Filmtracks Traffic Rank: #1,042
Written 12/22/98, Revised 1/9/07
Invert Colors
Buy it... only if you are familiar with the novel and film, and are
thus prepared for an extremely restrained, minimalistic, and sparse
score for a very small African-based ensemble.
Avoid it... if you expect anything in this score to have
characteristics common to Rachel Portman's more common light romance and
comedy works.
 |
| Portman |
Beloved: (Rachel Portman) For anybody familiar with
the Toni Morrison novel of the same name, the film adaptation by
heralded director Jonathan Demme will be a viewing experience very true
the book. It's a convoluted ghost tale from the times of American
slavery, during which the story tells of not only the atrocities of the
whites of the era, but of the difficult and brutal choices made by the
black slaves as well. Morrison's story almost needs a map to get
through, but essentially involves a pair of older, former slaves facing
their previous lives in the form of a ghostly girl who walks into their
lives and household one day. Nearly everything in the story is deeply
unsettling, and Morrison's method of traveling between different times
at will is faithfully preserved in the film adaptation. Demme's film was
highly praised at the time of its release, and actress Oprah Winfrey,
who was a major force behind getting the film made, manages to shed her
talk-show persona and adequately stand alongside Danny Glover as a lead.
A significant number of truly revolting and horrific scenes caused the
film to skirt mainstream acceptance, and while it was forecasted to do
well during the awards season, it was ultimately shunned. One of the
more intriguing aspects of the film was its significantly lengthy
musical score, composed by the very unlikely Rachel Portman. Known
mostly for her lush romance and comedy scores at the time (the genre in
which she had won her Academy Award a few years earlier), Portman was
suddenly tasked with coming up with an authentic sound for a genre and
culture best defined in the late 1990's by John Williams, whose scores
for both Rosewood and Amistad were considered the
benchmark of success. While those scores would offer some slight
influences in Portman's finished work for Beloved, her avenue
towards representing the culture of the time would be largely unique.
She maintained at the time that the Beloved score was her
personal favorite of her career.
From a technical standpoint, there's good reason for
Portman to be proud of
Beloved. In terms of her career, the score
was an extreme and challenging deviation from her usual sound. Using
only a small handful of instrumental performers and an African choir
(along with a few solo voices), it would be generous to call her score
"sparse." The only orchestral elements that her listeners will recognize
will be just a couple of woodwinds, instruments only recognizable from
her palette because their stark solos often feature Portman's normal
chord progressions. Other than those occasional progression references,
absolutely nothing in
Beloved will remind you of her previous
works. Instrumentally, a single plucked guitar (or perhaps another
string-based instrument) periodically provides a delicate backdrop to
the vocals. The woodwinds and a couple of traditional string instruments
(sounding mostly like a viola and clarinet, but that's just a guess)
provide bleak dissonance during several disturbing passages, often with
no interference. An authentic percussion section with a distinctly
tribal sound (drums and sticks) is featured in slight solo performances
at times. The vocals are the selling point of the score, often layered
between adult female solos and an African children's choir. While few of
these solos stand out from one another, Miriam Stockley's voice (as
heard prominently in the "Beloved" cue near the outset) easily prevails.
Thematically, Portman does develop a primary theme and a few subsequent
variations. The statements of these themes are typically so slow in
pacing that it's sometimes difficult to pinpoint them. The overarching
sadness of the score is what ultimately defines
Beloved. Portman
handles the seriousness of the subject by exercising restraint, and
while this approach may be fundamentally successful,
Beloved
never has the same emotional appeal as John Williams' entries into the
genre. Portman is so consistently morbid in her score that, at 60
minutes of consistent dread, the album becomes depressingly irritating.
Only in "Denver Goes Out Yonder" does Portman pick up the pace with a
heightened sense of emotion that has basic similarities to Danny
Elfman's
Sommersby when the flute joins the cue at 1:00. Overall,
Beloved is so understated and drab that it's an impossible
listening experience, no matter how much you may respect it.
** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download
Bias Check:
For Rachel Portman reviews at Filmtracks, the average editorial rating is 3.31
(in 30 reviews) and the average viewer rating is 3.26
(in 28,139 votes). The maximum rating is 5 stars.
|
