Rather than generate a multi-genre hybrid score for
Da 5 Bloods, Blanchard instead leans heavily upon established
ideas of war and Americana. This should come as no surprise given that
Lee incorporated Richard Wagner's "Flight of the Valkyries" into the mix
as well, no doubt as a tribute to
Apocalypse Now. The more
pastoral applications evoke Aaron Copland via Jerry Goldsmith while the
emotional weight is clearly inspired by John Williams and the technique
of applying broken chords to denote trauma emulates Carter Burwell. The
90-piece orchestra is in full force for the opening powerhouse cue,
"What This Mission's About," that Blanchard admitted was an extreme
challenge due to the gravity of the scene. "That opening one. That was
it, dude," he later commented. "Man, talk about having like an 'oh,
shit' moment. You know? It's like, when I got it, and I watched it, I
went, 'Oh, my God.'" It is here that Blanchard best combines the stoic
and respectful heroism of Williams on lower brass, strings, and snare
while applying the challenging chords common to Burwell. The theme and
its secondary phrases expressed here carry over extensively in the
remainder of the score, adapted to a variety of less forceful
applications as the lead characters struggle through both their mission
and the impacts of systemic racism that haunt them half a world from
home. Between "We Bury It (For Now)" and "Bloods Go Into Jungle" on the
album release, the main theme for the team is nearly omnipresent,
Blanchard sometimes adapting the idea to an interesting new emotional
level, as in "MLK Assassinated," though most of the recapitulations are
softer variants of the same static structures and instrumentation of the
opening cue. Arguably a highlight of the score is "Finding the Gold,"
the only truly upbeat and triumphant cue in the entire work, the
optimism inherent in Williams' warmer writing, especially with
supporting woodwinds, shining through as a moment of relief. (Note that
the score otherwise does little to address the occasional humor of the
story, the film content to leave these scenes without music.) The
tonality on brass late in "Finding the Gold" is the score's closest
connection to Goldsmith's sense of nobility while the concluding chords
return to Williams bravado. One of the better-varied renditions of the
main theme comes in the tortured "Paul and Norman," a particularly
harrowing scene of self-reckoning that required Blanchard to offer a
greater emphasis of stress to the emotional range of the idea.
Meanwhile, the second major theme in
Da 5 Bloods
exists for the interpersonal drama and location of the tale. It's a
lovely theme in and of itself, though its rendering on a duduk
complicates matters. As a representation of Vietnam, the Middle Eastern
instrument is rather distracting and insulting, one of those occasions
when something "foreign sounding" doesn't suffice. As Blanchard
explains, "For the Viet Cong, I decided to incorporate a duduk, and for
the Americans I used full-sounding snares, percussion, and brass." Half
of that sentence makes sense. When pressed in one interview about
addressing Vietnam in the music, he continued, "I tried to pick up on
the little things, as that music has a certain type of melodic and
harmonic structure to it that's a bit more pentatonic. I'm pretty
sensitive and careful, as I never want it to sound like I'm trying to
appropriate something from a specific culture. I want it to sound like
I'm paying homage. That's why we brought in a really great duduk
player." Again, that explanation doesn't fly once the duduk is
mentioned, so listeners are left to appreciate the beauty of the
instrument rather than apply their brains to its use. The duo of "Otis
and Tien Have Dinner" and "Tien and Daughter Talk" initially suggest
that the theme may represent the redemptive Otis storyline (a character
discovers he fathered a daughter with a Vietnamese woman from the war),
but it extends to "David Meets Hedy," "Paul and David Have a Fallout,"
and other cues that reveal the idea to be one of personal healing as
well. Blanchard sometimes mingles the two themes adeptly, as in "Rice
Paddies," in which he passes the ideas across each other's base
instrumentation, but in their most prominent applications, they are kept
apart. The lengthy "End Credits" cue supplies them in convenient suite
form. Overall,
Da 5 Bloods is a score that must have looked
fabulous on paper but presents issues as recorded. The duduk is badly
inappropriate here, and the inevitable connections to other composers
may also distract. Perhaps more importantly, Blanchard has difficulty
adjusting the performance emphasis of his themes to compensate for their
extremely repetitive phrasing. This failure to expressively emote beyond
a limited range of steady respectfulness yields a surprisingly redundant
score given the film's length. Perhaps some of this weakness comes from
a rather uninspired performance from the full ensemble. While the
impressive opening and closing cues will earn all the press, look to
"Finding the Gold" for the score's most appealing release from its
otherwise overwrought stature. It's a highly respectful, appreciable
take on war-genre character drama, but one not without flaw.
**** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download