> This is a true five star score and one of only four JW masterpieces in the
> last 18 years and one of those was Harry Potter 3 which you failed to
> understand...

> Nowadays compared between other film scores War Horse would be six stars
> and even compared inbetween John Williams scores this is a five star
> masterpiece!

> But i nevert expected a fair review from you, i mean you gave AotC and
> Presumed Innocent five stars and Harry Potter 3 only four!!!
> How can you be so wrong after that many years of score reviews...

thanks for posting this comment its the best comment ive read regarding CC's failure to understand the score ,and let me ask this how the hell he reviews a FILM score without watching the actual film and hearing the music in context??? why wont he change the sites name to tracks.com
believe me its not his only failure throw out the years here are some examples: overrating horner way too much, unwilling to review groundbreaking masterpieces just because he ((and only he)) thinks they are old such as the good, the bad and the ugly,if the score has a major march theme its a five stars else its ordinary such as memoirs of geisha and the list goes on and on
CC has failed big time and that's gonna be his downfall