Glisten Effect
Editorial Reviews
Scoreboard Forum
Viewer Ratings
Composers
Awards
   NEWEST MAJOR REVIEWS:
     1. Superman (2025)
    2. Jurassic World Rebirth
   3. F1
  4. M3GAN 2.0
 5. Elio
6. How to Train Your Dragon (2025)


   CURRENT BEST-SELLING SCORES:
       1. Top Gun (2-CD)
      2. Avatar: The Way of Water
     3. The Wild Robot
    4. Gladiator (3-CD)
   5. Young Woman and the Sea
  6. Spider-Man 2 (3-CD)
 7. Cutthroat Island (2-CD)
8. Willow (2-CD)
   CURRENT MOST POPULAR REVIEWS:
         1. Spider-Man
        2. Alice in Wonderland
       3. The Matrix
      4. Gladiator
     5. Wicked
    6. Batman (1989)
   7. Raiders of the Lost Ark
  8. The Wild Robot
 9. Beetlejuice Beetlejuice
10. Doctor Strange: Multiverse
Home Page
Archives:   2000-2006 | 2006-2015 | 2015-2021
Menu Options ▼

Edit | Delete
Re: Zimmer & friends pt 10a - TBTF 2020: BB3, Call of the Wild, 48 rejected score
Profile Image
• Posted by: Riley KZ   <Send E-Mail>
• Date: Saturday, February 11, 2023, at 9:24 a.m.
• IP Address: ip-104-224-113-101.xplore.ca
• In Response to: Zimmer & friends pt 10a - TBTF 2020: BB3, Call... (JBlough)

> This is part of a series.
> - Here’s the last post on The Lion King, Dark Phoenix, etc.
> - https://www.filmtracks.com/scoreboard/forum.cgi?read=119950
> - If you want the full set of links covering the Too Big To Fail era or
> earlier, click on my profile.

> -----------------------

> One would think getting into the final run of years in this era (2020,
> 2021, 2022, and early 2023) would mean having to spend a few paragraphs
> talking about the impacts of the COVID-19 pandemic. We’ll get there, but
> there were a number of works by this musical lineage in 2020 that merit
> discussion first:

> - Five were for films released in the first few months of that year when
> things still seemed normal

> - Another was for a film that had its premiere in March 2020 but ended up
> reaching audiences via a fall streaming release

> - One was for a film that had a festival showing in fall 2019 before
> ending up on VOD services in late 2020

> - Another was for a film that was shown at Sundance in early 2020 before
> ending up in virtual cinemas in summer 2020

> - Four were for 2020 films / shows that had no release pre-pandemic but
> likely had their scores completed before then

> - One was an album of concert suites that were probably recorded before
> the pandemic

> There’s also Mosul which was first shown at the 2019 Venice Film
> Festival before ending up on Netflix around Thanksgiving 2020, but Henry
> Jackman’s music (which he characterized as being cut from the same cloth
> as what he did for Captain Philips) didn’t get an album release.
> There were also several scores that I’ve confirmed had all or nearly all
> of their music completed in 2019 or early 2020 but sat on the shelf until
> March 2021 or later, and I’ll cover those in future posts along with all
> the other scores that were composed and recorded during/after the
> pandemic.

> -----------------------

> The Rhythm Section (2020) - **½
> Steve Mazzaro; produced by Hans Zimmer; add’l music by Lisa Gerrard;
> sequencer programming Omer Benyamin; technical score engineer Chuck Choi;
> technical assistants Steve Doar & Alejandro Moros; digital instrument
> design Mark Wherry;
> digital instrument preparation Taurees Habib & Raul Vega; Cynthia Park
> as Zimmer’s assistant

> TBTF discovery #73.

> This action film would be delayed numerous times and eventually limp into
> theaters to impressively low box office returns. Another composer was
> likely on it at the start; Adam Taylor had worked with director Reed
> Morano on her two prior films and episodes of The Handmaid’s Tale,
> and there’s an unconfirmed rumor that David Arnold was involved at some
> point. But Steve Mazzaro was announced as its composer two months before
> its release date, probably doing a last-minute “save the movie”
> replacement job. It certainly wasn’t the first time that Hans or someone
> else associated with this musical lineage (or a junior composer overseen
> by Hans, as was the case here) was brought in under such circumstances.
> Heck, by my count it was the forty-eighth such instance as of January
> 2020.*

> His score teeters on the edge of incoherence, as all of the Zimmer eras
> (the early years, MV, RC, and Too Big To Fail) inform different areas.
> Some chord shifts suggest the keyboard scores of Hans’ earlier years. The
> tension in Take The Contract recalls Interstellar but with
> Lisa Gerrard on top of it, while other passages with Gerard’s voice play
> more like her Media Ventures contributions. The track Marseille
> starts out feeling like Black Hawk Down and ends up thumping like
> Dunkirk. Mombasa from Inception lurks over the action
> piece Hunting. There are also nervous violin solos and even several
> tracks that allude to the midfilm Scotland sequences, with the
> album-closing piece Journey a stellar example of that latter
> element.

