Filmtracks Home Page Filmtracks Logo
MODERN SOUNDTRACK REVIEWS
Menu Search
Scoreboard Forum
Craig - My Top Ten (JBlough 2019)

Craig - My Top Ten (JBlough 2019)
JBlough
<Send E-Mail>
(155.201.42.12)
Profile Picture
Thursday, January 23, 2020 (1:44 p.m.) 

1. How To Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World
2. Godzilla: King of the Monsters
3. Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker
4. Shazam!
5. Lost in Space Season 2
6. Our Planet
7. Little Women
8. Spider-Man: Far From Home
9. Maleficent: Mistress of Evil
10. Cliffs of Freedom
Composer of the year: Bear McCreary

1-3 get *****. 4-10 get ****½. The runner-up is Dream Factory / Traumfabrik. Outlander S4 and Rim of the World contended, but the closing duo of ‘Milou’s Dream’ and the eponymous suite sealed the deal.

The rest of my top 20: Aladdin, Avengers: Endgame, Captain Marvel, CyberWork and the American Dream, Masquerade Hotel, Swoon, Untamed Romania

Other ****: Doctor of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Good Omens, A Hidden Life, His Dark Materials Season 1, The Professor and the Madman

***½ (round up to 4) works: Dora and the Lost City of Gold, Dumbo, Game of Thrones Season 8, Knives Out, Minuscule: Mandibles From Far Away, Sordo / The (Silent) War, Zwingli

***½ (round down to 3) works: Child’s Play, Erica, The Mandalorian Season 1, The Man Who Killed Hitler and Then the Bigfoot

***: Charlie's Angels, Children of the Sea, Greedfall, It Chapter Two, Ni No Kuni: The Movie, The Secret Life of Pets 2

Random thoughts:
2019 was a middle-of-the-pack year relative to the rest of the decade. It was superior to 2016 or 2011 but nowhere near 2018 or 2014, though the year’s top 3 scores are all in my top 150 all time. I rated 43 scores from works released in 2019 (including four that I didn’t get to until this month), which was a bit higher than last year’s count.

I liked enough of the music from The Mandalorian, though portions were certainly PANTS. The weaker The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance got one listen on Spotify which wasn’t enough for a rating (probably ***, though I’m not interested in a 2+ hour repeat).

Favorite track: ‘Shazam!’ from Shazam!, closely followed by ‘Portals’ from Avengers: Endgame

Composer of the year was an easy decision. I gave at least ***½ to all 6 McCreary scores I heard, though I skipped the unenthusiastically received albums for Eli and See and, like most of America, I didn’t know the first/only season of Proven Innocent aired.

2019 specialty releases:
Favorite specialty album released in 2019 is a tricky one to pick. There was no slam dunk.
- All LLL boxes are well-produced, but not every featured score is terrific (e.g., all the Apes sequel scores).
- Superman, Lonesome Dove, A Man Called Peter, and Masters of the Universe lack much in the way of “net new” material.
- The “film versions” of the scores for King Rat, Monsignor, and especially The Thin Red Line are not better listening experiences.
- Air Force One was fun to get in complete form but still registers as a mid-tier 90’s Goldsmith action score.

My individual album pick is a tie between Intrada’s releases of Apollo 13 and An American Tail. Both are for excellent scores, feature significant new material, and contain great liner notes. My runner-up pick is the superb restoration work done on The Bride of Frankenstein by La-La Land.

My box set vote goes to Kritzerland’s Henry King at Fox. RIP Nick Redman.

