For
Toy Story 3, Newman (with three co-writers)
loses the sci-fi, jazz, and ragtime elements and merges the slapstick
cartoon material and Western homages with a dose of slight bayou blues,
Mediterranean mafia stereotypes, electric guitar rock, vague Parisian
romance, and Latin rhythms and acoustic guitar flourishes. Most notably,
though,
Toy Story 3 is defined by its plentitude of rowdy action
sequences of straight orchestral bombast (albeit the somewhat
light-handed sort that Newman creates to emulate the Stalling sound).
Listeners who enjoyed Newman's take on that classic cartoon sound in the
previous scores will appreciate the 20+ minutes of similar material
here. It seems frightfully generic, however, and only in the final two
cues does the score truly exhibit the heart that occasionally stole the
spotlight in the franchise's previous soundtracks. The tender piano and
string performances in "So Long" are as subdued and introspective as
Newman can seemingly be in this context, yielding a surprisingly lovely
and engaging moment. Unfortunately,
Toy Story 3 continues to
suffer from thematic ambiguity all the way to the end. The sleazy
half-blues/half-Mediterranean material for the villain of the daycare
clearly occupies the mid-section of the score, and the sentimental theme
at the end is unmistakable. But as with the other two scores, the
franchise's primary identity, "You've Got a Friend in Me," is all but
forgotten. Slight references, such as the brief optimism at the outset
of "Going Home," are simply not enough. Thankfully, unlike
Toy Story
2, Newman does provide a new song with his own voice, though the
melody of the rather bland, vintage, rock-influenced "We Belong
Together" does not convincingly anchor the score. Also a nagging
difficulty with these scores is the collection of references to
mannerisms of other composers, whether it be Ennio Morricone and Marc
Shaiman's Western styles or James Horner's solemn piano work.
Ultimately,
Toy Story 3 is an effective score but by no means
memorable. Don't expect it to conclude with a positively rousing, upbeat
send-off to infinity and beyond. It's nice to hear this franchise reach
its conclusion with Newman's music, but these scores were never that
cohesive to begin with. Disney opted initially not to press a song and
score album on CD (the two songs, Newman's "We Belong Together" and a
Spanish rendition of "You've Got a Friend in Me" by Gipsy Kings, were
put on a six-song CD with the other films' songs, sans the original
"You've Got a Friend in Me," a stunningly irritating marketing ploy),
instead offering over 50 minutes of it for download. As with
Up,
however, Intrada Records pressed a CD of identical contents a few years
later. Both products are simply too long of a presentation for this
harmlessly generic score, regardless of Newman's stature and the affable
nature of the music.
*** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download