PRINTER FRIENDLY VIEW
(inverts site colors)

The bulk of interesting material in Dark Fate relates to Holkenborg's admirable but not always successful establishment and continuation of the themes. Aside from the slurring motif for the evil terminator, two main ideas return from Fiedel's work. The primary, five-note rhythmic motif underlying the main theme is a fan favorite, replacing an ominous, less stylish four-note identity for the T-800 in the original film by Judgement Day. Holkenborg seems to tease the notion that this pounding, slapping five-note identity has shifted to Sarah by Dark Fate, a somewhat humorous but appropriate reassignment given her career spent as a bad-ass terminator hunter. But, in the end, the motif is applied as simply an affectionate representation of the whole franchise, heard at the crescendo of "Terminated," at 0:40 into "REV 9," and as the rhythm setter for the finale at "0:41" into "Epilogue" and throughout the end credits suite, "Dark Fate." The quick "Sunglasses" cue with the most obvious rendition of this rhythm for the T-800's near return to early form is missing from the album. The "Terminated" cue in particular is a massively missed opportunity to more closely connect with Fiedel's original ideas; while Holkenborg does revisit Fiedel's palette in this cue, which seems repeated in parts during the Sarah video flashbacks and the actual opening scene, the new score fails to provide the four-note or heartbeat effects from the franchise's origins, downplaying the connective horror of the sequences. More intriguing is how Holkenborg applies the main franchise theme. It remains tied primarily to Sarah, but not as impactfully as needed. Allusions at 3:22 into "C5" and 2:30 into "Terminator" are underplayed, and the composer only truly unleashes them in the closing trio of "For John," "Epilogue," and "Dark Fate." While its use in these later cues is quite impressive (certainly more than any of the other sequels, thankfully), it is distinctly disappointing that Holkenborg failed to offer at least echoes of this theme at the outset of the opening execution scene and during emotionally powerful conversational scenes involving Sarah talking about her past and, in particular, not having any photographs of John. The music in these scenes is either absent or dialed back, and it robs a vital chance to further develop this optimistic and determined but sad identity. This leaves the payoff performances for yet another T-800 sacrifice and the "driving off to destiny" scenes at the end, which work well enough to satisfy at the most basic level.

Of interesting note in Dark Fate is Holkenborg's decision to cut off the main theme before the final note of the fourth phrase, never allowing it resolve quite like it used to until "Epilogue." Instead, it shifts to a more triumphant tone in its new resolution. This choice makes sense, given Sarah's loss of family and identity, but it also makes the lack of the theme's original resolution at the outset of the opening scene an even greater waste. The "Dark Fate" suite instead cuts off literally the last descending note as it transitions into the Latin instrumentation to reflect the new, young heroine, Dani. Because of her Mexican heritage, her instrumental representation is shamelessly Latin in its acoustic guitar personality. Holkenborg starts her idea with the same rising three notes as Sarah's before meandering off into an unmemorable progression that doesn't stick in memory. The idea is introduced at 1:37 into "My Name is Dani," and the style of this performance occupies the planning scene in "Coyote." Sarah's theme merges with Dani's not surprisingly in the "Dark Fate" suite; among the more bizarre things to be heard is the acoustic guitar performance of Sarah's main theme with the Latin flair in this cue, this despite Fiedel's use of the instrument for Sarah's older self in the alternate Judgement Day epilogue. The more interesting but underplayed idea in the score exists for Grace, the enhanced human sent back to protect the target of this film. This character's depressing story arc is treated to a theme opposite in structure to Sarah and Dani's, two descending trios of notes leading the way at 0:26 and 1:37 into "Grace" and at 3:12 into "You Saved Me," a cue that offers some vague melodramatic extensions of the idea, it seems, but not obviously. It receives its catharsis late in the film, a choral and solo cello expression of lament for her own sacrifice at 2:47 into "For John" followed by a coda at 7:16 into that same cue. As the audience sees a young, blissfully unaware version of Grace in the contemporary timeline at the outset of "Epilogue," Holkenborg offers a surprisingly bleak and tepid rendition of the theme, not creatively providing the segue from the dead, older version of the woman to the younger one playing in park with some dramatic blend of melancholy but heart-warming optimism. It's in part because of poorly or underplayed cues like this one that the movie as a whole is such a downer. The theme for Grace, like the one for Dani, isn't as memorable as necessary because such passages needing more engaging music were either missed in the spotting or post-production phases.

There is irony in the fact that Dark Fate is more thematically developed that the three prior scores in the franchise, especially putting those by Marco Beltrami and Danny Elfman to shame, and yet the score's application of those ideas is simply amiss somehow. These movies and scores have always struggled to address the human drama element of the entire Terminator concept. The only composer to really nail this aspect was Lorne Balfe for Genisys, and Holkenborg tries to traverse the same path with less success. A touch of this Balfe character drama from the prior film exists in the strings early in "You Saved Me," and it seems too much of a coincidence that Holkenborg offers largely the same rising progressions and choral effect as Balfe at 3:49 into "For John" for a partially faceless T-800's heart-breaking sacrifice while restraining a superior terminator. It should be noted that the choral element in Dark Fate is badly undermixed; for most of the score, you can barely tell that it is even there, a problem that also existed in Genisys and seems senseless given that the fantasy element of the franchise could be well served by its greater presence. Overall, you have to commend Holkenborg for returning to Fiedel's established themes, samples, and modes. Enthusiasts of the franchise's vintage, metallic thrashing for action scenes will appreciate the bare and raw carnage that Dark Fate extends. Many casual moviegoers will also appreciate the better enunciation of the five-note concept rhythm of coolness and Sarah's main theme in the closing scenes. But the actual spotting, rendering, and placement of this score is oddly dissatisfying throughout. There are better fan-made tributes to Fiedel's original material than what we hear from a composer paid significant money to produce generally the same thing, and Balfe's arrangement of the Judgement Day end titles remains superior. On album, the score's weaknesses are exposed to a far greater degree than in the film. A CD version from La-La Land records is limited to 3,000 copies and suggests in its track listing that only the final two cues use Fiedel's main theme even though this is very much not the case. (The label must have had to omit instances in which Holkenborg doesn't complete more than three phrases of the theme, which is silly.) The ills of this score are closely tied to those of the film, the lack of satisfying development and closure for existing themes matching the all-too-few interactions between Sarah and the T-800 in this story. This franchise needed to conclude with Sarah on that park bench in Cameron's alternate ending of Judgement Day, for all the films and music that followed in the concept have failed to truly capture our hearts and ears.  ***   @Amazon.com: CD or Download

Bias Check:

For Tom Holkenborg reviews at Filmtracks, the average editorial rating is 2.16 (in 19 reviews) and the average viewer rating is 2.49 (in 6,100 votes). The maximum rating is 5 stars.

Total Time: 57:57