> Barbara Broccoli and Michael G. Wilson were producers on this film, and
> before it came out they brought in Hans and Steve to salvage the music of
> another one of their upcoming releases, though after they finished their
> re-score on that other film it would be shelved for more than a year
> thanks to COVID.

> *Here’s the list
> Completely replaced
> 1. Regarding Henry - Georges Delerue
> 2. K2 (European release) - Chaz Jankel
> 3. Point of No Return - Gary Chang
> 4. White Squall - Maurice Jarre
> 5. Face/Off - Mark Isham
> 6. Tarzan - Alan Silvestri
> 7. Remember the Titans - John Debney
> 8. Rat Race - Elmer Bernstein
> 9. Texas Rangers - Marco Beltrami
> 10. The Bourne Identity - Carter Burwell

> 11. Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of the Black Pearl - Alan
> Silvestri
> 12. Something’s Gotta Give - Alan Silvestri
> 13. Phone Booth - Nathan Larson
> 14. Team America: World Police - Marc Shaiman
> 15. Hitman (2007) - unknown
> 16. TMNT - Marco Beltrami
> 17. Clash of the Titans (2010) - Craig Armstrong & Neil Davidge
> 18. Game of Thrones Season 1 - Stephen Warbeck
> 19. Arthur Christmas - Michael Giacchino & Adam Cohen
> 20. Planes - James Seymour Brett

> 21. 300: Rise of an Empire - Federico Jusid
> 22. CHAPPiE - Ryan Amon, Chris Clark & Rich Walters
> 23. Terminator Genisys - Christophe Beck
> 24. Pan - Dario Marianelli
> 25. Money Monster - Michael Andrews
> 26. The Legend of Tarzan - Mario Grigorov
> 27. Hacksaw Ridge - John Debney
> 28. The Crown Season 1 - Paul Englishby
> 29. Geostorm - Pinar Toprak
> 30. Blade Runner 2049 - Jóhann Jóhannsson

> 31. Pacific Rim: Uprising - John Paesano
> 32. Gemini Man - Marco Beltrami
> 33. No Time To Die - Dan Romer

> Replaced except for source music
> 34. Ella Enchanted - Shaun Davey
> 35. The Lone Ranger - Jack White

> Mostly replaced
> 36. Gears of War 2 - Kevin Riepl

> Partially replaced
> 37. White Fang - Basil Poledouris
> 38. Secret Window - Philip Glass
> 39. Constantine (2005) - Brian Tyler
> 40. Ghost in the Shell (2017) - Clint Mansell
> 41. Christopher Robin - Jon Brion
> 42. Ad Astra - Max Richter

> Partially replaced - Harry/Ridley section
> 43. Prometheus - Marc Streitenfeld
> 44. Exodus: Gods and Kings - Alberto Iglesias & Federico Jusid

> Not enough known to classify properly
> 45. Blade: Trinity - The RZA
> 46. Wallace and Gromit: The Curse of the Were-Rabbit - Julian Nott
> 47. Fast & Furious 6 - Lucas Vidal

Way too harsh on Rhythm Section, which I thought was an excellent action score that went surprising directions I didn't expect.

>
>
> Bad Boys for Life (2020) - ***
> Lorne Balfe; add’l music by Steffen Thum, Max Aruj, Steven Davis &
> Sven Faulconer; orchestrated by Shane
> Rutherfoord-Jones; conducted by Nick Glennie-Smith; music production
> services Queenie Li; drums Sheila E.

> TBTF discovery #74.

> The Bad Boys franchise is a great exhibit for the increasingly
> divergent musical preferences of its makers. The first inaugurated the
> Media Ventures action sound under Jerry Bruckheimer, while the sequel
> released eight years later was the prototypical example of the rap / rock
> coolness director Michael Bay looked for on many of his future scores.
> Only Bruckheimer returned for the long-awaited third film, and thus the
> music swung back to his preferred style and his preferred composer Lorne
> Balfe, who got a massive return on investment for doing those last-minute
> replacement scores for Geostorm and Gemini Man. Lorne
> couldn’t resist another opportunity to reinterpret another composer’s
> iconic idea, in this case Mancina’s from the first film. “Every one of
> my friends who’s not musical remembers it. It's definitely coming
> back.” He would also convincingly reproduce the legacy 90s Bruckheimer
> sound by evoking not just Bad Boys but The Rock as well.
> Lorne’s score was a fun dose of nostalgia, though the job would be
> somewhat bittersweet as the composer had to step away to take care of his
> sick father back in Scotland. “If it hadn’t been for my team, I
> wouldn’t have finished.”

