Filmtracks Home Page Filmtracks Logo
MODERN SOUNDTRACK REVIEWS
Menu Search
Scoreboard Forum
Should Powell score the live action HTTYD sequels?

Should Powell score the live action HTTYD sequels?
Steven P.
(syn-050-089-024-100.res.spectrum.
com)
Profile Picture
Thursday, July 31, 2025 (2:56 p.m.) 
Now Playing: F1 - Zimmer

We had some heated debates here about Powell's score for the live-action reboot of How to Train You Dragon, so I wanted some time to pass before getting to the subject of the sequels (although I can hear some of you already yelling "TOO SOON" at your screens).

With the financial success of the first film, the next 2 live action sequels are all but certain. So my question is if you think Powell should score them.

It goes without saying the I think Powell should do what he wants. I certainly understand the appeal of wanting to revisit some of his most popular and beloved music and explore ways to update and play with the material. However, I also feel it comes at the expense of having him working on something original and exciting.

I think my preference would be to continue to have Powell involved in some capacity, but having someone else (maybe a former assistant) take on the main scoring duties. Powell's music is a crucial part of what makes the animated films so great so that continuity is needed, but it could be neat to hear another composer working with the material while still keeping continuity with the themes and style. If any new themes are being considered depending on changes made to these sequels, perhaps Powell could write those (or a situation similar to Chamber of Secrets).

Thoughts?


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
Riley KZ
  Responses to this Message:
jjstarA113
Riley KZ


Re: Should Powell score the live action HTTYD sequels?
jjstarA113
<Send E-Mail>
(syn-071-070-205-217.res.spectrum.
com)
Thursday, July 31, 2025 (6:13 p.m.) 
Now Playing: Henry Jackman - Smurfs

> We had some heated debates here about Powell's score for the live-action
> reboot of How to Train You Dragon, so I wanted some time to pass before
> getting to the subject of the sequels (although I can hear some of you
> already yelling 'TOO SOON' at your screens).

> With the financial success of the first film, the next 2 live action
> sequels are all but certain. So my question is if you think Powell should
> score them.

> It goes without saying the I think Powell should do what he wants. I
> certainly understand the appeal of wanting to revisit some of his most
> popular and beloved music and explore ways to update and play with the
> material. However, I also feel it comes at the expense of having him
> working on something original and exciting.

> I think my preference would be to continue to have Powell involved in some
> capacity, but having someone else (maybe a former assistant) take on the
> main scoring duties. Powell's music is a crucial part of what makes the
> animated films so great so that continuity is needed, but it could be neat
> to hear another composer working with the material while still keeping
> continuity with the themes and style. If any new themes are being
> considered depending on changes made to these sequels, perhaps Powell
> could write those (or a situation similar to Chamber of Secrets).

> Thoughts?

Many times I've had the thought of Powell passing the live-action franchise onto Batu Sener on a whim. Naturally Powell would still stick around as a consultant (as was the case on Sener's Harold and the Purple Crayon), and potentially, as you said, provide some new themes where necessary.


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
Steven P.
  Responses to this Message:
Steven P.


Re: Should Powell score the live action HTTYD sequels?
Steven P.
(syn-050-089-024-100.res.spectrum.
com)
Profile Picture
Thursday, July 31, 2025 (7:03 p.m.) 

> Many times I've had the thought of Powell passing the live-action
> franchise onto Batu Sener on a whim. Naturally Powell would still stick
> around as a consultant (as was the case on Sener's Harold and the
> Purple Crayon
), and potentially, as you said, provide some new themes
> where necessary.

Yeah, I think that's a good win-win scenario.


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
jjstarA113
  Responses to this Message:
Steven P.


Re: Should Powell score the live action HTTYD sequels?
Riley KZ
<Send E-Mail>
(d50-99-93-229.abhsia.telus.net)
Profile Picture
Thursday, July 31, 2025 (6:35 p.m.) 

> We had some heated debates here about Powell's score for the live-action
> reboot of How to Train You Dragon, so I wanted some time to pass before
> getting to the subject of the sequels (although I can hear some of you
> already yelling 'TOO SOON' at your screens).

> With the financial success of the first film, the next 2 live action
> sequels are all but certain. So my question is if you think Powell should
> score them.

> It goes without saying the I think Powell should do what he wants. I
> certainly understand the appeal of wanting to revisit some of his most
> popular and beloved music and explore ways to update and play with the
> material. However, I also feel it comes at the expense of having him
> working on something original and exciting.

> I think my preference would be to continue to have Powell involved in some
> capacity, but having someone else (maybe a former assistant) take on the
> main scoring duties. Powell's music is a crucial part of what makes the
> animated films so great so that continuity is needed, but it could be neat
> to hear another composer working with the material while still keeping
> continuity with the themes and style. If any new themes are being
> considered depending on changes made to these sequels, perhaps Powell
> could write those (or a situation similar to Chamber of Secrets).

