To appreciate a score like
Criminal Law out of
context, especially if you're a die-hard enthusiast of Goldsmith's
typically resounding combination of orchestra and electronics, you have
to accept the work at face value. Even as prevalent as the electronics
are in a concurrent score like
Extreme Prejudice, there is little
that will prepare you for the stark landscape of
Criminal Law.
Synthesizers back in the 1980's had a distinctly fake sound to their
imitations of real instruments, and scores like that utilized such
samples showed their age very quickly. Goldsmith didn't often employ
this kind of sampling, but when he did, the tones were harsh,
mechanical, and dissonant, leaving practically nothing for the listener
to latch onto and remember later. From start to finish,
Criminal
Law is an exercise in ambient texture devoid of thematic or rhythmic
development beyond brief ideas introduced in nearly every cue.
Stylistically, the music is probably appropriate for the age and
attitude of the film itself, sweeping aside any sense of harmony or
genuine sensibility in the same way the film disregards logic and
reality. It broods with unsatisfying monotony similar to James Horner's
The Name of the Rose from the same era, even developing a token
thematic inclusion at the end. For Goldsmith, the resolution is a
synthetic trumpet and piano theme of slightly contemporary tones vaguely
similar, as usual for the period, to
The Russia House. Whether
the composer's reason for producing an all-electronic score for
Criminal Law was budgetary or purposefully for the texture, one
thing is for certain: the learned Goldsmith collector will be able to
translate the rhythms and motifs to their orchestral counterparts if
they listen closely enough. This may be difficult, given the propensity
this score has towards boring the listener, but there are certain
sections in
Criminal Law that could easily make for a very strong
result if only performed by orchestral instrumentation. The choice of
the samples utilized is also somewhat curious, though, because Goldsmith
refrains from using his more popular synthetic sounds (pan pipes,
bouncing basketball, wet street swishes, etc) in favor of very dull and
unmemorable keyboarding and generic background tones. Overall,
Criminal Law is definitely one of the weakest Goldsmith efforts
of the digital era, combining a lack of diverse instrumentation with a
stylistic intent to only add to the film's dissolution through dark
textures.
* @Amazon.com: CD or
Download