Older stuff:
I would be remiss if I didn’t cite the many composers whose film outputs I was largely or entirely unfamiliar with before this year: Richard Addinsell, John Addison, William Alwyn, Daniele Amfitheatrof, Jeff Alexander, Malcolm Arnold, Georges Auric, Arthur Benjamin, Richard Rodney Bennett, Lord Berners, Stanley Black, Roy Budd, Mark Chait, Francis Chagrin, Andrew Cottee, Benjamin Frankel, Dave Grusin, Christopher Gunning, Neal Hefti, Kenyon Hopkins, Gottfried Huppertz, Constant Lambert, Leighton Lucas, Nathaniel Mechaly, Philipp Noll, Riz Ortolani, Clifton Parker, André Previn, Alan Rawsthorne, Nelson Riddle, Gerard Schurmann, the Sherman Brothers (and, by extension, Irwin Kostal), David Shire, Mischa Spoliansky, and Ralph Vaughan Williams. Most of these discoveries were due to the Chandos Movies series. FSM’s MGM Soundtrack Treasury was also impactful.

New listens to older scores/compilations (214 entries) was a bit higher than my 2018 listening (199 entries). No new classical albums were played last year (vs. 95 in 2018), though I did get to plenty of Chicago classical music concerts. Better luck in 2020, classical music albums!

The top 10 older scores I discovered last year are ranked below while the rest are subsequently ordered alphabetically within rating tiers. Anything I found via Chandos is in bold text...and yes, dear reader, there is a lot of bold text below.

*****
1. The Keys of the Kingdom (1944) - Alfred Newman
2. Mary Poppins (1964) – songs by The Sherman Brothers; score & song arrangements by Irwin Kostal
3. Raise the Titanic (1980) - John Barry
4. The Bridge on the River Kwai (1957) - Malcolm Arnold
5. Return to Oz (1985) - David Shire
6. Scott of the Antarctic (1948) – Ralph Vaughan Williams
7. Metropolis (1927) - Gottfried Huppertz

****½
8. Dark City (1998) - Trevor Jones
9. Hobson’s Choice (1954) - Malcolm Arnold
10. Love is a Many-Splendored Thing (1955) - Alfred Newman
Runner-up: Lawman (1971) - Jerry Fielding

****1/2 (round up to 5) scores
Bitter Springs (1950) – Ralph Vaughan Williams & Ernest Irving
The Bride Wore Black (1968) – Bernard Herrmann
A Bridge Too Far (1977) – John Addison
The Fallen Idol (1948) – William Alwyn
The Flemish Farm (1943) – Ralph Vaughan Williams
49th Parallel (1941) – Ralph Vaughan Williams
Godzilla (1954) - Akira Ifukube
The History of Mr. Polly (1949) – William Alwyn
The Inn of the Sixth Happiness (1958) - Malcolm Arnold
Lady Caroline Lamb (1972) – Richard Rodney Bennett
Lifeforce (1985) - Henry Mancini
The Loves of Joanna Godden (1947) – Ralph Vaughan Williams
Odd Man Out (1947) – William Alwyn
Shogun (1980) - Maurice Jarre
Wee Geordie (1955) - William Alwyn

****1/2 (round down to 4) scores
Advise and Consent (1962) - Jerry Fielding
Beastmaster 2: Through the Portal of Time (1991) - Robert Folk
Boy on a Dolphin (1957) - Hugo Friedhofer
Burma Victory (1945) – Alan Rawsthorne
The Captive Heart (1946) - Alan Rawsthorne
A Christmas Carol / Scrooge (1951) - Richard Addinsell
Cold Lazarus (1996) - Christopher Gunning
David Copperfield (1969) - Malcolm Arnold
The England of Elizabeth (1957) - Ralph Vaughan Williams
Far From The Madding Crowd (1967) - Richard Rodney Bennett
The French Revolution: Years of Hope (1989) - Georges Delerue
The French Revolution: Years of Rage (1989) - Georges Delerue
Greyfriars Bobby (1961) - Francis Chagrin
The Man Who Would Be King (1975) - Maurice Jarre
Masters of the Universe (1987) - Bill Conti
Merchant Seamen (1940) – Constant Lambert
95 (2017) - Panu Aaltio
Oliver Twist (1948) – Arnold Bax
The Orville Season 1 (2017) - Bruce Broughton, Joel McNeely, John Debney & Andrew Cottee
Suicide Squadron / Dangerous Moonlight (1941) - Richard Addinsell

