Of course, with Iñárritu, the situation with
the soundtrack is never that simple, as the man has a tendency to fall
in love with temp tracks. As such, this movie ended up with a
significant amount of other ambient music that was ultimately licensed
and included in the final cut. A sizable chunk of that temp score was
music by German electronic music artist Carsten Nicolai, otherwise known
as Alva Noto; fortunately, in this case, Noto and Sakamoto had
collaborated on non-film projects several years before, so Sakamoto
formally asked Noto to join him a co-composer. This decision was also in
part due to Sakamoto's recovery from chemotherapy treatments for his
throat cancer, and he was fearful that he would not be able to compose
all the music for the picture himself. Iñárritu wasn't
finished building his musical ensemble, however, approaching American
composer Bryce Dessner, a guitarist in the rock band The National, after
utilizing some of his music in the temp track as well. Sakamoto and Noto
never collaborated directly with Dessner, but the former ultimately sent
him his material to help coordinate the sound of the two. While Sakamoto
conducted his contributions with a larger ensemble in Seattle, Dessner
did so with a 25-member string ensemble in Berlin. Among the more
notable licensed music in
The Revenant includes three pieces by
John Luther Adams and one by Olivier Messiaen, exposing the director's
obsession in this case with the ondes martenot instrument. All of this
material does manage to form a rather cohesive emotional tone for the
film. Noto's contributions often involve the remixing or reimagining of
Sakamoto's ambient material, while Dessner handles the bulk of what
might be considered the "action" music. The combined score for
The
Revenant is immensely dispiriting and dreary, careful to address the
vastness of the scenery with an excessively muted and dull personality,
as if to almost define the location and the people in it as
insignificant and doomed. Undoubtedly, with Iñárritu
demanding input on every little aspect of the recording, the decision to
apply colorless and wearisome music to this story was intentional.
Iñárritu's philosophy towards music
suggests that a sustained understatement of the soundtrack accentuates
the hardships on the screen and, for some listeners, that appeal may
exist. There's also the "less is more as an artistic choice" strategy at
work as well, and some very casual listeners may perceive this score as
being like an atmospheric Hans Zimmer entry but without that composer's
trademark, 5-minute crescendos. The hype machines of the media tell
listeners that the music for
The Revenant is "revolutionary"
when, in reality, it is overwrought ambience with little purpose other
than to fill space and claim greatness. The instrumental palette for the
recording is restrained to strings and synthesizers for most of its
substance, with occasional percussion elements added by Dessner for some
semblance of force. Expect the tempos to be extremely slow. In fact, a
listener may not even be able to discern Sakamoto 's main theme for the
film unless he or she accelerates it by two or three times, by which
point it actually reveals itself to have an insipidly cyclical melody of
despair. The theme's very slow structure consists of a two-note phrase
followed by three-note phrase, with an interlude that follows the same
five-note overall sequencing with varying tonalities. The composers
never achieve any meaningful alteration to the purpose and tone of this
theme, leaving it as sparsely pointless in its final performance as it
was in its first. Still, one must give credit to Sakamoto and his team
for repeating the theme frequently throughout the score, if only to
break up the otherwise monotonously faceless material in between. The
idea is introduced in "The Revenant Main Theme" and becomes more
pronounced and accessible in "Hell Ensemble," a performance reprised
with eerie sound effects in the background during "The End." The theme's
default string meanderings turn synthetic and even gloomier in "Glass
and Buffalo Warrior Travel" but shift to more expressive tones in
"Church Dream," its lines smoothed out a bit. A variation on the idea's
progressions is explored in "The Revenant Theme 2." Solo cello and piano
await the theme in "The Revenant Main Theme Atmospheric" (this track
title is one of the funniest of any score for the year, because every
performance of the theme is atmospheric, this one no more so than the
others), and additional synthetic manipulation is afforded the idea in
"The Revenant Theme (Alva Noto Remodel)."
Outside of Sakamoto's main theme and related brooding
for
The Revenant, Dessner's more diverse material does spice up
the experience a bit, but his music's dissonance is no more pleasant
than the other composers' music is boring. The lengthy "Cat & Mouse" and
"Final Fight" cues are truly awful; his percussive layer is
inconsistently applied. The synthetic sound effects sometimes distract
so badly from the organic recording that they make you think there is a
problem with your music player. A hissing background noise sounds like
static interference in "Carrying Glass," and "Final Fight" has
unnecessary cricket noises that beg for evaluations of your sanity. A
little more palatable for most listeners will be the solo ondes martenot
in "Out of Horse" and a notable cello solo in "Arriving at Fort Kiowa."
Overall, don't believe all the promoters and listeners who claim that
the score for
The Revenant is high art. It may function well in
the film because that product is extraordinarily bleak and depressing
and this music is equally bleak and depressing. For that triumph of
matching alone, the score avoids the lowest rating. But this music is so
devoid of emotional variation that it forfeits its role as a functioning
film score, once again postulating that sound effects utilized as music
could someday replace functional film scores and still please a minority
of listeners. The score was deemed ineligible for an Oscar nomination
because of the collaborative nature of its construction (this despite
Sakamoto unsuccessfully appealing to AMPAS to reconsider their
decision), but it was exactly the kind of morbidly futile artistry that
would have won such an award. On album,
The Revenant is a
yawn-inducing affair not even suitable for an effectively gloomy mood,
as too much of it annoys. Out of sequence, the presentation is also
missing a significant amount of music by all three composers, as well as
the licensed remainders. Two cello recordings performed by Hildur
Guðnadóttir, the piece by Messiaen played when Glass emerges
from the dead horse, the Adams material for the Arikara ambush scenes,
and a slew of Noto augmentations are absent, too. These tracks enjoy
prominent placements in the film, so the score's album isn't even an
adequate representation of the more general soundtrack. But does that
really matter? Climbing into the carcass of a recently dead animal might
be preferable to this listening experience. At least the carcass might
be warm.
* @Amazon.com: CD or
Download