I'd probably give it 3.5/5. Damn fun stuff.

>
>
> Rebuilding Paradise (2020) - ***
> Hans Zimmer & Lorne Balfe; add’l music by Boris Salchow, Peter G.
> Adams, Max
> Aruj & Steffen Thum; technical Music Assistants Michael Bitton, Alfie
> Godfrey & Mike
> Ladouceur; technical score engineer Chuck Choi; digital instrument design
> Mark Wherry;
> digital instrument preparation Taurees Habib & Raul Vega; electric
> cello Peter Gregson;
> electric violin Eos Counsell; guitar Michael Bitton; RC studio manager
> Shalini Singh;
> music production coordinator Queenie Li; Cynthia Park as Zimmer’s
> assistant

> TBTF discovery #75.

> Debuting at Sundance in January 2020, Ron Howard’s acclaimed documentary
> about California’s 2018 Camp Fire disaster had its release delayed by
> COVID before eventually emerging via a mix of traditional theaters,
> drive-ins, and video on demand (VOD) services. It was a rare documentary
> assignment for both credited composers, and the mix of the format and the
> tragic topic covered led the team to go for a slightly understated
> approach, one made up of slow chord shifts, somber but unemotive strings
> and piano, and solo instrumental accents (both acoustic and electronic).
> Lorne would characterize the film as needing “less is more. As soon as
> you go into the usual film scoring, where you’re trying to enhance every
> emotion, you’re turning it into a Hollywood moment.” The album gives
> off an appropriate sense of restrained perseverance, save for the exultant
> One Year Anniversary which plays like a hybrid of Zimmer’s early
> days and his melodic minimalistic present.
>
>
> Jungleland (2020) - ****
> Lorne Balfe; score technical assistant Max Aruj; orchestrated by Shane
> Rutherfoord-Jones;
> conducted by Johannes Vogel; music production coordinator Queenie Li

> TBTF discovery #76.

> Lorne’s role on this underground boxing picture was announced in August
> 2019, a month before the film’s premiere at the Toronto Film Festival,
> with the film eventually getting a limited theatrical release in November
> 2020 before moving to VOD services. Director Max Winkler didn’t want the
> music to reflect the grimness of the characters’ situation because “I
> don’t think these guys see their circumstances as depressing. I wanted our
> horns to reflect this optimist despite everyone telling him he should
> stop.” Balfe’s score was worlds away from anything he’d ever written
> for films, something much more reliant on wistful flute parts, restrained
> folk modes, and noble brass chorales that sounded nothing like Remote
> Control and instead suggested a melancholy-yet-hopeful hybrid of Aaron
> Copland and Philip Glass, as well as Renaissance composer William Byrd (a
> favorite of the director) on in its final album track. \

I think I liked both of these...? Don't remember them at all.

>
>
> The Call of the Wild (2020) - *****
> John Powell; add’l music & arrangements by Batu Sener & Paul
> Mounsey;
> orchestrated by John Ashton Thomas, Mark Graham, Andrew Kinney, Randy
> Kerber,
> Rick Giovinazzo, Pete Anthony, Jon Kull & Jeff Atmajian; conducted by
> John Powell

> The umpteenth adaptation of Jack London’s famed dog-centric adventure
> novel ended up being one of the last films produced by 20th Century Fox
> before its acquisition by Disney and thus became the first film released
> under Disney’s 20th Century Studios banner. Audiences seemed indifferent
> to the film, perhaps because its trailers suggested the movie had trotted
> into the uncanny valley by relying a lot on CGI animals for its episodic
> storytelling, and COVID lockdowns setting in a few weeks after its release
> dampened its long-term box office prospects. But John Powell suggested
> there were plenty of other challenges with getting it to the finish line
> anyway. “There were reshoots, and then the animation wasn’t finished.
> We made a lot of changes near the end. It was going to have a lot less
> dialogue than it ended up with, but it was the end of Fox, they got a bit
> frightened and added more and more dialogue.” At least the film was a
> nice way for Powell to reunite with director Chris Sanders who’d co-helmed
> the first How To Train Your Dragon, though Powell had a feeling
> that if Alan Silvestri hadn’t been tied up with work on Avengers:
> Endgame in 2019 that Sanders might’ve elected to work with him instead
> as he’d used Silvestri on his prior film The Croods.