Breakdown of acquisitions by type:
- New (pre-2018): 133

- Compilation rerecording: 29 - mostly Chandos, plus Nonesuch’s Music From The Films Of François Truffaut and Kritzerland’s Unchained Melodies/Holiday Set

- Legitimate purchase of score I previously had: 16 - Air Force One, The Big Country, Innerspace, The Last Starfighter, Legend (US rejected/Europe cut), Lonesome Dove, Monsignor, The Polar Express, Predator, Princess Mononoke, Spirited Away, Star Trek (2009), Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered Country, Superman IV: The Quest for Peace, Superman: The Movie, and 3:10 to Yuma (2007)

- Film recording of score I already had LP recording or rerecording of: 9 - Body Heat, Breakfast at Tiffany’s, The Bride of Frankenstein, Charade, Conan the Barbarian (1982), King Rat, Lost Horizon (1937), Two for the Road, and The Valley of Gwangi

- Expansion of previously owned score: 7 - An American Tail, Apollo 13, Cinema Paradiso, Minority Report, Schindler's List, The Thin Red Line, and The World Is Not Enough.

- Compilation: 7 - LLL's Potter, Apes, and Quinn Martin v1 sets; Kritzerland’s Henry King at Fox; FSM’s United Artists & MGM v1 Western sets; and...shudders...the VS Film Music Festival Krakow 2016 pre-show CD...NEVER BUY THIS, PEOPLE

- 2018 score acquired in 2019: 7 - BlacKkKlansman, First Man, Mary Poppins Returns, Otros Mundos, Ralph Breaks the Internet, and Watership Down in January; Bumblebee later

- Additional recording: 3 - Tadlow’s Obsession, Tribute’s Fahrenheit 451, and the Symphonic Suite for Arion

- LP recording of score I already had film recording of: 1 - FSM’s I Spy Vol. 2

- Concert: 1 - Maurice Jarre at the Royal Festival Hall

- Non-score album by film composer: 1 - Hisaishi’s Minima_Rhythm 2


Threaded Display
  In Response to:
Riley KZ
  Responses to this Message:
Craig Richard Lysy
Riley KZ


Got it John! Thank you For Contributing! smile *NM*
Craig Richard Lysy
<Send E-Mail>
(66-194-2-2.huntingtonhospital.com)
Profile Picture
Thursday, January 23, 2020 (2:18 p.m.) 



Threaded Display
  In Response to:
JBlough
  Responses to this Message:
Craig Richard Lysy
Riley KZ


Re: Craig - My Top Ten (JBlough 2019)
Riley KZ
(s0106441c12180233.lb.shawcable.ne
t)
Profile Picture
Friday, January 24, 2020 (8:34 a.m.) 

> 1. How To Train Your Dragon: The Hidden World
> 2. Godzilla: King of the Monsters
> 3. Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker
> 4. Shazam!
> 5. Lost in Space Season 2
> 6. Our Planet
> 7. Little Women
> 8. Spider-Man: Far From Home
> 9. Maleficent: Mistress of Evil
> 10. Cliffs of Freedom
> Composer of the year: Bear McCreary

I regret not re-listening to Our Planet nor hearing Lost in Space at all before posting my list. Ah well.

> 1-3 get *****. 4-10 get ****½. The runner-up is Dream Factory /
> Traumfabrik. Outlander S4 and Rim of the World contended, but the closing
> duo of ‘Milou’s Dream’ and the eponymous suite sealed the deal.

> The rest of my top 20: Aladdin, Avengers: Endgame, Captain Marvel,
> CyberWork and the American Dream, Masquerade Hotel, Swoon, Untamed Romania

> Other ****: Doctor of Traditional Chinese Medicine, Good Omens, A Hidden
> Life, His Dark Materials Season 1, The Professor and the Madman

> ***½ (round up to 4) works: Dora and the Lost City of Gold, Dumbo, Game of
> Thrones Season 8, Knives Out, Minuscule: Mandibles From Far Away, Sordo /
> The (Silent) War, Zwingli

