> works, it owes a lot to Hisaishi’s music. It really is a great tune.”

> After years of Hisaishi tinkering with the kind of minimalism and
> electronics that Terry Riley and Ryuichi Sakamoto had popularized,
> including only two years earlier with The Universe Within, on A
> Scene at the Sea
he finally found a version of that sound that was
> undeniably his own. Taking a simple theme and weaving it over hypnotic
> repeated percussion, guitar, violin solos blown in from Curved Air,
> new age vocal duets, the composer’s own keyboard playing, and whatever
> sounds he could summon from his Fairlight synthesizer, Hisaishi whipped up
> a soothing, engaging, and utterly unique love theme, its lengthy
> album-opening arrangement Silent Love one of the essential
> film score tracks of 1991. Hisaishi returned to the idea several times but
> also balanced out the listening experience with a soulful secondary waltz
> theme, several contemporary jazz interludes, and one ultra-cool climactic
> surfing track.

> This is not one of those expansive Studio Ghibli scores that the composer
> is best known for today, and some of the work’s synthetic elements may
> wear on some listeners; the mostly fun Bus Stop has some moments of
> imitation ensemble noise that haven’t aged well, and the first half of the
> short track Next Is My Turn has some cheap-sounding suspense
> material that evokes the lesser portions of Chizuko’s Younger
> Sister
. But the rest of the album is a contemporary-sounding triumph,
> even if a low-key one, and it more than capably captures the soul of the
> movie, one that has very little vocal dialogue and is thus more reliant on
> music for its emotional core than the average film. Six years later the
> composer put together a marvelous orchestral arrangement, one which has
> some impressive horn counterpoint, but at best it can only be considered
> complementary to the original recording’s beguiling mix of sounds.

> A Scene at the Sea started to change opinions in Japan about Kitano
> (already famous as a TV comedian) as a director, securing nominations for
> best film, directing, screenplay, and editing at the Japan Academy Prize
> awards. The association also awarded Hisaisahi best composer for this
> along with the rest of his 1991 output.

> It would also nail down the template for Kitano’s next few collaborations
> with Hisaishi. If you want to understand how we got to more well-known
> works like Sonatine and Fireworks, you have to start here.

> Score album -
> https://youtube.com/playlist?list=PLSP_sMZH6pQ0JkQKiMyXsMWjYlSXI5HZm&si=mpMpa3IvrDazFuGJ
> Works I Silent Love -
> https://open.spotify.com/track/1PZb0CAIjzu1BCu3mx3SAp?si=37f5aa1bf738459e
> Original Silent Love arrangement -
> https://open.spotify.com/track/2BvkrhRz7dzf87oJS9ucLQ?si=f4699804f617453b

> -----------------------

> Next time: “I'd rather be a pig than a fascist.”

Excellent write up as always bud. Haven't heard of any of these but now must find Scene at the Sea.


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
JBlough
  Responses to this Message:
JBlough


Re: Hisaishi rundown post #5 - 1990-91: Tasmania Story, A Scene at the Sea
JBlough
<Send E-Mail>
(155.201.57.2)
Profile Picture
Tuesday, October 24, 2023 (9:07 a.m.) 

> Excellent write up as always bud. Haven't heard of any of these but now must find Scene at the Sea.

It is odd that only some of the Kitano / Hisaishi collaborations are available on U.S. digital / streaming services. Sonatine used to be but now isn't. Brother was probably CD only here, courtesy of Silva Screen. Kikujiro and Fireworks are still around. A Scene at the Sea may never have received a U.S. release of any sort.

So...thank goodness for YouTube!



Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
Riley KZ
  Responses to this Message:
JBlough


Re: Hisaishi rundown post #5 - 1990-91: Tasmania Story, A Scene at the Sea
JLFM
<Send E-Mail>
(38.41.63.122)
Profile Picture
Tuesday, October 24, 2023 (10:56 a.m.) 
Now Playing: Anima Mundi (Philip Glass)

> Tasmania Story / Tasumania monogatari (1990) - ***

> Chizuko’s Younger Sister / Futari (1991) - *½

I have both of these rated at a full star higher than you, but I agree with your general assessments. Like you mentioned, Tasmania Story definitely exists in that Totoro soundscape (even if it's not on the same level), and I recommend it to fans of that score.

> A Scene at the Sea / Ano natsu, ichiban shizukana umi (1991) -
> ****½

In general, I haven't really heard Hisaishi's scores for the Kitano films (with one or two exceptions), and that goes for this one as well. It was already on my radar but this makes me even more excited to get to it!


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
JBlough
  Responses to this Message:
JBlough


Re: Hisaishi rundown post #5 - 1990-91: Tasmania Story, A Scene at the Sea
JBlough
<Send E-Mail>
(155.201.57.2)
Profile Picture
Tuesday, October 24, 2023 (11:13 a.m.) 

> In general, I haven't really heard Hisaishi's scores for the Kitano films (with one or two exceptions), and that goes for this one as well. It was already on my radar but this makes me even more excited to get to it!

I think I heard it once in undergrad and dismissed it immediately, probably because of how electronic it was. How times change...


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
JLFM
  Responses to this Message:
JBlough

  • Return to Top (Full Menu) ▲
  • © 1998-2025, Filmtracks Publications