: (John Carpenter/Various) While
initial studio hesitancy and the 2020 pandemic delayed the production of
and its two promised sequels.
Picking up the original 1978 storyline and ignoring most of the other
sequels and reboots, the 2018 film was met with praise from concept
enthusiasts, especially with original actors returning to the fray. The
first sequel to this extension, 2021's
, did not
fare as well critically, for the movie failed to take its narrative in
any meaningful or surprising direction and didn't offer as much presence
for lead actress Jamie Lee Curtis. Rather, the movie is simply an excuse
to see a wide variety of new and returning characters killed by the evil
"shape," Michael Myers, even despite entire well-armed mobs attempting
to overtaken him in open spaces. The movie requires you to believe that
the citizens of the nice town of Haddonfield are all a bunch of helpless
cows awaiting slaughter, with no law enforcement prowess whatsoever.
Certainly, by 2021, both the national press and the FBI would be all
over this insanity and give it the death it truly deserves. But, alas,
no. Audiences absolutely must see a creepy guy kill others without the
convincing purpose that even a terminator has. After helping launch the
concept in the 1970's, director, writer, and composer John Carpenter
disavowed much of the franchise thereafter, bowing out after three films
and only returning for the 2018 entry as a consultant and composer. He
returns again for music duties on
, joined like
before by his son, Cody Carpenter, and rock-musician godson, Daniel
Davies. The director, David Gordon Green, encouraged these men to take
the modernized version of their classic 1978
music from
the previous movie and make it even more aggressive, supplying perhaps
an experimental edge to this score. After all, with bigger, angry
slasher mobs must come some stomping electronic bravado, right?
The end product for
Halloween Kills isn't
significantly different from the 2018
Halloween score, however,
with a few heavier layers to some cues, but the overall equation
remaining mostly static. The continuation of the franchise's original
three themes is still commendable in these newer works, and that
faithful dedication alone to melody and style may be enough for some
listeners of
Halloween Kills, but Carpenter and his team are
clearly struggling to find ways to evolve these ideas into anything
substantially new by this point. Given how stale the formula of the film
has become, perhaps the tired stance of the music cannot be considered a
surprise. To a moderate degree, Carpenter does supply a bit more
dramatic depth to the tone of
Halloween Kills in its treatment of
the survivors, the music more often exploring piano-driven tonalities to
compelling ends. But whatever advances made in these portions are
countered by completely limp suspense and action writing. There is not
much depth to this music, no weight or breadth to its motions. The piano
holds its own, but all the synthetic elements, including electric
guitar, are shallow and unconvincing. Some of the action cues aren't
even scary, including the totally pointless loops of "Rampage." The
confrontation cue, "Payback," is not engaging enough in its sparseness.
These issues exist in most of the cues, leaving listeners grasping only
to the concept's themes for satisfaction. The main franchise theme
remains a winner in all of these films, both the melody and its iconic,
underlying 5/4 rhythm returning frequently in
Halloween Kills. In
"Main Title," its familiar piano tones are joined by a poorly sampled or
manipulated synthetic choir, with extended treatment including even some
poor brass sampling. The rhythm alone opens "Standoff," slowed
significantly, before the fragmented theme later emerges over
Carpenter's stalking motif with very dissonant results. The piano rhythm
is joined by menacing electric guitar notes in "He Appears," while the
theme is manipulated by angry guitar in "From the Fire."
Fragments of theme lace "Unkillable" in highly
obnoxious pulsing action, "Payback" opens with a reprise of the "Main
Title" performances, "Michael's Legend" offers the idea in softly
altered form on piano over a new rhythmic base, and a more formal
arrangement with additional, more grating synth layers in "End Titles"
cranks up the volume but not the power, the solo piano rhythm suddenly
ending to close out score and suggest more horrors to come in the next
film. Meanwhile, given the emphasis of the script on other characters,
heroine Laurie Strode's theme remains somewhat diminished in
Halloween Kills, consolidating at 1:17 on piano in "Strodes at
the Hospital" but overtaken by new protagonist material emphasized for
this entry. Beginning earlier in that cue as a rambling piano rhythm
under synth ambience, this music becomes somewhat elegant via piano solo
in "Frank and Laurie" and highlights the best cue in the work, "It Needs
to Die," with more determined, tonal, and dramatic appeal that includes
a few piano leads as well. Ghostly deconstructions of this material over
suspenseful ambience occurs in "Reflection," and related piano layers
are a nice touch in the hype-seeking "Michael's Legend." The stalking
motif consisting of a thumping piano base returns under the under main
theme in "Standoff" but really makes its mark under the entirety of
"First Attack," though this cue is tormented by terrible upper range
synths that will send you fleeing. The motif doesn't really recur after
that, though the same general idea elongated with louder malice can be
encountered in "Cruel Intentions" and "Hallway Madness." Few other
motifs of interest exist in
Halloween Kills, the repetitive
descending sequences of "The Myer's House" doing little to extend a
musical identity to the villain. Overall, the score hits all the right
basic notes but sounds incredibly cheap given the filmmakers' intent to
instill a greater sense of gravity in this score. The impact simply
isn't there, most cues neglecting to generate even moderate doses of
dread, and only the most avid franchise enthusiasts will appreciate the
continued variations on the main theme and its rhythm.
As expected, the score was released on album by
Carpenter's own label, Sacred Bones, in a wide array of product options
ranging from a CD to a series of limited LP vinyl collectibles. Similar
merchandise from the 2018 score, leading up to its expanded album of
2019, were quick to sell out, and this demand has forced the label to
attempt to limit the quantities of especially the LPs that individuals
can purchase. True to the franchise's era and good for a chuckle,
Carpenter even offers a cassette option for
Halloween Kills,
along with a "Trick or Treat" tote bag. In 2025, both the 2021 and 2022
sequel scores received expanded treatment on CD and vinyl just like the
2018 predecessor had already experienced, including an option to
purchase the fuller versions of all three in one set. (Endless varieties
of colorful vinyl options with gruesome artwork continue to earn
Carpenter cash from the seemingly endless wealth of this franchise's
fanbase.) In the case of this entry, many ambient and transitional cues
are added to the experience, but more of the softer piano material is
there as well. A significant amount of important music is revealed in
the longer offering for
Halloween Kills, causing a much
better-rounded listening experience with very impactful holes filled in
the narrative. Amongst the new cues, the stalking motif is sparsely
rendered in "Flashback," "Hey Kid," and "Someone's in the Car" while
nice hints of the Laurie Strode theme in "Phone Call" and "Back at the
Hospital" extend into the tonal piano contemplation of "Goodbye Michael"
and "Frank." That theme also continues in slight ambience during "Look
at Me." Vitally, the main theme is provided a fascinatingly soft, almost
haunted version in "Back to His Sister's Room," and the important,
propulsive duo of "Final Kill" and "Michael Answers" drives the
conclusion. If approaching
Halloween Kills on album for the first
time, the fuller 77-minute presentation is the much better
representation of the score. That said, none of the various album
options will convince you that anything's new or scary in this sequel,
however, the music and its creator potentially running out of
inspiration even if the body count mercilessly continues to climb.
** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download