> ***½ (round down to 3) works: Child’s Play, Erica, The Mandalorian Season
> 1, The Man Who Killed Hitler and Then the Bigfoot

> ***: Charlie's Angels, Children of the Sea, Greedfall, It Chapter Two, Ni
> No Kuni: The Movie, The Secret Life of Pets 2

> Random thoughts:
> 2019 was a middle-of-the-pack year relative to the rest of the decade. It
> was superior to 2016 or 2011 but nowhere near 2018 or 2014, though the
> year’s top 3 scores are all in my top 150 all time. I rated 43 scores from
> works released in 2019 (including four that I didn’t get to until this
> month), which was a bit higher than last year’s count.

> I liked enough of the music from The Mandalorian, though portions were
> certainly PANTS. The weaker The Dark Crystal: Age of Resistance got one
> listen on Spotify which wasn’t enough for a rating (probably ***, though
> I’m not interested in a 2+ hour repeat).

Agreed. A 45 minute album of both of those scores would be great. But I'd rather get a colonoscopy than listen through 7 EP albums of Mandalorian again.

> Favorite track: ‘Shazam!’ from Shazam!, closely followed by ‘Portals’ from
> Avengers: Endgame

> Composer of the year was an easy decision. I gave at least ***½ to all 6
> McCreary scores I heard, though I skipped the unenthusiastically received
> albums for Eli and See and, like most of America, I didn’t know the
> first/only season of Proven Innocent aired.

> 2019 specialty releases:
> Favorite specialty album released in 2019 is a tricky one to pick. There
> was no slam dunk.
> - All LLL boxes are well-produced, but not every featured score is
> terrific (e.g., all the Apes sequel scores).
> - Superman, Lonesome Dove, A Man Called Peter, and Masters of the Universe
> lack much in the way of “net new” material.
> - The “film versions” of the scores for King Rat, Monsignor, and
> especially The Thin Red Line are not better listening experiences.
> - Air Force One was fun to get in complete form but still registers as a
> mid-tier 90’s Goldsmith action score.

> My individual album pick is a tie between Intrada’s releases of Apollo 13
> and An American Tail. Both are for excellent scores, feature significant
> new material, and contain great liner notes. My runner-up pick is the
> superb restoration work done on The Bride of Frankenstein by La-La Land.

Apollo 13 is SO FREAKIN GOOD.

> My box set vote goes to Kritzerland’s Henry King at Fox. RIP Nick Redman.

> Older stuff:
> I would be remiss if I didn’t cite the many composers whose film outputs I
> was largely or entirely unfamiliar with before this year: Richard
> Addinsell, John Addison, William Alwyn, Daniele Amfitheatrof, Jeff
> Alexander, Malcolm Arnold, Georges Auric, Arthur Benjamin, Richard Rodney
> Bennett, Lord Berners, Stanley Black, Roy Budd, Mark Chait, Francis
> Chagrin, Andrew Cottee, Benjamin Frankel, Dave Grusin, Christopher
> Gunning, Neal Hefti, Kenyon Hopkins, Gottfried Huppertz, Constant Lambert,
> Leighton Lucas, Nathaniel Mechaly, Philipp Noll, Riz Ortolani, Clifton
> Parker, André Previn, Alan Rawsthorne, Nelson Riddle, Gerard Schurmann,
> the Sherman Brothers (and, by extension, Irwin Kostal), David Shire,
> Mischa Spoliansky, and Ralph Vaughan Williams. Most of these discoveries
> were due to the Chandos Movies series. FSM’s MGM Soundtrack Treasury was
> also impactful.

Which were the Shire and Addison scores that got you?

> New listens to older scores/compilations (214 entries) was a bit higher
> than my 2018 listening (199 entries). No new classical albums were played
> last year (vs. 95 in 2018), though I did get to plenty of Chicago
> classical music concerts. Better luck in 2020, classical music albums!

> The top 10 older scores I discovered last year are ranked below while the
> rest are subsequently ordered alphabetically within rating tiers. Anything
> I found via Chandos is in bold text...and yes, dear reader, there is a lot
> of bold text below.

