The recording of the score was itself a nightmarish
part of the
Inchon production, the ensemble forced into a small
room under a church in Italy and rotating players over the course of a
haphazard month of recording in 1980. The lack of a proper facility
caused daunting restrictions for Goldsmith, especially with such a large
percussion section and the inability to sonically separate the group's
sections or eliminate copious, accidental room noise, but the composer
looked back at the experience as a generally positive challenge. The
composition itself is adequate in every one of its tasks but not
particularly memorable in any of them, either. Goldsmith did indeed try
to make the best of the situation by spicing up his ensemble with
creative percussion that dominates portions of the score. Also at play
is a significant depth of melody, with no less than four major ideas
intermingling regularly throughout the work. As such,
Inchon is a
relatively smooth listening experience. The main theme for the general
stirs up a fair amount of pomp but does not compete with Goldsmith's
material from
MacArthur. Its two major performances ("MacArthur's
Arrival" and "Inchon Theme") would make for worthy compilation material,
though it's rare to hear
Inchon anywhere else. A romantic melody
heard in "The Apology" and rearranged in "Love Theme" is a foreshadowing
of Goldsmith's
Legend and subsequent heartfelt ideas of the
1990's and is the highlight of the score. A theme for the martyr
character of Lim has just as poor an impact as Goldsmith's
representation for Inchon harbor; both could pass without notice for any
listener not closely deconstructing the work. The narrative arc of
Goldsmith's work isn't particularly enticing, the opening cues of the
work not clearly establishing the thematic core. The overall tone of the
score is predictably variable, with the composer taking little stylistic
chances in either the action or contemplative sequences. This
conservative approach, distinctive only because of its faint oriental
progressions at times, causes
Inchon to be a somewhat pedestrian
score. That said, the action sequences are raw and brutal in tone,
pounding away with almost too much volume compared to the rest of the
work.
On the whole,
Inchon remains a reasonably
competent but obscure footnote far below the composer's many superior
militaristic and dramatic efforts. Goldsmith rearranged the Italian
recordings into an LP presentation that is so jumbled and sliced that it
doesn't really resemble the film version, though it made for a more
interesting listening experience. A mock version of that arrangement was
reassembled by the composer and Intrada Records in 1988, with Goldsmith
making a few new changes for a 55-minute edition. In 2006, Intrada
revisited the music once again, presenting a very limited 2-CD album of
both the original LP arrangement and the complete score but without the
edits and minor truncations of the 1988 edits. That product sold out
quickly, however, prompting Intrada to re-press that set in identical
form in 2013 with no quantity limitations. Still, that product
eventually sold out as well, and the label, upon access to new sources
for the music, remastered the prior set's contents in 2020 and added the
actual film reconstruction without Goldsmith's preferred edits on a
third CD. That product notably focused on a high-resolution digital
download option as the main attraction while an extremely limited 3-CD
set of the same contents was intentionally available only for a matter
of weeks. A 2024 Intrada follow-up adds four early takes and edits the
complete score sequence to better isolate cues on the third CD.
Unfortunately, all of these albums, despite the best mastering
technology available in their times, could not salvage a recording that
featured major distortion, ambient studio sounds, player errors, and a
very flat soundscape. Some of these problems overlap; the love theme's
performance in "The Apology" has a swelling string sequence at about
1:14 that is cringe-worthy in its distorted wretchedness, nearly ruining
the cue. Performance flubs, such as the low brass errors in the latter
half of "The Scroll," don't help. In short,
Inchon sounds muddled
and disoriented regardless of remastering attempts, even compared to its
contemporary peers, and Intrada's dedication to realizing a
high-resolution option for this score rather than countless others in
its catalogue is baffling until you consider the label's long-standing
passion for the work regardless of its issues. This score badly needs a
full re-recording like that for
The Salamander to do it justice,
and in lieu of such treatment, only Goldsmith's most ardent collectors
should seek any of its album releases.
@Amazon.com: CD or
Download