While the Mann songs in
Magnolia are extremely
obvious in their placements, Brion's score is comparatively diminutive.
Many major scenes were left unscored, including the famous and
incredible one involving frogs raining from the sky. When it is
employed, the score is mixed softly into the soundscape, especially
compared to the songs, and Brion's work is dialed in and out without
many synchronization points. Part of this strategy owes to how Brion
wrote his music, the cues often long and maintaining consistent rhythmic
formations that could be dropped in segments into scenes with fades at
either end. The sense of motion in the score is its most memorable
characteristic, Brion using cyclical structures like Philip Glass but
with brighter tonal shades. If one word could describe its appeal, it
would be "momentum." There is rarely a moment in the score that isn't
conveying some distinctive feeling of inevitable forward movement. Given
the beefy length of the cues, this rhythmic motion can continue for
almost maddening periods of time, though most of the material is
accessible enough to pass without much bother. The ensemble is
distinctly classical, an orchestra providing a traditional environment
that blurbs, bubbles, and sometimes stomps its way through highly
recurrent phrasing. There are exceptions to this sound, notably the
stylish diversion of "So Now Then" that seems to apply vibraphone,
Hammond organ, and mandolin to break the hypnotic orchestral movements.
Brion does write themes for the score, and they are meant to represent
non-character concepts generally. All of his ideas are extremely
convoluted, sinewy and distant, difficult to really grasp or remember.
His main theme unfolds playfully on strings without easy enunciation in
"A Little Library Music," turning even more spritely with woodwinds
joining up-tempo fragments thereafter. The various phrases of the theme
bounce along with lengthy rhythmic interludes, brass eventually carrying
the meandering melody by "Going to a Show." Don't expect this theme to
dominate the film, however. It bumbles at 4:11 into
"Stanley/Frank/Linda's Breakdown" on woodwinds, the three-note phrases
from its interlude occupying the middle of "Chance of Rain." The theme
defines all of the suite-like "Magnolia" on celeste in a somewhat
quirky, lurching form that is almost impossible to recall after the
melody is done.
Outside of the totally elusive main theme for
Magnolia, Brion explores a handful of other tunes. Again,
however, none is memorable. A breakdown motif of sorts is partially a
very slow deconstruction of the main theme, consolidating at 1:36 on
high strings in "Jimmy's Breakdown." Reprised in similar form in
"Stanley/Frank/Linda's Breakdown," the idea launches into a much lighter
variant with the impulsive propulsion from the earlier "Showtime" cue,
reaching for slight references to John Williams' rhythmic applications
for woodwinds. The sparse breakdown theme extends out of misery to a
form new melody in the middle of "Chance of Rain," its ascending figures
transforming into an uplifting new idea in "So Now Then." Other ideas
are largely confined to development in single cues, including the
impressive "Showtime," which builds relentlessly throughout the long cue
in undulating, ascending and descending lines. Its melody proper becomes
full on brass at 2:22 with striking string slashes, later shifting
between formations with different sections for the long cue. The
underlying rhythm of this piece is always sustained to some minimal
degree, at times bursting through with almost giddy excitement. A theme
developed throughout "I've Got a Surprise for You Today" is a highly
noble and cyclical brass anthem with deep bass string gravity. More
source-like is the "WDKK theme" representing the "What Do Kids Know?"
show on screen by supplying vintage big band jazz as its jingle. Sadly,
Brion doesn't manage to make obvious connections between these ideas in
his score. Nor are there dominant carry-overs of melodies from the songs
into his work; Brion is credited with compositional co-credit on one
song. Not only is there a disconnect between the songs and the score,
but Brion's incidental music doesn't do much to define a narrative in
and of itself. It's a stream-of-consciousness score, one that relies
upon extremely obtuse melodic phrasing as means of emphasizing its
propulsive rhythms or ambient emotional tone. While sometimes bleak, the
score does really shine in "Showtime" and "So Now Then," those cues'
spirited demeanor standing apart as highlights. None of the musical
choices for this score is too surprising, because it's the songs that
dominate the soundscape on screen. While the total lack of narrative
development by Brion is a disappointment, he nails the emotional core of
several individual scenes, even if his music is too lightly and
sparingly applied. Annoyingly, the songs and score were released
separately; a combined album was merited here.
*** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download