> *****
> 1. The Keys of the Kingdom (1944) - Alfred Newman
> 2. Mary Poppins (1964) – songs by The Sherman Brothers; score & song
> arrangements by Irwin Kostal
> 3. Raise the Titanic (1980) - John Barry
> 4. The Bridge on the River Kwai (1957) - Malcolm Arnold
> 5. Return to Oz (1985) - David Shire
> 6. Scott of the Antarctic (1948) – Ralph Vaughan Williams
> 7. Metropolis (1927) - Gottfried Huppertz

Raise the Titanic is SO GOOD.

> ****½
> 8. Dark City (1998) - Trevor Jones
> 9. Hobson’s Choice (1954) - Malcolm Arnold
> 10. Love is a Many-Splendored Thing (1955) - Alfred Newman
> Runner-up: Lawman (1971) - Jerry Fielding

> ****1/2 (round up to 5) scores
> Bitter Springs (1950) – Ralph Vaughan Williams & Ernest Irving
> The Bride Wore Black (1968) – Bernard Herrmann
> A Bridge Too Far (1977) – John Addison
> The Fallen Idol (1948) – William Alwyn
> The Flemish Farm (1943) – Ralph Vaughan Williams
> 49th Parallel (1941) – Ralph Vaughan Williams
> Godzilla (1954) - Akira Ifukube
> The History of Mr. Polly (1949) – William Alwyn
> The Inn of the Sixth Happiness (1958) - Malcolm Arnold
> Lady Caroline Lamb (1972) – Richard Rodney Bennett
> Lifeforce (1985) - Henry Mancini
> The Loves of Joanna Godden (1947) – Ralph Vaughan Williams
> Odd Man Out (1947) – William Alwyn
> Shogun (1980) - Maurice Jarre
> Wee Geordie (1955) - William Alwyn

> ****1/2 (round down to 4) scores
> Advise and Consent (1962) - Jerry Fielding
> Beastmaster 2: Through the Portal of Time (1991) - Robert Folk
> Boy on a Dolphin (1957) - Hugo Friedhofer
> Burma Victory (1945) – Alan Rawsthorne
> The Captive Heart (1946) - Alan Rawsthorne
> A Christmas Carol / Scrooge (1951) - Richard Addinsell
> Cold Lazarus (1996) - Christopher Gunning
> David Copperfield (1969) - Malcolm Arnold
> The England of Elizabeth (1957) - Ralph Vaughan Williams
> Far From The Madding Crowd (1967) - Richard Rodney Bennett
> The French Revolution: Years of Hope (1989) - Georges Delerue
> The French Revolution: Years of Rage (1989) - Georges Delerue
> Greyfriars Bobby (1961) - Francis Chagrin
> The Man Who Would Be King (1975) - Maurice Jarre
> Masters of the Universe (1987) - Bill Conti
> Merchant Seamen (1940) – Constant Lambert
> 95 (2017) - Panu Aaltio
> Oliver Twist (1948) – Arnold Bax
> The Orville Season 1 (2017) - Bruce Broughton, Joel McNeely, John Debney
> & Andrew Cottee
> Suicide Squadron / Dangerous Moonlight (1941) - Richard Addinsell

> Breakdown of acquisitions by type:
> - New (pre-2018): 133

> - Compilation rerecording: 29 - mostly Chandos, plus Nonesuch’s Music From
> The Films Of François Truffaut and Kritzerland’s Unchained
> Melodies/Holiday Set

> - Legitimate purchase of score I previously had: 16 - Air Force One, The
> Big Country, Innerspace, The Last Starfighter, Legend (US rejected/Europe
> cut), Lonesome Dove, Monsignor, The Polar Express, Predator, Princess
> Mononoke, Spirited Away, Star Trek (2009), Star Trek VI: The Undiscovered
> Country, Superman IV: The Quest for Peace, Superman: The Movie, and 3:10
> to Yuma (2007)

> - Film recording of score I already had LP recording or rerecording of: 9
> - Body Heat, Breakfast at Tiffany’s, The Bride of Frankenstein, Charade,
> Conan the Barbarian (1982), King Rat, Lost Horizon (1937), Two for the
> Road, and The Valley of Gwangi

> - Expansion of previously owned score: 7 - An American Tail, Apollo 13,
> Cinema Paradiso, Minority Report, Schindler's List, The Thin Red Line, and
> The World Is Not Enough.

