One of the most interesting aspects of
Thor:
Ragnarok is Mothersbaugh's acknowledgement of protests from fans
about the lack of continuity in the musical themes of the Marvel films.
He explicitly sought to rectify that perception, though he did so while
also infusing an all-new electronic style and his own title theme for
Thor into the equation, oddly negating his other attempts to bring
continuity to the franchise. In fact, what few, albeit intelligent
attempts by the composer to resurrect the music of prior Marvel-related
scores in
Thor: Ragnarok are completely overshadowed by the sheer
force of his style of writing for this particular film. There is a
struggle constantly heard in this music between the symphonic and
electronic elements, and the schizophrenia does cause the whole to
suffer. At times, the combination of the two halves is extremely adept
and satisfying, and Mothersbaugh will certainly impress enthusiasts of
orchestral bombast with his intellectually superb constructs and
renderings of the ensemble in parts. At other times, however, the
straight new wave electronic passages are simply too disparate from the
rest of the work to even function as source applications for Sakaar and
its Grandmaster. The album presentation doesn't help the listener,
either, with cues out of order and not containing some of the more
pertinent connections to prior Marvel identities. Also to be contended
with, of course, is the insertion of several vintage rock songs straight
into the action scenes of the film, the most memorable of these being
Led Zepplin's smartly placed and relevant "Immigrant Song" into multiple
scenes. Mothersbaugh tries valiantly to balance the symphonic demands of
the studio with the comfort zone of his heart, sometimes, as in the
latter half of "Running Short on Options," succeeding extremely well,
but, as in "What Heroes Do," taking the retro elements to ridiculous
levels. For some listeners, the latter passages, or those in which the
electronics dominate alone, will outright ruin the Marvel concept in
"The Revolution Has Begun" and "Sakaar Chase." To those not accustomed
to Mothersbaugh's vintage style and sense of humor, the duo of "Planet
Sakaar" and "Grandmaster Jam Session" will be nothing less than
insufferable to the extent that they disqualify the whole score. Indeed,
they are ridiculously funny and obnoxiously unbearable on album, but
don't let these portions distract you from the otherwise fantastic
orchestral side to the work.
Texturally, Mothersbaugh impresses with his application
of Nordic instruments such as the hardanger fiddle and nyckelharpa in
Thor: Ragnarok. A duduk is less applicable, but he receives kudo
points for at least using that, along with more stereotypical solo vocal
layers, to provide sonic color to the score. In "Ragnarok Suite" and
"Twilight of the Gods," listeners hear monumentally outstanding and
dynamic symphonic music, exceeding even the most ambitious approach of
Patrick Doyle and Brian Tyler for the character. The suite opening the
album, perfectly incorporating Mothersbaugh's retro electronic tones in
a supporting role, is among the best compositions of 2017 and alone
justifies the entire album. This suite introduces the new Thor theme
that is conveyed with rock tones in "Thor: Ragnarok" and with synthetic
zeal in "The Revolution Has Begun." Interestingly, the other major new
theme, representing Thor's evil sister, Hela, is not featured in this
suite, its introduction saved for "Hela vs. Asgard." Mothersbaugh's own
theme for Thor is a combination of progressions offered by both Doyle
and Tyler, the latter's
Thor: The Dark World music only reprised
clearly in a parody recreation of events from that film shown in this
entry. Meanwhile, the new Thor theme dances around the Doyle's chords
before finally outwardly stating that theme in full glory during the
coronation scene in "Where To?" Far less obvious are Mothersbaugh's
apparent attempts to offer pinpoint musical connections to Bruce Banner
and the Hulk, alluding to everything from Craig Armstrong's 2008
material for the character to Tyler's handling of him in
Avengers:
Age of Ultron and, most poignantly, Joe Harnell's classic "Lonely
Man" theme from the television series. Unfortunately, this material does
not seem evident on the album. By comparison, Mothersbaugh fails to
state Michael Giacchino's
Doctor Strange theme in "Weird Things
Happen" despite obviously conveying the Indian instrumentation and
rhythmic figures that underlay the identity. Overall,
Thor:
Ragnarok solves some of the franchise's musical ills while creating
new ones, supplying some fantastic orchestral and synthetic blends at
times while destroying your ears with them at others. The musical
continuity that the composer sought to rectify is only partially
successful. Mothersbaugh's own themes are either unnecessary or, in the
case of Hela, not particularly memorable. The lengthy "Ragnarok Suite,"
however, is perhaps the best single composition in the entire Marvel
Cinematic Universe through 2017, and that's no small feat.
*** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download