One of the ironies of the music for
Trouble With the
Curve is the plethora of comparisons between the film itself and the
topic of
Moneyball from the previous year. Interestingly, while
Moneyball will be considered by most to be a vastly superior
baseball and family film, both productions suffer from rather bland and
uninspiring music. Beltrami's tone in
Trouble With the Curve is a
bit friendlier than Mychael Danna's had been for the earlier venture,
but a lack of dramatic resolve and impactful gravity connects the two
works. Beltrami does provide, at the very least, a better narrative flow
and some parochial spirit by opening and closing the score with a few
cues of meandering electric guitars meant to address the American South.
Unlike similar usage in Danny Elfman's
Real Steel, however, the
guitars here don't seem to contribute to an overall thematic arc with
which to tie the story together. In fact,
Trouble With the Curve
is melodically anonymous for most of its length, a curious choice given
the positive effect the score's eventual theme (of simple, rising
phrases) starting in "The Real Deal." Beltrami explores a few motifs in
the first two thirds of the score, but none of these ideas blossoms into
a meaningful identity. That leaves the fluffiness of the instrumentation
to carry the personality of the score, and here
Trouble With the
Curve is also hit and miss. At times, as in "Bo's Homer" and
"Another Hit," there are hints of the enthusiasm that graced
Soul
Surfer. The plucked strings, piano, and acoustic guitar in
"Flanagan" and (with more fluid strings) "Mickey's Home Run" offer
moments of liveliness not heard again in the score. Instead, you
encounter extended sequences of nearly inaudible filler material for
strings or piano, not much unlike, intriguingly, a Clint
Eastwood-composed score. Cues like "Post Clogging," "Horse With No
Name," and "Get On the Bus, Gus" practically kill the listening
experience, and the redemption you hear from the orchestral ensemble in
"Trouble With the Curve" and "Not All I've Got," while basically
effective at their task, cannot entirely salvage the listening
experience. The unrelated song "On My Way" at the end of the otherwise
score-only product contains infinitely more life than anything in
Beltrami's contribution. There is an argument to made for a two-star
rating for
Trouble With the Curve, not just because of the
(unrealistic) expectations following
Soul Surfer but also due to
a total lack of genuine warmth and enthusiasm in 90% of this score.
Still, Beltrami competently follows all the basic genre rules and
provides the bare minimum necessary for the music to function.
*** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download