> Thoughts?

Absolutely - not just because more Powell is always a good thing (even with something as controversial and complained about/fought over as HTYYD2025), but because the sequels don't have NEARLY the legacy and love that the first one does. Which means they'll actually change a substantial amount. Which means...MORE NEW MUSIC!


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
Edmund Meinerts
  Responses to this Message:
Steven P.
Edmund Meinerts


Re: Should Powell score the live action HTTYD sequels?
Steven P.
(syn-050-089-024-100.res.spectrum.
com)
Profile Picture
Thursday, July 31, 2025 (7:03 p.m.) 

> Absolutely - not just because more Powell is always a good thing (even
> with something as controversial and complained about/fought over as
> HTYYD2025), but because the sequels don't have NEARLY the legacy and love
> that the first one does. Which means they'll actually change a substantial
> amount. Which means...MORE NEW MUSIC!

I'm not so sure. If they can make a ton of money without having to change the formula, why would they? I mean, that seems to be the mindset of Hollywood these days. I'd be surprised if less than 80% of the sequels isn't the same as the animated films.


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
Riley KZ
  Responses to this Message:
Steven P.
Edmund Meinerts


Re: Should Powell score the live action HTTYD sequels?
Edmund Meinerts
<Send E-Mail>
(p5497b027.dip0.t-ipconnect.de)
Profile Picture
Thursday, July 31, 2025 (10:22 p.m.) 

> Absolutely - not just because more Powell is always a good thing (even
> with something as controversial and complained about/fought over as
> HTYYD2025), but because the sequels don't have NEARLY the legacy and love
> that the first one does. Which means they'll actually change a substantial
> amount. Which means...MORE NEW MUSIC!

It means less new music. Any time Powell spends on these is time he isn't spending on something 100% new. So sure, maybe the sequel live actions will be more like 50-50 rather than the 20-80 balance we got the first time around, but 50 is still less than 100.


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
Riley KZ
  Responses to this Message:
Riley KZ


Re: Should Powell score the live action HTTYD sequels?
Riley KZ
<Send E-Mail>
(d50-99-93-229.abhsia.telus.net)
Profile Picture
Friday, August 1, 2025 (4:47 p.m.) 

> It means less new music. Any time Powell spends on these is time he isn't
> spending on something 100% new. So sure, maybe the sequel live actions
> will be more like 50-50 rather than the 20-80 balance we got the first
> time around, but 50 is still less than 100.

I'd agree if the dude was scoring a bunch of big budget adventure scores every year, but...that's not accurate at all. Dude is either doing small things like a Michael J Fox doc or small things like Don't Worry Darling and then returning to the big stuff we love when it's Dragons. I don't really think, if he refused to score the sequels, we would have them replaced with other Powell music - especially in this vein.


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
Steven P.
  Responses to this Message:
Steven P.


Re: Should Powell score the live action HTTYD sequels?
Steven P.
(syn-050-089-024-100.res.spectrum.
com)
Profile Picture
Saturday, August 2, 2025 (8:33 a.m.) 
Now Playing: War of the Worlds - Williams

> I'd agree if the dude was scoring a bunch of big budget adventure scores
> every year, but...that's not accurate at all. Dude is either doing small
> things like a Michael J Fox doc or small things like Don't Worry Darling
> and then returning to the big stuff we love when it's Dragons. I don't
> really think, if he refused to score the sequels, we would have them
> replaced with other Powell music - especially in this vein.

We still have Wicked part 1 & 2.

Also, whenever Disney gets around to making more Star Wars films, they could do a lot worse than having Powell pick up the baton from Williams after Solo. Hey, a guy can dream, right?


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
jjstarA113
  Responses to this Message:
jjstarA113


Re: Should Powell score the live action HTTYD sequels?
jjstarA113
<Send E-Mail>
(192.145.118.94)
Saturday, August 2, 2025 (5:26 p.m.) 
Now Playing: KPop Demon Hunters (Soundtrack from the Netflix Film)

> We still have Wicked part 1 & 2.

> Also, whenever Disney gets around to making more Star Wars films, they
> could do a lot worse than having Powell pick up the baton from Williams
> after Solo. Hey, a guy can dream, right?

And hopefully Wicked: For Good brings it in the action-adventure department after the relatively low-key score for Act I.

Considering Laura Karpman's rising star and that director Sharmeen Obaid-Chinoy has worked with her previously on two episodes of Ms. Marvel and the short film Sitara: Let Girls Dream, it's very likely that Karpman could be scoring the upcoming Rey movie. But if it's neither her nor Williams...please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please please big grin.


Post Full Response
Edit Post         Threaded Display
  In Response to:
Steven P.
  Responses to this Message:
jjstarA113

  • Return to Top (Full Menu) ▲
  • © 1998-2025, Filmtracks Publications