Instead, this "In Session" product is primary aimed at the older
ears in the film music community. The best selling point of these re-recordings is the
opportunity to hear classic themes performed by large, digitally recorded and mixed
orchestras in a sound quality that was never realized with the originals. This is
especially true of the scores on the first CD of this set. The presentation of music on
the "In Session" set is basically chronological, though the beginning and end have been
specially ordered. The set begins with Alex North's
2001, which is not the only
rejected selection on the album. The second disc finishes the progression, essentially,
with Georges Delerue's
Platoon. The very end of the second CD is the album's
only annoying weakness. For some reason, Joel McNeely's original theme for the "Star
Wars: Shadows of the Empire" video game was included, even though it is a comparatively
difficult listening experience and certainly no classic when compared to everything
else on the set. Also of curiosity is the choice of ending the set with Waxman's
Taras Bulba, which can easily leave you with heartburn depending on your opinion
of that score. As for the choice of tracks within the centerpiece of the set, producer
Townson has done a pretty good job of choosing the best selections of music from each
score, perhaps with the exception of Bernard Herrmann's
Vertigo (though the
later love theme is, perhaps, a bit over-emphasized on compilations of the era). With
most selections ranging between three and five minutes in length, the album flows well
from piece to piece. The only distractingly lengthy cues come from Goldsmith's
Star
Trek: The Motion Picture and
Platoon. Otherwise, the selections are
strong.
The only other flaw of the album is perhaps a result of a larger
circumstance of the Varèse Sarabande re-recordings in general. If you are
knowledgeable about the series, you'll know that Townson prefers to tackle scores of
the 1960's beyond all others. And in addition to this concentration, there is also a
heavy bias towards the works of Alex North and especially Herrmann, both of whom occupy
a disproportionate amount of time on this album set. Therefore, the product functions
as a good overview of Varèse's classic film music re-recordings, but
not
as good of a representation of the history of film music as a whole. Varèse's
actual intent with the presentation was never known, but if Townson wanted to celebrate
the whole of film music history, more attention needed to have been paid to the classic
Golden Age works of Miklós Rózsa, Alfred Newman, Erich Korngold, etc, as
well as additional Bronze and Digital Age composers (which may have helped album sales,
too). That may stand as a suggestion for the series of re-recordings as a whole, for
"In Session" exposed just how generous Varèse had been to Herrmann and North. In
subsequent years, Townson couldn't resist pushing the size of similar sets to six CDs,
and perhaps such a quantity of air time would be necessary to really provide a balanced
presentation of the art's history. In great favor for this album is its spectacular
packaging, with impressive art and photography by Matthew Joseph Peak and lengthy notes
by Townson, who celebrated the production of his 500th album with this entry. Overall,
if you've been pondering the purchase one of Varèse's re-recordings but are
still unsure about where to start, then this set is a really good starter kit at a
reasonable price.
**** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download