Posted by: My Name Is Tim <Send E-Mail> Date: Thursday, March 12, 2009, at 5:27 p.m. IP Address: adsl-75-60-91-154.dsl.sndg02.sbcglobal.net
In Response to:
Clemmensen is an idiot(Rick R)
> Anyone who knows anything about film music has figured out that Benjamin
> Button is one of top five of the year. Except for Clemmensen, who needs
> much more professional training before his opinion can be taken seriously.
Now wait a minute. While it may be in 2008's Top 5, those 5 were all 3 star efforts when you look out the bigger window of 10-15 years of modern film music.
And if you compare Desplat's scores from 2001 to Now, you can tell Benjamin Button is somewhere in the middle.
I would also agree with a 4 star rating for Bejamin. But because of the cheap soft paper packaging the score comes in, I would take away a star from the package as a whole. Perhaps thats what Clemmensen did.