Like most compilations, there are a few standout
surprises than need to be recognized. The back-to-back performances of
Species and
Lifeforce (written by Christopher Young and
Henry Mancini, respectively) are highlights of the compilation, with the
extended end title variant on the main theme of
Species served
with the appropriately haunting choir. More ambitious is
Lifeforce, with its driving, militaristic, and heroic theme well
rendered here (though its tiring use to promote professional football
games on television in 2006 has somewhat tarnished the theme's original
purpose). Also highly praised through the years has been Prague's
performance of Jerry Goldsmith's
Capricorn One, one of the very
best and most spirited in their history. The inclusion of
The Black
Hole is commendable; the original has never been released due to
lost source tapes, and it's relatively strange to hear vibrant
science-fiction music from John Barry anyway, so it's a fabulous stop on
the CD. Breaking with the norm, Silva offers the "Han Solo and the
Princess" concert arrangement from
The Empire Strikes Back rather
than the typical march, a far more interesting piece given the worn
tread on the more famous theme. The only notably lackluster performances
on this set are unfortunately
Apollo 13 (poor selection of cue to
perform),
Enemy Mine (poor material to begin with), and
Star
Wars (just an off-kilter performance). After a gracious nod to Alex
North's partially rejected
2001, the set embarks into the realm
of
Star Trek. The television themes are adequately portrayed (an
obvious horn flub in
Voyager is the only serious problem), though
the most impressive performances are dedicated to the major motion
picture scores. Lengthy tracks from
The Wrath of Khan,
The
Final Frontier, and
The Undiscovered Country are all very
well done, though this logic largely follows the fact that those scores
are among the best of the series anyway. The sound effects littered
throughout the album are reminiscent of the Telarc/Erich Kunzel albums,
and they likewise have little to do with the actual sounds from the
films or shows. The ones on the first CD consist mostly of grinding
noises... not suitable for real use as an annoyance for neighbors in
your apartment. Overall, though, this set (and those in the series that
followed) is outstanding, especially given that it's available on the
used market for under five dollars as it reaches its tenth birthday.
***** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download