> The story was an expansive, turn-of-the-century yarn, and Powell responded
> with something in the fantastical-yet-personal style of his Dragon
> scores coupled with an attempt at recreating the sound of the frontier
> without drifting into cowboy territory. “It’s a normal score, but I did
> introduce some fun instruments. If you get into the question of ‘what is
> American music,’ it’s influenced by Copland, who was very influenced by
> Shaker hymns and the orchestration of Debussy and Ravel. But that’s a
> little bit more Western than what we wanted. We are in the Yukon, not the
> prairies. I like the idea that everyone who went to that area of the world
> at that particular time was an immigrant, so I was really open to any kind
> of music. There are accordions, tin whistles, Irish flutes, a small
> ensemble of harmoniums, an ensemble of 12 banjos who also played mandolins
> and guitars. I wouldn’t say I tried to make it sound terribly American -
> even though there are banjos in it, they weren’t playing bluegrass, they
> were playing things you would perhaps get out of Ireland.” There was
> some novelty in 2020 to hearing such large-scale, folk-inflected adventure
> music since it really hadn’t resurfaced much since Basil Poledouris was
> writing such scores in the 1980s and 1990s.

> Coupled with all that would be the same densely orchestrated, explosively
> entertaining material that Powell had been consistently delivering over
> the last decade-plus. Coming on the heels of The Hidden World,
> Solo, Ferdinand, Pan, and How To Train Your Dragon
> 2, perhaps this approach was a tad too familiar for some listeners,
> never mind the absurdly sky-high expectations Powell had created for his
> work by this point. But many others, including me, found it a profound
> score with thrills and wonder in abundance, one chock-full of catchy
> themes, unique instrumentation, and mesmerizing moments of musical
> storytelling, perhaps none better than the mid-album track Buck Takes
> The Lead which found Powell operating near the peak of his celebratory
> music powers and was for my money the best piece of scoring that year.
> “He's taken over the sled and is now the leader and realizes that he
> has this and everyone respects him. I do love it when I can be
> joyful.” On a more personal note, it came out around the time I first
> skied in Whistler, which made an awesome mountain even more awesome and
> deepened my appreciation for the music, and it has become a reliable go-to
> album for solo skiing in the years since.

> As of this writing, this is the last film score he’s done in this
> adventurous style that he’d essentially perfected in the 2010s. Powell
> isn’t semi-retired as some have speculated, but as he nears 60 he has
> become more choosy about what he signs on to. The project he was planning
> to do after this was an opera with his old friend Gavin Greenaway, and his
> few COVID-era scores have been for decidedly different films with
> decidedly different musical needs than The Call of the Wild had - a
> crime film requiring only 12 minutes of score, a thriller, and a
> documentary. If The Call of the Wild ends up being the last such
> Powell composition, it was a heck of a way to go out. To quote this film,
> what an adventure.

Just relistened to this one a few days ago and yep, it still holds up as one of the best scores of the new decade.

>
>
> Film Suites Vol. 1 (2020) - ****½
> John Powell; performed by The Philharmonia Orchestra & Voices;
> conducted by José Serebrier

> The adventure would in fact continue a bit over the 2020 holidays, around
> which time Powell’s record label would release an album of concert suites
> of some of his film music performed by the orchestra that had premiered
> his Prussian Requiem a few years earlier. Powell had been talking
> about the concept publicly since at least 2014, right around when he was
> taking his sabbatical for that aforementioned oratorio. He’d even mused
> about radically reinterpreting some of them, namely Face/Off which
> he didn’t end up covering here, but the end product would largely play
> like a faithful orchestral and choral concert performance of his film
> arrangements. It definitely skimps on the quirkier side of Powell’s
> writing for films, and one could question if we really needed five whole
> minutes of Assassin’s Tango from Mr. & Mrs. Smith in the
> program, but for the most part it was a tremendously entertaining overview
> of many of Powell’s musical highlights from the last twentyish years,
> including a delightful performance of the playful The Great Tree
> from Endurance which was likely how many Powell fans discovered
> that underheard 1999 score even existed in the first place. Here’s hoping
> a second volume emerges in the near term.

> -----------------------

> Next time: “Flower power sounds.”

That sentence makes me think of the finale to 40 Year Old Virgin.

Anyhoo, great write up as always!




Messages in this Thread:     Expand >>


Copyright © 1998-2025, Filmtracks Publications. All rights reserved.
The reviews and other textual content contained on the filmtracks.com site may not be published, broadcast,
rewritten or redistributed without the prior written authority of Christian Clemmensen at Filmtracks Publications. Scoreboard created 7/24/98 and last updated 4/25/15.
Filmtracks takes no responsibility for any offense or mental trauma caused by this forum. Behold the Scoreboard motto to better understand why this party is relentlessly trolled.