The selection of material to perform is always a point
of contention on such compilations, though in the case of Armstrong, he
often arranges his themes into a form that lends itself well for that
use. Additionally, this "For the Record" CD debuted just a year after
the composer's "Craig Armstrong: Film Works 1995-2005" promotional
compilation that offered the original performances of many of the same
cues. The completion of his score for
World Trade Center in the
interim allowed for a whopping four tracks from its subdued and
depressingly beautiful score to be included on the "For the Record"
product. Gone, unfortunately, are the replacement cues written for
The Negotiator and
Cruel Intentions. Of more importance,
however, is that the Ghent performances attempted to represent
Armstrong's career without any of the composer's trademark electronic
loops. In
The Bone Collector,
The Quiet American, and
Plunkett & Macleane, the ensemble makes token efforts with
percussion to emulate the missing synthetic layers. Unfortunately, you
can't really represent Armstrong's career without these electronic
tones, and the performances on this compilation therefore suffer
significantly from their absence. The highlights from
Plunkett &
Macleane, "Escape" and "The Ball," had to be omitted as a result.
Ironically, the Ghent setup would have been better suited for
Elizabeth: The Golden Age and
The Incredible Hulk, both
written not long after this recording. The strictly orchestral
performances are rather passionless across the board, the trademark
piano at the heart of so many of Armstrong's themes failing to resonate
emotionally. The technically accurate playing by the full ensemble lacks
the melodramatic flair that Armstrong's original scores tend to exude,
exacerbating the issue with the synthetics. The choir was absolutely
necessary, however, and it at least does its job adequately in the
appropriate places. The solo vocal performance in "One Day I'll Fly
Away" from
Moulin Rouge is a disaster compared to Nicole Kidman's
screen version. On the upside, the album does feature a dialogue-free
version of "O Verona" from
William Shakespeare's Romeo + Juliet
and the "Restaurant Proposal" theme from
Love Actually to
accompany that score's lovely "Glasgow Love Theme." The addition of
"Lissa's Theme" from
Best Laid Plans is a nice move as well, even
if it is very similar to
The Bone Collector. Overall, this "For
the Record" album cannot compete with the original recordings on "Craig
Armstrong: Film Works 1995-2005" because of the lack of passion and
electronics in the performances. Hearing Armstrong's music without its
natural synthetic element is simply too bizarre to behold.
** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download