 |
Powell |
 |
Glennie-Smith |
Just Visiting: (John Powell and Nick Glennie-Smith)
The monumental success of
Les Visiteurs in 1993 during the
concept's debut in its native France was long a target of translation
into the American market. After Miramax and Mel Brooks had terrible
difficulty dubbing the 1993 hit into English, Disney eventually
assembled most of the major cast and crew for a English-version remake
that stayed very true to the original but, in 2001, failed to muster
much magic at the box office. The concept of the misguidedly
time-traveling knight and the comedy and romance inherent in that plot
(and many others like it at the time) revealed themselves to be a
phenomenon unique to France. The nonsensical remake degraded the idea to
the level of dumb, American franchising. Despite these facts, a perfect
match was established between the production and the Media Ventures
composing buddies of John Powell and Nick Glennie-Smith. There was an
atmosphere so false and ridiculous about
Just Visiting that it is
fitting that the accompanying score is an auto-pilot Media Ventures
effort that, musically speaking, added nothing substantially new to the
careers of either composer. From the trailers, film music fans who
purchased this score without having seen the film might have assumed
that they were destined to hear another comedy routine of
Chicken
Run proportions (after all, that score remained one of the most
popular comedy works of the early 2000's). Unfortunately, while it
offers a few impressive passages and is generally listenable throughout,
Just Visiting is a less inspiring and cheaper sounding work. Less
enhanced by orchestral might and more entrenched in electronic samples
two generations away from the Hans Zimmer formula,
Just Visiting
goes through melodramatic motions without the instrumentation to really
make it work. Nevertheless, Powell and Glennie-Smith do go out of their
way to provide a score on paper that is likely far more impressive than
the film probably deserved.
In construct, the music is emotional at its base and
grandiose in stylistic intent. Both the heroic elements of the past and
the parody moments of the present are scored with the same over-the-top
sense of adventure, likely meant to heighten the comedic parts of the
modern day scenes. Even though Powell is clearly listed as seemingly the
only composer, a substantial portion of
Just Visiting was written
by Glennie-Smith, and it is his contribution to the score that often
introduces the needed orchestral performances of their compositional
ideas. Two other Media Ventures assistants contribute as well. The
augmentation with synthesizers is unfortunately present the most when
the score needs that tone the least, in the opening sequences of
centuries ago. These scenes in England are handled primarily with
synthesizers, with token harpsichord and solo woodwind mixes to add a
shallow element of locale to the music. The end result of these few cues
at the start of the film is a sound that is distractingly corny, which
may be appropriate given the ridiculous plot to follow. Once in modern
Chicago, the composers' talents with the synthesizers and guitars are
better utilized. The rhythmically grooving "Tub for Two" is the sole
standout comedy cue in the score, and its silliness is actually a
highlight of the album. This track may be more reflective of the film's
sense of humor, and yet it is surrounded by many somber cues of extended
minor key motifs. Several dramatically conceived cues in the score
present a sound that will appeal to fans of Zimmer's more melodramatic,
neo-classical works. The choral elements alternate between the
synthesized variety and the real thing (recorded in London). The latter
group's contribution is infrequent and the synthesized one is, after
five years of the same samples at the time, tired and overused. Parts of
Glennie-Smith's material has the same aural texture as his work for
The Man in the Iron Mask in 1998, a score which itself was
already sounding derivative.
Ironically, it is when Powell and Glennie-Smith
transfer the spirit of the score into the realm of pop rhythms that
Just Visiting begins to stir some interest. The love theme,
introduced appropriately in the past during a short, but lovely acoustic
guitar performance in "Rosaline and Thibault," matures into its modern
variant in "On the Bridge," where Powell combines the underlying
classical string progression with a modern rhythm that leads to a
satisfying combination of genres for the score. It's a simplistic
realization of what Patrick Doyle provided with more power for
Great
Expectations; in
Just Visiting, the same style is lacking in
romantic bite in key parts because of the weak depth of the recording.
Chicken Run, by comparison, featured stunning sound quality and
an incredible blend of orchestral and synthesized elements into one
remarkable package. The music for
Just Visiting doesn't sound as
crisp, often existing seemingly behind a wall, muting the performance to
an extent. Glennie-Smith's cues tend to have better ambience than
Powell's, for reasons that are difficult to pinpoint but likely can be
attributed to the balance of the mix. The lack of much reverberation
added to that mix causes the major themes to lose appeal. The love theme
discussed earlier reappears in less interesting forms in "Not a Bunny"
and "Julia Sees the Castle." The title theme, provided a glorious
performance in "The Hag's Hut" (though with a notable brass flub at
2:14), is revisited frequently throughout the score. While this theme
doesn't offer much in terms of enthusiasm, it is the one aspect that
ties this score together into a cohesive whole. The most obvious
detriments in
Just Visiting are those cues that rely so heavily
on sparse synthetics in stereotypical Media Ventures staccato rhythms
that they sound like a demo recording, including the "The Big Chase," a
badly underpowered cue. The song at the end of the album has a dance mix
that, for some reason, seems oddly appropriate as a title theme for a
1980's cartoon and is a poor match for the remainder of the material on
the product. On the whole,
Just Visiting is a marginally
enjoyable score that had promise in its conception, but deserved better
arrangements at almost every turn.
*** @Amazon.com: CD or
Download
Bias Check: |
For John Powell reviews at Filmtracks, the average editorial rating is 3.28
(in 50 reviews) and the average viewer rating is 3.16
(in 52,492 votes). The maximum rating is 5 stars.
|
The insert includes no extra information about the score or film.