> - Compilation: 7 - LLL's Potter, Apes, and Quinn Martin v1 sets;
> Kritzerland’s Henry King at Fox; FSM’s United Artists & MGM v1 Western
> sets; and...shudders...the VS Film Music Festival Krakow 2016
> pre-show CD...NEVER BUY THIS, PEOPLE

> - 2018 score acquired in 2019: 7 - BlacKkKlansman, First Man, Mary Poppins
> Returns, Otros Mundos, Ralph Breaks the Internet, and Watership Down in
> January; Bumblebee later

> - Additional recording: 3 - Tadlow’s Obsession, Tribute’s Fahrenheit 451,
> and the Symphonic Suite for Arion

> - LP recording of score I already had film recording of: 1 - FSM’s I Spy
> Vol. 2

> - Concert: 1 - Maurice Jarre at the Royal Festival Hall

> - Non-score album by film composer: 1 - Hisaishi’s Minima_Rhythm 2

Fun read bud, thanks!



Threaded Display
  In Response to:
JBlough
  Responses to this Message:
JBlough


Re: Craig - My Top Ten (JBlough 2019)
JBlough
<Send E-Mail>
(mobile-107-77-206-71.mobile.att.n
et)
Profile Picture
Friday, January 24, 2020 (10:31 a.m.) 

> I regret not re-listening to Our Planet nor hearing Lost in Space at all before posting my list. Ah well.
It would've been fascinating to explore the 8-album version of Our Planet. But 2+ hours seemed plenty as a standalone listen, and additional purchases are probably only merited after I watch the series.

At times Lost in Space S2 is such a WALL. OF. SOUND. In a good way. It's probably my favorite thing Lennertz has ever written, even surpassing Warhawk.

> Apollo 13 is SO FREAKIN GOOD.
Agreed. It's a classic, even with the occasional self-referencing (you can imagine me hearing Sneakers for the first time a few years ago and going 'OH...that's where that came from'). And the decision by Intrada to program the atmospheric material at the end of disc 1 was a great decision.

> Which were the Shire and Addison scores that got you?
The one Shire I picked up was Return to Oz. Intrada's expansion added a lot of great material. And the credits piece remains a highlight of the 1980s.

The Addison exploration started with the terrific Chandos album. From the FSM MGM Treasury I got the The Honey Pot and The Charge of the Light Brigade.

I later picked up Tom Jones, The Amorous Adventures of Moll Flanders, and Joseph Andrews, all rather entertaining if (necessarily) a bit all over the place. Only Grace Quigley was a disappointment, and even it had its moments.

It may be hard to expand that collection much further, or rather beyond the Ryko CD for A Bridge Too Far and the two episodes of Amazing Stories that are on my shelves somewhere. Sleuth, The Crimson Pirate, and Strange Invaders command high prices on the secondary market. The Seven-Per-Cent Solution was never released on CD. Maybe Torn Curtain?

> Raise the Titanic is SO GOOD.
I think I held off on picking this up on the off chance I could find a reasonably-priced copy of the CD somewhere. I finally broke down and bought the tracks digitally.



Threaded Display
  In Response to:
chollman
  Responses to this Message:
chollman


Re: Craig - My Top Ten (JBlough 2019)
chollman
(74-112-95-197.perimetercenter.net)
Profile Picture
Friday, January 24, 2020 (10:54 a.m.) 

Man, Warhawk is such a good score! But I think I agree with you that Lost in Space Season 2 is probably even better!


Threaded Display
  In Response to:
JBlough
  Responses to this Message:
chollman

  • Return to Top (Full Menu) ▲
  • © 1998-2025, Filmtracks Publications