One of the most interesting aspects of
Kundun to
consider at the time was its concurrent release with John Williams'
score for 1997's other Dalai Lama film,
Seven Years in Tibet. The
two works, despite merging Western and Eastern elements and featuring
Gyuto Monks as the representation of their ethnicity, are frightfully
different in their tone and sense of authenticity. While Williams'
score, with the help of Yo-Yo Ma's cello performances, is more pleasing
to Western ears,
Kundun will be far more challenging for most
average film score collectors. It could be argued that Glass' slight
touch, with dissonance or inflection in each cue, is a culturally
superior representation. Glass does not offer blatant themes, but
instead presents a series of simple motifs over string and percussion
rhythms typical to his career. Bass tones created by the monks,
bassoons, contra bassoons, and Tibetan horns are powerful, but they
often meander in pitch, creating an atonal backdrop for whatever
wandering line for brass or woodwinds that Glass explores at great
length in the treble region. While a few of these motifs do expand in
their development throughout the score, the ponderous rhythms do become
tiresome outside of the context of the film. Each cue's rhythm is a
slight variant of the one that came before, and the ideas typically end
abruptly at the conclusion of each album track. Gently thumping drums
are mixed in dull fashion in most of the cues, creating a muted
soundscape that only dilutes the score's appeal further. The motifs
explored early in the score, in "Reting's Eyes" and "Chinese Invade,"
finally reach a harmonious and resonating crescendo in "Escape to
India." The easy highlight of the score, "Escape to India" combines more
aggressive string rhythms, as tonally pleasant as they would be in
The Illusionist almost a decade later, with a chanting choir and
gorgeous flute solos in its latter half. Every idea in the score
culminates to one, impressive full ensemble and soloist conclusion that,
as usual, ends abruptly. Overall, Glass conveys his respect for Buddhist
culture very well in
Kundun, but his knack for leaving the
listener with nothing more than a generally subdued impression of that
culture makes for a tedious album.
Kundun will not appeal to most
film score fans expecting a
Seven Years in Tibet kind of
listening experience.
@Amazon.com: CD or
Download