The resulting score for
Thunderbolts* was then
rearranged into the picture as needed rather than cues being written to
specific synchronization points, and in some cases, the tempo of the
film's editing was sometimes matched to the existing music rather than
vice versa. The personality of Son Lux's music is irreverent and
haphazard by design, tossing aside most superhero conventions in favor
of what they called the "kitchen sink" method of throwing all sorts of
random ideas at the concept. That strategy functions for the basic feel
of the music but yields a highly ineffectual film score that doesn't
develop its structures to any satisfying level. It is truly a score
defined by its style rather than its substance, and many film music
collectors will find it to be a wildly disjointed experience despite
espousing some momentary highlights. The ensemble for
Thunderbolts* is orchestral at its core, and the instrumental
usage is sometimes interesting, but the recording is laced with
synthetic and percussive layers that sometimes dominate. Unusual
percussive sampling was done by Son Lux, and the composers thought they
were being as creative as a Hans Zimmer ghostwriter with the things they
banged upon to generate noise, but the result of their efforts sounds
the same. There's nothing inherently wrong with their sampling,
actually, but it doesn't support anything useful on top of it and often
gets lost in the rampant manipulation during post-processing. That
extremely abrasive and pervasive distortion of the soundscape compounds
dissonance inherent in the orchestral performances, the instrumental
nastiness most challenging in "Show Us the Worst." Reverb levels are
highly inconsistent throughout, too, "The Climb" oddly wet in sound
while surrounding cues are prickly in their dryness. There is very
little consistency in the work aside from its rough edges, and the
thematic narrative is where Son Lux really fails the film and the
franchise. While this movie is considered an origins tale and the trio
of composers treated its themes as a developmental set that only
partials congeals at the end, if one could even qualify it as
congealing, the handling of the identities is among the worst to inhabit
a Marvel film.
The main Thunderbolts group theme is extremely
underwhelming, representing one of the least interesting and inspiring
character identities in the franchise. With its simplistic eight notes
divided into call and action parts with awkward harmonies, there is
absolutely no secondary phrasing to the idea whatsoever, making it
extremely repetitive and juvenile. The theme is intentionally left
deconstructed in most of the film until the group earns it in the
closing cue, which is logical but not particularly necessary or
satisfying. Son Lux toys with its progressions right away in the
meandering rhythms of "There's Something Wrong With Me," the theme
struggling late in "Countdown," forced into a synthetic haze in "Forest
Memory," and dismembered in "Maybe We'll All Get Out of Here Alive." It
blends into the score's main action motif in "It's Bucky!" for its
fullest performance yet but is slowly tempered in "For the Glory" prior
to moderately heroic teasing. Fragmented in "Left the Door Unlocked,"
the payoff is left until "Thunderbolts*," where it is conveyed
repetitively at 0:25 on strings and manipulated on brass later. The
theme combines the brass and strings for a vaguely heroic incarnation at
2:09, but "Thunderbolts*," despite being the official announcement of
the theme, doesn't convey it with any authority or sense of purpose.
Making the audience wait until the end of the score for the big reveal
of a main theme's full construct is fine as a technique, but that
performance has to be really good to justify the wait. This one is not
only simplistic and repetitive, but its inflection from the ensemble is
disappointingly tepid. The disorganized secondary themes in
Thunderbolts* aren't much more successful. Rising, 4-note figures
of vague heroism represent the Sentry character and associated
super-human concepts, previewed vaguely in "Walker's Memory" and trying
to congeal in "First Flight" but failing to really do so. It finally
shows its progressions in "Introducing Sentry" and further boosts its
identity in "Penthouse Fight" on brass. Some listeners will completely
miss this identity. More prevalent is the villain theme for the CIA
director, though it sometimes seems totally disconnected from the rest
of the score in its awkward attempt to humanize the character around its
otherwise muted antagonistic duties.
The villain theme stews in troubled string layers in
the latter half of "The Light Inside You is Dim," meanders in woodwind
layers during "Unimpeachable," and obtains its villain status in the
suffering of "It's Not Robert You Need to Be Afraid Of." It gains a
little more troubled sympathy in the obtuse "I Don't See Your Mistakes,"
attempts melodrama in the slurring "No Use Fighting," pushes that
tension into "Yelena's Choice," and offends as a distorted piano
rendition plunks away in "The Attic" before dissolving badly. Son Lux
leaves the idea on a more personable note, offering it some sensitivity
on solo cello in "Not Alone" and building to a catharsis from the
ensemble in that cue. It also features on piano at 2:39 into the
"Thunderbolts*" suite, though its performance suddenly occurs with no
transition whatsoever from prior exploration of the main theme. It's a
frustratingly poor suite as a result. For the obligatory fighting and
chasing, the trio conjure an action motif that is a descending four-note
rhythm in staccato movements. Distorted throughout "I Needed That Face"
while bouncing annoyingly through the soundscape, this motif becomes a
fanciful rhythm on flutes in "Last Assignment" and is elongated in the
frantic strings of "Maybe We'll All Get Out of Here Alive." It opens
"It's Bucky!" in more traditional action mode, gains momentum in the
extremely manipulated "Show Us the Worst," extends to a longer brass
variant in "You Can't Even Save Yourself," and teases at the outset and
blasts through the mix's distortion at 1:21 into "Thunderbolts*." As a
menace motif, Son Lux also applies downward slurring brass as a tired
technique, informing pounding descents like those in "It's Bucky!" In
the end, the music for
Thunderbolts* makes a hell of a lot of
noise and is occasionally interesting, but it's simply not a very good
film score. It's the work of novices on this playing field, and the even
if your ears can survive the absolutely wretched manipulation of the
mix, the conveyance of the themes is inadequate throughout. Several cues
representing important moments in the story do nothing to advance the
thematic narrative, and the action cues provide brute force of sound
rather than refined representation of synchronization points on screen.
Both are byproducts of how the music was written. It's the type of score
that gets noticed because it's so different from the expected mould, but
that mould exists for a reason, and
Thunderbolts* flounders
because it can't find a comfortable balance between convention and
creativity.
@Amazon.com: CD or
Download